Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I never had a settled trans identity, but I came very close to transitioning at one point and ultimately did not follow through. I have said plainly that I was "very close at one point to transitioning but ended up not following through because I recognised I was not and I'm still not very mentally healthy." I never pursued hormones or surgery, so there is no medical timeline to report for myself.
What drew me toward transition, and what pulled me back, is the part of my story I care most about. I have described myself as not being mentally healthy, and I have suggested to others that what they read as gender dysphoria might actually be depression — asking one person, "Sounds to me like you've got depression... Have you been on anti depressants or seen a therapist before?" I recognised in myself that transitioning was not going to fix my underlying issues. I also came to see that a lot of what gets labelled dysphoria is really discomfort with culturally constructed gender norms: men wanting to wear dresses, makeup, long hair, a slender figure. I noted that I have "yet to hear about dysphoria from not getting a period," which is part of why I came to believe that dysphoria is often self-induced and misdiagnosed rather than an innate knowledge of being born the wrong sex.
The single biggest influence on my thinking was discovering algorithmic filter bubbles. Learning about AI made me aware that recommendation systems feed you content that confirms what you already believe. When I was weighing transition, I was "recommended tons of validating trans articles, spaces, youtubers, you name it. It was awfully convenient." Realising that the affirming material I had been absorbing was being served to me by an algorithm designed to keep me clicking was a turning point. I posted about this publicly and asked others whether similar algorithmic steering had affected their own decisions to transition.
Alongside that, I did a lot of reading and research — medical literature, open letters to healthcare practitioners, and long exchanges with other people online. I quoted studies on puberty blockers (bone loss, FDA adverse reports, irreversible side effects persisting after discontinuation), cross-sex hormone risks (blood clots, hypertension, cardiovascular disease), sterilisation when cross-sex hormones follow puberty blockade at Tanner Stage 2, and the single long-term follow-up study showing higher mortality, suicide and psychiatric hospitalisation among surgically transitioned adults. I also became convinced that financial incentives drive a lot of the medical establishment's enthusiasm for transition — that doctors and therapists "make a killing off of transitioning prescriptions and surgeries" and that the trans community is profitable in a way homosexuals never were, which is why, in my view, societies accepted trans people "overnight."
My broader framework for understanding what happened became the analogy between trans identity and religion. I wrote a long post arguing that trans functions like a belief system: unprovable, self-reinforcing, dependent on echo chambers that ostracise dissenters, and defended by social pressure rather than evidence. I compared the certainty trans people express about being born the wrong sex to religious faith — "No one can prove their God exists and no one can prove you weren't born the wrong gender" — and argued that the only defence against indoctrination is critical thinking and taking in multiple perspectives. I have described my current view as believing "trans is a cult that uses indoctrination, herd mentality and echo chambers to control their members" and that it preys on "mentally ill and desperate individuals, claiming becoming trans is a cure all." At the same time I have been careful to say I still believe transition can benefit some people, and that my main goal is to raise awareness that transition is not for everyone and that detransitioners exist.
I have also been critical of gender-critical spaces when they stray into misandry, telling one commenter that dismissing all men is "proving your own sexism and bigotry" and pushing back on the claim that "talking to men disgusts me" as pathological. I have argued it is entirely possible to be an effeminate bisexual man without changing gender, and told people directly: "You do not have to change genders to be perceived" a certain way. I have been sceptical of transition as a response to unwanted male attention, to fetish-driven transition (transmaxxing), and to the pressure young people face, saying 16 is "still incredibly young" and that children should have to wait until adulthood before making irreversible decisions.
On sexuality and bullying: I was the last in my school year group to have my voice break and was bullied relentlessly with homophobic slurs, and I noted with bitterness that most of my bullies later came out as gay — "Fucking projecting hypocrites the lot of them." I have a sister who was so convinced her developing breasts were cancer that she forced my mother to take her to the doctors, which I have offered as an example of normal body anxiety being medicalised.
I have been active in detrans communities since at least April 2019, posting and commenting regularly, and I have explicitly said I do not comment on posts about experiences I do not share. I have no history of surgery, hormones, or puberty blockers myself, no stated fertility concerns, and no reported suicidal ideation or self-harm. My regret is not about physical changes but about time and near-misses: the years spent inside a filter bubble, the near-decision to transition while mentally unwell, and the realisation of how easily I could have been led somewhere irreversible.