Alle verhalen

Counselor sluit zich aan bij de detransgemeenschap om degenen te dienen die ze verlaten noemt

Man · Gedesisteerd943
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee: ik ben een man die nooit is getransitioneerd, een in trauma gespecialiseerde counselor in Nieuw-Zeeland die via mijn eigen trauma tot het werk kwam en nu detransitioners steunt. Ik kwam in mijn late jaren vijftig bij counseling via een niet-academische route en doe nu een promotieonderzoek naar zelfmoordcijfers na transitie. Ik geloof dat genderdysforie geworteld is in kindertrauma, ongunstige jeugdervaringen en verstoorde gehechtheid, en ik ben een uitgesproken criticus van genderbevestigende zorg, die ik kwaadaardig noem wanneer ze onverwerkt trauma bevestigt. Ik sloot me aan bij de detransgemeenschap om een groep te dienen die ik als in de steek gelaten zie, en ik bied chat, Zoom en leesmateriaal aan personen in nood. Ik ben niet getransitioneerd en beschrijf zelf geen spijt over transitie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male, and I have never transitioned — my story here is not one of detransition but of what led me to spend my life working with people who do detransition, and of my own trauma and how it shaped my thinking. I came to counselling through my own trauma rather than through an academic route. I did not start practising until my late 50s, and I now work full time as a counsellor specialising in trauma. I live in New Zealand, which means my professional pathway differs substantially from the American one — counselling, psychotherapy, psychology and psychiatry are all separate disciplines here with little overlap and very different academic routes. Most of my training is person-centred and somatic, focused on healing what I describe as the 'internal system' rather than on treatment. I am currently doing a program with the Trauma Research Foundation, and I have said plainly that I am doing the academic work later in life. I have also said I am doing a PhD in the area of suicide rates comparing gender-affirming and gender-exploratory intervention, though I have acknowledged I do not yet have enough data to state my preliminary findings as fact. My own trauma sits underneath everything I believe. I have described disrupted attachment and developmental trauma as causal in gender dysphoria, BPD, ADHD and a range of other conditions — even without direct abuse, if a mother did not look after a child well, or was affected by drugs and alcohol, the child develops maladapted ways of being, one of which is detaching from the gender that 'failed' them. I have also written about 'skin-hunger' — an insatiable need to be touched, typically arising when you were not held much as a baby, or if you lost your primary comforter or caregiver before your teens — and I have said that in my own life the feel of water on my skin is soothing. I have not given more detail about my own childhood, and I will not invent any. I have always been told I am 'very in touch with my feminine side'. My reading of that is that, for a man, I am high in agreeableness, openness and neuroticism, and highly relational — personality traits, not gender. I believe gender is biologically defined, and that a great deal of the discussion around gender is actually about personality traits. I joined the detrans community because I want to serve it. My observation is that desisters are abandoned by conventional society and by the communities they sought refuge in — an incredibly vulnerable, 'unloved' community — and I hope to do something about that, even if it is just helping one person at a time recover and heal. I have also said I think about 'structural confrontation' as well, because these voices need to be widely heard and acknowledged, and that I have not yet figured out how best to amplify them. I tried to research how to support detransitioners through a university and could not get a single university to let me study it; I had to go offshore to find people willing to stand up and defend the needs of this group. I have said that ethics committees will not pass anything that disagrees with the prevailing ideology, and linked the Bath Spa University case as an example. I have shared research on Adverse Childhood Experiences and gender, on PCOS and gender identity, on Tavistock suicide data, and articles from The Economist and SEGM. I have also said that the academic world lost its grip on reality about ten years ago, and that PhD candidates are having to sue their institutions to be allowed to do critical research. I hold strong and specific views about transition. I have said that affirming therapists have an agenda and often violate their own ethical standards, that the harm being done by affirming professionals is 'endemic and evil', and that it is 'evil to affirm what is probably unhealed trauma'. I have estimated the likelihood of deep regret after transition at around 99 percent, and said average surgery success sits at around 15 percent with many people having up to a dozen reparative follow-up surgeries. I have told people that gender dysphoria is never a good reason to damage your body, that transitioning is never the solution to emotional distress and trauma, and that many people considering transition who do not have underlying trauma are gay or bi — that trans ideology has made simply being gay or bi not OK, and that I consider it a psychosocial contagion. I have recommended non-affirming, exploratory therapists and organisations like GETA, and I have recommended Internal Family Systems (IFS) as a modality for exploring gender and sexual issues without shame or fight-or-flight. I also hold views outside this area that I state plainly: I do not accept that human evolution is demonstrably provable, treating it as a belief like belief in God, while biology is provable; I am critical of postmodernism and social constructionism; and I have said the separation of gender and biological sexuality will eventually become a historical failure. I am active and encouraging in the community. I have offered to chat or Zoom with people who are stuck, offered to send reading material, and told people who are struggling that their best life is in front of them. I have told a young woman to hang in there because 'the real you is still there', told others their eyes are beautiful and to keep pursuing their femininity, and told people their feelings at 15 are likely to pass as their brain finishes developing. I have said that anyone who genuinely cares about you will be thankful you are doing what is best for you, and that activists use shame to destroy other people's lives. I have explained my model of the self as one self with many protective parts, and that trauma shuts down the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, which is what allows us to know where a memory is in time — so until healing takes place, trauma keeps running the ship. I have not described any medical transition of my own, any regret about transition, or any change in identity. I remain a man, a trauma-specialised counsellor, and an outspoken critic of gender-affirming care.