Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die zich vanaf mijn midden tienerjaren als trans identificeerde, als ‘letterlijk kind’ door een incompetente arts en therapeut snel aan HRT werd gezet en 3 jaar hormonen gebruikte voordat ik eind 2021/begin 2022 stopte. Ik begrijp mijn transitie nu als een sociaal overlevingsmechanisme — een reactie op het zonder mededogen behandeld worden als jongen en op giftige vriendengroepen — en ik kwam tot detransitie via meditatie, psychedelica, wiet en therapie die me hielp gebeurtenissen uit mijn kindertijd en vroege tienerjaren te verwerken die me ontevreden maakten met mijn lichaam. Ik identificeer me weer met mijn geboortegeslacht, omschrijf de transgemeenschap als een sekteachtige echokamer en pleit ervoor dat omgaan met problemen voorrang krijgt boven transitie als ‘pleisteroplossing’. Lichamelijke veranderingen keren al om (seksuele functie en gezichtsbeharing komen binnen ongeveer vijf weken na het stoppen met HRT terug). Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of suïcidepogingen beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born male, and by the time I was 15 I was already active on trans communities online — traa is where I started, and I got called an 'egg' so much on egg_irl that I actually started believing it. Looking back, I now understand that becoming trans was, for me, a social survival mechanism. I noticed I was frequently treated with little care or compassion because I was a man and was expected to be strong, stoic, and never have feelings, while women seemed to be treated with more compassion and were allowed to actually feel and express their emotions. From that I logically concluded: oh, so I must be a girl then.
I was rushed through the medical system as a 'literal child' — put on HRT with a doctor who rushed me and a therapist I now describe as grossly incompetent. Nobody asked questions; they just gave me what I thought I wanted. I don't even blame myself anymore, I'm just disappointed all around that nobody involved knew better.
A big part of being trans for me was also having friends and a group, but those friends and groups were honestly toxic and really cringe, so I ended up isolating myself — having cis friends was hard because I lived somewhere pretty conservative at the time.
What moved me toward detransition was looking inward for answers. Mostly through meditation (mindfulness and breath-focus) and a bit of psychedelics, I was able to review my past and see the events in my childhood and early teen years that made me grow discontent with my body. Once I recognized them I could work through them, and by the end of that process I identified with my birth sex and knew I needed to stop taking HRT. I also credit smoking weed: it opened my mind and changed my thought patterns and habits in ways that left me wiser, and once I stopped smoking I could apply what I'd learned — within a month I knew with complete certainty I needed to stop HRT and just accept who and what I am. I also went to therapy at one point; the therapist told me exactly what I needed to hear, but I stopped the sessions because I didn't quite believe it at the time. As I developed better coping mechanisms, my trans feelings slowly started to dissipate.
I was on HRT for 3 years. By early February 2022 I had been off for about a month and a week, and I was already seeing sexual function return to normal and facial hair starting to grow back at a noticeable rate. I had also had some kind of procedure that caused pain — I mentioned the pain wasn't very bad for me when I got 'them,' though I hadn't suspended HRT immediately afterward.
I posted my story in January 2022 under the title 'being trans was a social survival mechanism and i accept that now,' saying I'd accepted this truth '3 years too late' — 15-year-old me was smart enough to know it but not wise enough to believe it. I'm now deep in the acceptance stage, not even angry or upset. I've become an active commenter in the detrans community, offering advice on meditation, coping, doctors, and puberty blockers (I warned a parent that blockers can affect a child long-term even after stopping, including reduced natural testosterone production and increased chance of gynecomastia). I describe the trans community as cult-like and an echo chamber of 'validation,' and I compare the rush to medicate to how doctors 'assign any number of mind-numbing antidepressants instead of actually addressing the societal issues that lead to depression' — 'oh, you dont like being a woman because society treats women like shit? you must be a man then!'
My current view: the human race is divided into two physical sexes (plus some occasional genetic deviation), and with that fact in mind people should be allowed to do whatever they want — dress, behave, be addressed however they want — but if you're male you're male. I support bodily autonomy for people of sound mind, but I dislike the idea that transition absolutely will fix all of your problems with no downsides; trying to learn to cope should be prioritized over using transition as a bandaid solution. Now that I'm detransitioned, being a biological male feels immensely better than pretending to be female — it really feels like I was just delusional, and even if I truly believed it I couldn't reasonably expect everyone else to believe it too. I identify with my birth sex now.