Alle verhalen

Vier jaar oestrogeen, en een dochter die hij bijna niet had kunnen krijgen

Man · GedetransitioneerdTransitie 24 → Detransitie 276,9K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die als transvrouw leefde en ongeveer vier jaar man-naar-vrouw-HRT gebruikte voordat ik rond begin 2021 stopte om gezondheids- en vruchtbaarheidsredenen. Transitie gaf me aanvankelijk geluk en ik ging goed door, maar ik ging het zien als onhoudbaar vanwege gezondheidsrisico's op lange termijn, constante angst over hoe anderen me zagen en wat het me kostte aan familie, sociaal leven en financiën. Ik werkte aan mijn lichaamsontevredenheid met zen en non-dualiteit-mindfulness, dankbaarheidsoefeningen, sport, CGT en onderzoek naar wat ik zie als zwakke wetenschap achter de hypothese van het gegenderde brein, en ik denk helemaal niet meer aan gender. Ik ervaar aanzienlijke spijt en mogelijk PTSS over mijn transitie, al zeg ik dat ik nu gezonder en gelukkiger ben dan ooit, getrouwd en verwachtend van een dochter van wie ik de vruchtbaarheid toeschrijf aan het feit dat de hormonen die niet hebben vernietigd. Ik deel actief mijn verhaal, ben van meerdere trans-subreddits verbannen en pleit ervoor dat transitie wordt voorgesteld als een echte keuze met volledige geïnformeerde toestemming en niet als de enige behandeling voor genderdysforie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male, and in hindsight I had vague gender body issues from a young age, but my first overt thoughts about it came roughly two to three years before I transitioned. I started identifying as a trans woman and living socially as a woman around 2017, when I was about 24, and I was on male-to-female HRT for over three to four years. My regimen included spironolactone as an anti-androgen along with estrogen. I never had any surgery, because I questioned the validity and effectiveness of that from the very beginning. I did have laser hair removal on my face. By most external measures my transition was successful: I passed well, I had a supportive job, a wife, and a supportive family. Transition genuinely brought me things I wanted at the time — it made me feel better about my body, made me happier, and I learned to handle my anger issues better. But underneath that, I was doing my hair and makeup every morning so I could LOOK like a woman, and I was consumed with how people perceived me. One of the most disturbing realizations I had was that for almost three years I had not been able to look up at the sky to appreciate birds and clouds because I was afraid people would see my Adam's apple. I transitioned hoping to become more present in the world, but in some ways it caused the exact opposite. I also developed a subconscious, unintentional fear of being misgendered even when it was no longer really possible. What moved me toward detransition was a combination of health concerns and the prospect of building a family. I have a genetic predisposition for complications like breast cancer and blood clots, and the realization that I would be gambling with my health for the next 40 to 50 years of my life by staying on synthetic hormones became unbearable. I read that preliminary short-term studies suggest an elevated breast cancer rate in trans women compared to the male population, and that there are no clinical trials of these drugs for trans people and no FDA approval for these uses. On top of that, I began thinking about having children and marrying my wife, and I realized that fertility could be at stake. Wanting a child was a large aspect of my detransitioning. I also came to see how much I had sacrificed: normal social relationships, the financial burden of medical care, concern about where I live and whether I could find a doctor, friction with my family, and constant worry about my body. I stood in pharmacy lines with sick people, knowing that I am not sick. I tapered off over the course of less than a week — my doctor said it was okay to stop spironolactone without a taper, but I tapered anyway to be safe. My body began to change very quickly; within about a week I was passable as a man again after cutting my hair and wearing men's clothes, and within about three weeks my face had changed enough that I could no longer pass as a woman. My face masculinized and facial hair returned despite the laser hair removal, in a matter of weeks. Changes continued for at least three months after stopping. It took about 1.5 months for my body and mind to feel back to normal. My voice took longer, though that was behavioral rather than physiological — I sometimes still didn't pass on the phone. Sexual function took some time but seems to return for most people; I have concerns about fertility that I have not yet had tested by a physician, though I noted with gratitude that the hormones apparently did not ruin my fertility. I had limited dysphoria before my transition, and it actually got worse over the course of my transition. I put dysphoria in quotes because I believe the well-established concept of body dysmorphia already covers it, and that it can result from trauma, neurotic behavior, internalized sexism, depression, or other psychological states. Working through it after detransition involved four main things: practicing zen and reminding myself that "I" am not my body; practicing gratitude for what is right about my body (functioning legs and arms, a mind that can learn and create, eyes that can see); looking into what I see as the lack of scientific evidence for the transgender condition, particularly the gendered brain hypothesis; and exercising to keep body and mind healthy and reduce anxiety. I also found CBT to be a reliable tool. Zen and non-duality had been part of my life for many years before transition, and I had performed mental gymnastics during transition to convince myself it was in line with my spiritual practice; returning to that practice was essential to my detransition. Psychedelics also forever changed what I see in the mirror. I found r/detrans at a critical moment and saw others who had made it out, and a YouTuber called "Have a Good One" was one of the only role models I could find when I was considering detransition. I was not certain or comfortable when I began preparing to detransition — I was having emotional breakdowns and crying while shopping for men's clothes, which is out of character for me, because it felt like throwing away four years of my life. The only motivators that kept me going were concerns for my health and the desire to have children one day. It scares me what might have happened to me without those outside motivators. I also credit reading The End of Gender by Debra Soh, and perspectives from Jordan Peterson, with helping me question what I had been told. Mentally, I had social anxiety during my transition and did not socialize, hating how small and self-conscious I felt whenever I had to interact with people. After detransition I would say I have a lot of regret and maybe even PTSD, despite my transition having felt completely successful at the time. I manage that by reminding myself it is in the past and not giving those memories mental energy, and by choosing growth over regret. I also noted that my years of living as a woman now feel like a bad dream, and that I still occasionally get thoughts and dreams about NOT detransitioning, which makes me sick. I am now a detransitioned man. Almost a year out, I no longer feel trans and do not think about my gender or about "presenting" at all, and I am healthier and happier than I have ever been. I am married to the woman who was my fiancée during detransition — she had been openly supportive of my transition but later shared that she is not a dress-and-makeup-wearing girl and questioned how those things made me a woman, pointing out that most transitions, mine included, are a caricature of womanhood. We are expecting a daughter, and I plan to tell her about my experience because of the wisdom I gained about dogmatism, obsessive disorders, self-acceptance, and gratitude. I work as a chemist and have been learning to build neural networks. Politically I was conservative during my transition and have become far more liberal/libertarian since detransitioning. I have been vocal about my views. I was banned from r/transtimelines for reposting my detransition timeline there, and previously from asktransgender and transadoption for benign responses trying to help people who were struggling. I regularly share my story, post resources on zen mindfulness, and encourage others considering detransition. My attitude toward transition for other people is that it should be framed as a genuine choice rather than the only option: I believe people should be provided with multiple perspectives and unbiased information to make an informed adult decision, and I describe myself as a bodily autonomy absolutist. I do not think debate alone changes minds — I believe the most powerful thing is for people to see detransitioned people who are happy and healthy. I have come to view transgenderism as real in the way depression is real, but as a mutable mental condition rather than an immutable biological one, and I am critical of the medical field and culture for encouraging it and offering only medicalization.