Alle verhalen

Hormoonrisico's uitzoeken, en dan beseffen dat niemand haar ooit als man zou zien

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd464
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een paar jaar geleden gedesisteerd en ben een gendernonconformistische vrouw die haar mannelijke uitstraling heeft vergroot in plaats van femininiteit te omarmen. Ik ben gedetransitioneerd nadat ik de bijwerkingen van hormonen had uitgezocht in verband met mijn bestaande beperking en besefte dat niemand me ooit echt als man zou zien, waardoor transitie puur performatief zou zijn. Ik noem mezelf nu gendercritisch, geloof niet in genderidentiteit als concept en pleit voor betere geestelijke gezondheidszorg vóór medische transitie. Ik voel me nog steeds ongemakkelijk bij femininiteit en vrees dat dat misschien internaliserende vrouwenhaat is, terwijl ik ook word uitgemaakt voor butch en onverdraagzaam vanwege mijn standpunten. Ik blijf een GNC-vrouw die leert leven met het vrouw-zijn.

Volledig verhaal

I desisted a few years ago, and I've been sitting with some complicated feelings about how I present myself since then. I actually increased my masculine presentation after desisting, which surprised some people here who talk about growing their hair out or wearing dresses again. I don't enjoy performing femininity, and I've been wondering whether that means I'm still performing trans in some way. I'm a short woman, and I think part of why I hate presenting feminine is that I'm short and I believe people will treat me differently if I do. I mainly wear men's clothes because the pockets are bigger and they aren't cut in a way that shows my hips. I've never really been feminine — I don't want long hair or, as I put it, "open air cooch clothes." I've always been a gender non-conforming woman. I questioned briefly whether I was queer, but I never identified as queer. That brief questioning was enough to form my disgust towards the community and what I see as how much it lies and encourages mental health issues. I wish I could be GNC without people being afraid I'll scream at them for not using they/them towards me. I detransitioned because I wasn't getting the answers I needed when I considered starting hormones medically. I have a disability, and I needed to know the side effects relevant to it, but I could only find what I called "heresy" information on the side effects. I asked forums specific to my disability about side effects, but they told me it would be all fine when I knew that it wouldn't. They literally told me I wouldn't have side effects — I pointed out it's impossible for a medicine to have a 0% side-effect rate, and they don't know if I'd be one of the 10% that would experience some symptom. I had to look deeper and found articles saying the meds were very harmful, especially for people like me. Realizing I'd only ever dress and cut my hair "like a man" — which I was already doing and had been for years, where everyone called me by my sex-based pronoun — I knew that no one would ever actually see me as a man. Because transitioning would be entirely performative, I decided to actually just learn to live with being female. I've thought a lot about whether my masculine presentation comes from internalized misogyny — whether I'm performing masculinity subconsciously because I dislike femininity within myself, not externally, since I'm a staunch feminist. I've worried about what other people think and been afraid of what they'll do. I've also noted that if you keep chasing the goalposts of transition, every change, every article of clothing, every session with makeup, every time you hear your voice, you'll realize there's one more thing to do. I don't believe in gender identity as a concept — I see it as stereotypes. I've become critical of what I view as the oppression totem pole, noting that as a short woman who faces infantilization, I'm apparently lower than a 6' white trans swimmer. I've argued that mean comments aren't transphobia, and that I personally don't really believe transphobia exists — that what gets labeled transphobic is actually homophobia or just meanness. I identify as gender critical, and I've said that being GC means questioning trans policies and the community and recognizing the negatives. I've advocated for stronger mental healthcare for people who think they're trans before they transition, and I've been called a monster and a bigot for supporting abortion and that position. People also call me butch and say girls can't do certain things. I've tried to be supportive of others here — encouraging someone facing infertility not to feel defective, telling someone they're pretty, and giving firm advice to someone in a situation with a person I described as abusive and sexually harassing their friends. I believe women can be anything they want to be and that personalities and hobbies are just aesthetics — you're allowed to have any personality and like anything. When someone asked about buying feminine things, I said to buy stuff you like and that's comfortable, because it's just clothes. I've framed detransition as choosing your pain: the pain of detransitioning or the pain of continuing down a path you should never have started.