Alle verhalen

Twijfelen in een ruimte die dat niet toestond

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd234
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die als man leefde en me nu als vrouw identificeert ongeacht hoe ik me presenteer. Ik zet publiekelijk geen volledige medische tijdlijn uiteen, maar heb uitgebreid geschreven over hoe sociale besmetting, invloed van leeftijdsgenoten, lichaamsdysmorfie, BPS-gerelateerde identiteitsverwarring en een twijfel-vijandige transactivistische omgeving mijn pad vormden. Ik ging van links naar het midden politiek door hoe ik werd behandeld omdat ik twijfels uitte. Nu raad ik anderen aan helemaal te stoppen met nadenken over gender, niet-bevestigende therapie voor lichaamsbeeld te zoeken en te overwegen dat ze gendernonconformistisch kunnen zijn in plaats van trans. Ik geloof dat jongeren wel meegesleept worden in sociale besmetting en dat de transgemeenschap meer gerespecteerd zou worden als ze dat zou toegeven.

Volledig verhaal

I have spent the last several months on r/detrans reading other people's stories and replying to them, and my own history with gender is something I've thought about a lot while doing that. I don't have a full medical timeline of my own to lay out here, because most of what I've written publicly has been advice to others rather than a step-by-step account of myself — but the shape of it is clear to me. I transitioned and lived as a man. People who have posted their before-and-after photos have told me I looked female even when I was presenting as a man, and I've said the same thing back to others — that they look female in both pictures, that they were not beautiful as an FTM. I know what that experience of looking in the mirror and seeing something that doesn't match is like from the other side. I went from what I'd describe as left wing to more of a middle ground politically over the course of this, and I think that shift happened because of how I was treated when I started asking questions. The thing I keep coming back to is how hostile the environment was to anyone who questioned me at the time. I know from my own experience that if someone had tried to talk sense into me, I would have called them every type of "phobic" under the sun. I put up a hell of a fight. I've written that to people here more than once, because I think it's the central problem: no one dares to question young people for fear of being called transphobic, and trans activists accuse every critical person of being an intolerant bigot. When people are in what I now call the trans delusion, they will not tolerate any suggestions of waiting. People are told they have to support and affirm your gender identity, and if we don't, we're labeled right wing nazis. I also think about social contagion and peer influence honestly. I've asked others what made them feel the need to copy their friends, and whether it was just teenage rebellion — because I suspect something similar was operating for me. I've said plainly that the trans community would be respected more if they admitted young people do get caught up in social contagion. I don't think the people around me were teasing me when they expressed confusion about gender ideology; I think they were genuinely confused, because for most people it is very strange. I've also thought a lot about how mental health and body image feed into this. I've told people with BPD that it is VERY common to feel unsettled and confused about personal identity, and that they should seek real medical help rather than change anything radically while in that state. I've recommended therapy for body dysmorphia specifically — not necessarily an affirming therapist — to explore why particular characteristics appeal to someone. I've told people that a lot of women are uncomfortable with our bodies, especially in a society that sexualises them, and that pressure on women to look a certain way is the reason so many women end up on testosterone. I believe those beauty standards are bullshit. I've also raised, with others, the possibility that what they're experiencing is a fetish or sexuality issue rather than a gender issue — that you can be gay, or have a fetish, without letting it take over your life. And I've raised the role of family and cultural background: I noticed one person came from a Muslim family and asked whether Islam's strict gender roles might be influencing them, and whether they might simply be a gender non-conforming man who, because of their upbringing, believes that makes them a woman. I told them there is nothing wrong with being a man with more feminine traits, and that it takes radical acceptance to get comfortable with that. My general advice to people in the thick of it is to stop thinking about gender at all for a while — do hobbies you like, eat good food, walk for up to an hour a day. You are you no matter how you present to the world, and you need a healthy frame of mind before making big decisions. I'd suggest doing nothing in regards to gender in the moment. I don't currently identify as trans. I'm a detransitioned person who now thinks of herself as female regardless of presentation, and I'm skeptical of how transition is being offered to young people today.