Alle verhalen

Nooit doorgegaan voor man, en vrienden die iets anders zeiden

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd1,1K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich nu identificeert als mannelijke lesbienne. Ik ben direct na de middelbare school getransitioneerd na een kindertijd van dysforie, depressie en onbehandeld autisme, geworteld in een conservatieve opvoeding en geïnternaliseerde haat tegen vrouw zijn, maar ik ging nooit door voor man en werd geschaad door vrienden die erover tegen me logen. Testosteron gaf me waarschijnlijk blijvende hartproblemen (ritmestoornissen, inspanningsintolerantie) en haaruitval, en ik ben sindsdien gestopt met hormonen zonder een operatie te hebben gehad. Ik detransitioneerde door de mensen die me aanmoedigden af te snijden, na te denken over de wortels van mijn dysforie en een autismediagnose te krijgen, en hoewel ik nog dysforie heb, ben ik meer in vrede en in therapie. Ik ben kritisch op hoe transitie wordt gepusht zonder de grondoorzaken te onderzoeken en op het vieren van dysforie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and grew up in a conservative, fairly isolated background where the only image of women I ever saw was the submissive housewife type — women were neither masculine nor gay, and the little anti-gay propaganda I received was directed only at gay men. Because of that, the idea of being a lesbian or a masculine female was completely new to me, so my mind went straight to wanting to be a heterosexual male, which was easy given how much internalized hatred I had of being female. I had dysphoria from a very young age — I'd say around 10, before I even hit puberty — and I was suicidally depressed by age 9. I wanted to be reborn as male, to grow up as a boy, to have my interests encouraged because I was male, to finish high school and go into college and the workplace as a man. I also had autism from a young age but was never diagnosed until adulthood, because girls don't get diagnosed often. A lot of my bodily dysphoria came from sensory issues connected to my autism combined with my female body — I really disliked a lot of sensations, and a few of them combined with being female made me loathe my body immensely. I always saw it as gender dysphoria, especially combined with other struggles I had with being a woman. My gender therapists never picked up on the autism or the depression. I was very miserable in childhood, which led to the dysphoria, but nobody asked. They just pushed me to transition. They never talked about my homosexuality or internalized homophobia either. Honestly, I just wanted to be a straight man — I didn't want to be gay anymore and I didn't want to be a woman anymore — but nobody discussed it. None of my friends in the LGBT communities ever talked about it either, which is crazy since a lot of the women transitioning were butch lesbians or victims of sexism. It's like they didn't care why. I transitioned fresh out of high school. I was on testosterone for a while and attempted to pass, wearing a binder all the time and using makeup to enhance facial hair I grew out. But I never passed in real life. Around my liberal friends they would use male pronouns and my chosen male name, and if I asked, they'd insist I passed and that I WAS a man. Outside of them, nobody knew I was transitioning — people complimented me on being a woman with muscles and assumed I was a woman with facial hair. My friends were lying to try to increase their chances with me, and it made me furious since passing was something I struggled with so much. The worst was when male liberals would hit on me with "so I'm not usually attracted to men, but...". It was humiliating and it was probably the worst dysphoria I've ever had — knowing I could never be a man came crashing down. Using men's rooms made me cry because I knew I didn't pass and they were all lying to me; it was a relief to use women's rooms again. Hormones gave me serious health problems. I developed heart problems — arrhythmias and a very fast heart rate — and I have to monitor my heart rate constantly, avoid strenuous activity, and rest going up stairs. I'm at high risk for a heart attack despite being fit and young, and there's no history of heart disease in my family and no signs before this. I'm still undergoing tests; it's been a few years with no improvement, so they think it may be permanent, though my heart issues have slowly improved slightly. I also had hair loss (which they said would reverse but hasn't yet) and skin problems. I was told over and over there are no side effects, which was a lie. I also miss testosterone in some ways — I had a lot more energy — but the health issues may have killed me if I'd stayed on it. I never went through with surgery. What moved me toward detransition was realizing I would never be able to be a man, truly, not in the way I'd pictured growing up. Transition wasn't the answer — what I was becoming wasn't a man but some altered form of a woman. It wouldn't take back my female socialization, it wouldn't erase the shitty things I went through on account of my sex, I wouldn't get back the school days I missed from my period, I wouldn't have my family love me more for being born male, I wouldn't have had the household chores my brothers didn't have. I couldn't have children of my own, I'd be on hormones my whole life, I'd still need mammograms (my grandma and aunt died of breast cancer). It wasn't going to work. The first thing I did was cut off all the liberal friends who had lied to me about transition — since they were gone it was easier to clear my head and reflect. I asked myself all the questions no therapist or friend ever bothered to ask: why did I have dysphoria, where did it come from. A lot of reflection helped me come to terms with it. I wish I'd had the detrans subreddit when I decided; I thought I was alone. I also got an autism diagnosis later in life from a specialist where I deliberately never mentioned dysphoria. I'm still in therapy and it helps, though I have to choose my words very carefully — the instant I let the idea of dysphoria slip, therapists want to push me to transition, even knowing I've detransitioned before and have medical records showing the side effects. Nobody treated my actual mental illness. Now I identify as a masculine lesbian. Living as a masculine woman and identifying as a lesbian is the most relief I've had from the dysphoria. I still have dysphoria but it's so much better now that I'm not trying to treat it by transitioning, and I'm more at peace — I recognize it's a struggle like anything else, something I have to endure; I'm just a different woman, not a man. I'm still recovering from side effects; mostly I'm back to normal but I'm afraid some may stick around. I'm currently in a male-dominated career, which would have been impossible in the culture I was raised in, and being around women who are their own person has helped me feel better about being female. I've had luck improving my dysphoria by spending time around gay women and butch friends. I'm still, in my own words, "just a miserable woman" at times, but going to therapy and continuing to improve. I have complicated feelings about the trans community. I'm glad I was fairly isolated from it when I started so I missed most of the peer pressure, and it makes me fear for young people today. I get tempted to go back if I spend too much time among trans people, so I don't anymore. I find it frustrating that detransitioners are told we were never really trans, or that we're trans right now because we have dysphoria, or that we have a "male brain" — the goalposts keep moving. I think many people transition for trivial reasons and should go to therapy instead. I'm critical of celebrating dysphoria and of medical professionals who push transition without investigating root causes like autism, depression, sexism, or internalized homophobia. I do think there are gender critical, radfem-friendly trans people who are nice and supportive, and I'd welcome them in mixed spaces, though I wouldn't want trans woman allies in female-exclusive spaces. I've also posted about how male attention and harassment cause dysphoria for many women, and I've pushed back on sexist posts in detrans spaces. I initially detransitioned partly for what I now consider the wrong reasons, but I'm happier now.