Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als man geboren, identificeerde me ongeveer vijf jaar als transvrouw, begon op mijn 17e met hormonen en detransitioneerde op mijn 20e na drie jaar oestrogeen. Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde homoseksuele man. De hormonale veranderingen keerden goed terug: testosteron kwam vanzelf terug in het hoog-normale bereik, de genitale functie herstelde en uiteindelijk kwam ook het sperma terug, en in 2023 had ik een mastectomie. De detransitie gaf veel angst over zichtbaar queer zijn en het gebruik van herentoiletten, en ik verloor mijn beste vriend, maar mijn zelfvertrouwen en levenskwaliteit verbeterden en ik heb een steunende relatie met een man. Nu heb ik sterk kritische opvattingen over transitie, die ik als waanvoorstelling omschrijf, en ik pleit ervoor in plaats daarvan genderonconformiteit te accepteren.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male and I identified as a trans woman for about five years. I started transitioning socially at 15 and began cross-sex hormones at 17, six months before I turned 18, and I stayed on estrogen for three years and three months, from age 17 to age 20. I never had any surgeries during that time — it was hormones only. I grew up very gender non-conforming in a conservative, religious area; my family was Catholic and Baptist, and I've described that religious upbringing as a factor in my internalized homophobia. I'm gay, and I've said that being queer and gender non-conforming and being ostracized for it played a huge part in my transition. I also came to believe that a big part of why I transitioned was that I could blend in better and feel safer being perceived as a woman, because looking visibly queer made me feel unsafe.
By September 2022, at age 20, I was seriously considering detransition and posted asking about penile atrophy, noting I had shrunk quite a bit on hormones. I stopped hormones cold turkey rather than tapering — I wanted off synthetic hormones as soon as possible — and I had no serious withdrawal issues besides minor mood swings as my body readjusted. Within a month off hormones I reported increased libido, much better erectile function, size, increased appetite, oily skin and hair, shrinking breast tissue, and a clearer head. By month two I had increased body hair, was smelling like a man again, and felt my jawline becoming slightly more angular. I cut my hair off and described an awkward stage where I looked somewhere between a masc lesbian and a twink. By month three, bloodwork showed my testosterone in the 900 range with estrogen in a healthy male range, all without taking anything to help. I considered HCG or Clomid but chose to avoid further medicalization and wait. Sperm recovery took longest — it hadn't returned by month five but finally came back by April 2023. I had gynecomastia-like residual breast tissue that I planned to have removed surgically, and I got a mastectomy about a month after my final update in April 2023. I was working on changing my legal information back.
Detransitioning brought real anxiety. Going to in-person classes for the first time since detransitioning, with masculine clothes and cut hair, I experienced intense anxiety with people staring. I used the men's bathroom for the first time in years and felt unsafe the whole time; eventually I avoided public bathrooms entirely out of fear of harassment. Working out and staying busy with hobbies and friends helped. I also lost my best friend, who distanced herself after I detransitioned, and I avoided my extended family's questions because I was tired of it. On the positive side, I started seeing a man — I'm gay — while still identifying as trans, and we're still together; he knows my detrans history and has never been weird about it. I've made new friends who don't know my history. I also noted that dating while I was trans was hard and mostly unwanted sexual fetishism, and that dating has been much easier since detransitioning.
I don't describe diagnosable mental health conditions, but I've written about shame, internalized homophobia, religious trauma I'm still working through, and what I called delusion and narcissism surrounding my transition. I wrote that realizing the truth was humiliating and a hit to my ego, and that I wasted my teen years. I've said my life has improved over the roughly six months before my final update and that I feel great and confident for the first time in a long time. I did see a therapist who actually helped me, though I also said I'm too scarred by so-called therapists to look for a new one.
My views on transition are strongly critical. I've posted that anyone who transitions is inherently delusional, that transgenderism is delusional and narcissistic, that gender dysphoria always results from trauma, internalized homophobia, internalized misogyny, autogynephilia, narcissism, or other mental illness, and that gender-affirming therapy is harmful. I've argued against giving hormones and puberty blockers to minors, called bottom surgery the creation of an open wound, and claimed long-term estrogen is associated with early-onset Alzheimer's. I've advocated for accepting gender non-conformity instead of gender ideology, and I've said the solution is therapy and introspection with a therapist who will be real with you. I've been active in this community, answering questions and posting monthly detransition updates to help others, and I told people my DMs are open if they need a friend. I've said I may post an update after one year detransitioned.