Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die jarenlang leefde alsof ik een man was en publiekelijk beweerde gelukkig te zijn, voordat ik besloot te detransitioneren en concludeerde dat ik was ‘gehersenspoeld door de transcult’. Ik betoog nu dat transitie wordt behandeld als wondermiddel voor ongeluk waarvan de echte bron innerlijk is, en ik ben scherp kritisch op onomkeerbare operaties, vooral als ze worden uitgevoerd voordat iemand zelf tot die conclusie komt. Ik neem berichten over geluk na transitie met een korreltje zout, gebaseerd op mijn eigen jaren van het veinzen van tevredenheid die ik niet voelde. Ik heb mijn huidige identiteit in deze reacties niet expliciet vermeld, maar ik schrijf als iemand die gedetransitioneerd is en spijt heeft van de onomkeerbare veranderingen. In dit materiaal heb ik geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of mentale diagnoses beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I came to these discussions in early 2019 already firmly convinced that transition was a mistake for many people, and I spoke about it bluntly. My position was shaped partly by my own experience and partly by watching a close friend go through transition and then reverse it.
I had transitioned and lived for a period pretending to be a man. During that time I told people I was happy with the transition, and I kept that up for years — publicly performing contentment with something I wasn't actually at peace with. Eventually I decided to detransition. Afterward I described myself as having been "brainwashed by the transcult," which is the phrase I used for what I now see as the ideological pressure and the promise that transition would fix everything. That realization is the core of my story: I had believed, sincerely, that I was born in the wrong body and that hormones and social transition would resolve my unhappiness, and it did not.
I also watched a friend go through the same arc. She transitioned, told everyone she was happy, and later detransitioned — and, as I put it, "she won't get her breasts back." That irreversible loss is one of the things that made me angry. I came to believe that the medical system moves too fast: people should reach the conclusion that transition doesn't work on their own, and "preferably BEFORE they get irreversible surgeries performed on them." I was particularly harsh about the David Reimer case and John Money, calling for Money to have been imprisoned for what he did, and I used that case to argue that you cannot change your sex — that David "was always a male" and understood later that he had been lied to.
My view of unhappiness is that it is primarily internal, not social. I rejected the argument that trans people's distress comes from stigma and discrimination, saying "the main source of your unhappiness is on the inside" and comparing it to depression rooted in brain chemistry — depressed people still kill themselves even with loving families, so changing the environment doesn't fix the root cause. I used the analogy of someone who thinks a partner will make them happy, and noted there are millionaires who still commit suicide. I explicitly said people treat transition as a "magic bullet."
I'm skeptical of reports of happiness from people who have transitioned. When someone said they knew happy trans people, I asked whether they were truly happy or just saying so. My own years of claiming happiness while pretending to be a man are the basis for that skepticism — I take such reports "with a huge grain of salt." I also argued that detransition after a doctor's mistake is never a true reversal: people accepting ruined genitals as a "new normal" doesn't mean they're satisfied or would do it again, comparing it to quadriplegics who accept their situation because they have no other choice.
I did not describe my own medical details, ages, diagnoses, surgeries, mental health history, family situation, sexuality, or current identity in these comments, so I'll leave those blank rather than guess. What comes through clearly is that I detransitioned, I regret the irreversible changes — my friend's lost breasts stand in for what I see as the general harm — and I am now critical of transition as offered to others, particularly minors and people whose distress I believe has an internal, untreated root cause.