Alle verhalen

Een gendertherapeut die is gedesisteerd, en nu aandringt op betere beoordeling

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd75
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gendertherapeut die narratieve therapie als voornaamste methode gebruikt en die me eerder als non-binair identificeerde maar nu onverschillig ben over vrouw/vrouwelijk zijn, en ik ben niet trans. Ik pleit voor strengere beoordelingsnormen en regelgeving vóór medische transitie, terwijl ik het respectvolle gebruik van het woord „vrouw” door transmensen steun via een koepeltermkader. Ik heb zorgen geuit over een „incel-naar-transvrouw-pijplijn” en het misbruik van transterminologie. In dit transcript heb ik geen medische transitie, medische voorgeschiedenis van detransitie of operaties beschreven. Ik blijf actief in de detransitiegemeenschap in een ondersteunende, professionele rol.

Volledig verhaal

I am a gender therapist who works extensively with LGBTQIA+ folks in all stages of their journey, and the moderators verified me with my license to get my flair in this community. I use narrative therapy as my primary modality — it is the core of the work I do with folks. I describe it as focusing on semantics and reframing the language we use, for example changing 'People hate me' to 'I feel like no one likes me but that's also just a feeling,' or reframing 'I'm lazy' to 'I struggle with a mental illness and am frustrated that I can't do more.' The idea is to acknowledge the emotion while being truthful to yourself without lies or assumptions, and to recognize your own truth and who gets to know it. On my own gender history: I used to identify as non-binary, but I am now just indifferent to being female/woman. I am not trans. I have described myself as female and noted that my voice is naturally lower than the stereotypical feminine voice. I have not described any medical transition, hormones, or surgeries in this transcript. I agreed when given permission to comment in this detransition community that I would not take up space or talk over those who are detransitioning, and I said that if any comment of mine was even a toe out of line, a mod should boot me and I would delete it and understand. On the substance of transition and assessment, I have argued that society really needs across-the-board regulations and procedures for giving people the go-ahead on these things, because the patient runs a very serious physical and emotional risk if they aren't properly assessed. I noted that without guidelines, a professional has to weigh their license (as happened with what I called a 'crappy no assessment SW') versus being labelled as transphobic and no one wanting to work with them — while emphasizing the professional's risk is much lower in terms of life-long consequences. I explained that WPATH exists but is extremely costly and drawn out for a clinician to take on for no real benefit for most of them, because docs don't even care anymore if you're certified; if a social worker okays it then the liability falls on them, not the surgeon, legally speaking. I have commented on the 'incel to transwoman pipeline' as a common thread I hope there will be more research on, while cautioning 'not all transwomen' but saying they have been overrun with those who may be misunderstanding or misusing trans terminology. I loved an analogy comparing 'woman' to the colloquial term for female (mare, hen, sow, cow), saying 'Woman is just the colloquial term for female!' I also used an umbrella metaphor: 'man' and 'woman' are umbrella terms, with 'trans(wo)men' and 'cis(wo)men' underneath. I told someone 'You will never be a ciswoman. But you can still call yourself woman,' comparing it to sage, forest, olive, and lime all being 'green.' I clarified that female/male are clearly defined and are *not* umbrella terms, but I believe 'woman' could be colloquially adapted to mean either ciswoman or transwoman. I have advised someone on disclosing trans status, saying the first priority is safety — if outing yourself is dangerous, no decent person will fault you for lying. Otherwise I suggested considering whether they're comfortable lying and being caught, saying 'none of your business,' or 'Yeah I'm trans but I don't talk about it.' I recommended having a gender-emphasized therapist to work through acceptance dysphoria, saying awareness of reality and acceptance are two different things, and that I don't think it's morbid but hope they stay around and try to live in any way that makes them even a little more comfy. I also explained that a clinic asking for ID to release records is a HIPAA liability cover, and that they won't care about where you're at now on your (de)transition.