Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren, identificeerde me vanaf mijn tienerjaren als non-binair/agender en begon eind 2020, op mijn 22e, na twee jaar onderzoek met een lage dosis testosteron, waar ik meer dan een jaar op bleef terwijl ik topchirurgie overwoog. Op T kreeg ik een flinke verkleining van mijn heupen en ik twijfelde of topchirurgie wel bij me paste. Ik zou de ervaring niet willen uitwissen, want ze gaf me inzicht in wat ik eigenlijk wilde. In oktober 2022 noemde ik mezelf gedetransitioneerd. Ik blijf sceptisch over transitie als universele oplossing en kritisch over het AGP-kader, maar steun in grote lijnen nog steeds lichamelijke autonomie.
Volledig verhaal
I am a person from central Europe who was born female and identified as non-binary/agender for years before starting testosterone. I was 22 when I first posted about my doubts in November 2020, having researched microdosing testosterone and top surgery for about two years before deciding to medically transition once I became financially stable.
I never liked being called a girl and hated people connecting me to that gender. I always acted boyishly, had short hair, and did stereotypically masculine things like repairing things. When I first learned the term non-binary it fit me wonderfully and I claimed it as my own. I never identified as a guy either - I never was a woman or a man, I just was myself. I wanted broad shoulders, small hips, and no boobs. I described myself as agender and said I did not want to be perceived as anything - not man, not woman.
I framed going on low-dose testosterone as an experiment and a 'back door' - something I could stop whenever I wanted if I didn't like the changes. I said I did not have 'crippling dysphoria' like many people I knew or heard of; testosterone was just a way of adapting my body to my wants, including stopping my period and getting stronger for powerlifting. I am a powerlifter and quite fit, but said that still didn't bring me close to how I wanted to look.
By January 2021, I had been on testosterone for over a year (I asked someone else '22 and over a year?'). I noticed my hips had 'tapered a lot' and couldn't seem to grow back - a change I never expected to be so big. I also discussed that flat bones like the jaw can change on testosterone, and that it can affect growth plates of long bones in young people.
In January 2021 I was asked whether I would go back in time and erase taking hormones. I answered honestly that I would not - that taking hormones was a big decision and step I would never erase, because it gave tremendous insight into female/male bodies, social roles and looks, and that without hormones I would never have been able to see what I really wanted or what my goal was from there on.
I was still considering top surgery at that point - I said I was 'kinda in the same boat right now - don't know if top surgery is right for me' and that I hoped getting more ripped and top surgery would improve my discomfort in my own body. I also posted asking others about top surgery regret.
I come from a country in central Europe where you are not allowed to transition before taking tests regarding behavior and personality disorders, and where you cannot transition if you are suicidal. Privately it costs a lot but takes about two months of going to psychologists and psychiatrists running personality/behavioral tests and ruling out other disorders; if you have depression you need a cross-diagnosis which takes longer. Public healthcare requires a 'proof of life' test - living as your transitioned self for about a year or two before hormones or surgeries. Conversion therapy is banned but many religious centers still practice it.
I was studying biomedicine and read academic work during my studies, including a review of Anne Lawrence's book 'Men Trapped in Men's Bodies'. I was skeptical of the AGP/HSTS framework, arguing it was outdated, based on small non-diverse samples, and never tested on females or transmasculine patients. I engaged extensively in debates on the forum about cosmetic surgery, defending it as a personal choice with moderation, and got heavily downvoted for some views. I acknowledged I was presenting opinions controversial to the detrans community.
I was in a relationship with a spouse who is a philologist. I described my sexuality in terms of preferring women ('girls are so much better in sex and hotter too'), and mentioned being a 'stone top' at times. I had a notebook called the 'emotions log' where I would write down and process my emotions.
By October 2022, I referred to myself as 'being detrans' - saying 'I think I know better what's my worldview, and being detrans is not something that doesn't agree with.' I was arguing with others about scientific sources and mentioned reading through sources someone had provided.
I do not describe any surgeries I actually had, nor an explicit final detransition date, nor current mental health outcomes, in this transcript.