Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw (FTM, als vrouw geboren) die op mijn 14e uitkwam, op mijn 15e-16e 8-9 maanden testosteron nam en op mijn 16e abrupt stopte, zonder operaties. Ik zie mezelf nu als primaire detransitioner en een hardcore butch vrouw die haar mannelijke naam hield. Mijn transitie werd gedreven door lichaamsdysmorfie, een meeloopeffect vanuit online transgemeenschappen en FTM-YouTubers, groepsdruk van vrienden die me confronteerden met mijn twijfels, en het feit dat een masculiene uitstraling alleen acceptabel was als ik mezelf een jongen noemde. Ik noem het ‘de grootste spijt van mijn leven’ en wou dat ik nooit van transgenderisme had gehoord, al ben ik nu grotendeels oké met mijn lichaam en heb ik succes gehad met stemtraining. Ik adviseer anderen met enige twijfel actief om de stekker eruit te trekken en een stap terug te doen vóór ze transitioneren.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and came out as a trans guy (FTM) when I was 14, after first identifying as a lesbian and wanting to be "super duper butch" but not knowing any butch lesbians in real life and feeling like the message was "be a lesbian, but not like that." When I came out as trans, the first things I did were change how I dressed, get a boy's haircut at an actual barber shop, and change the posters and bedsheets in my room — things I'd always wanted but felt I couldn't have as a girl. When I first came out, I agreed with my parents I would take it really slowly and said I wasn't going to go on testosterone for ten more years. I watched trans guy testosterone progress videos and thought "oh cool good for him....but probably not for me."
Over time, two things pushed me toward wanting testosterone: a bandwagon effect and body dysmorphia. I'd had dysmorphia for years, on and off, and was jealous of boys, especially skinny ones. As I got more involved with online trans spaces and FTM YouTubers, and met other FTM guys whose main topic was going on T as soon as possible, I started feeling "Shouldn't I want this more?" My mindset did a 180 — from being happy to put off anything medical until after college, to feeling like I needed to start T right now and get all the surgeries as soon as possible. I now see that as my biggest red flag.
In summer 2019 I was scheduled for an appointment to start testosterone. I'd been working with my dad all day and we missed the appointment and had to reschedule, and I noticed I was actually a little relieved. I made a post about it on r/LGBDropTheT. One of my friends follows me on Reddit and saw it; a few days later, when I had friends over at my house, he and another friend — the "wokest" members of my group — confronted me about the post and asked if I had internalized transphobia. I was caught off guard and ended up agreeing with everything they said. I later went on T anyway. I also tried detransitioning earlier by immersing myself in gender-critical and anti-trans material, looking at my undressed body in the mirror (the dysphoria got too bad), reading body-acceptance pieces, and telling myself it would be easier on myself and everyone else if I just toughed it out and went back to being a lesbian — but I convinced myself everyone secretly hates trans people and the ones who were nice to me were just lying.
I was on testosterone for 8 or 9 months and quit cold turkey a few weeks before June 11, 2020, when I said I was 16. I had no surgeries. I stopped binding and packing and discovered I'm actually mostly okay with my body. I have a love/hate relationship with my voice and started voice training; my pitch analyzer app showed an average of 134 Hz (highest 155) versus a lowest female pitch of 165 Hz, and after about 5 months of training I posted before/after pitch results to encourage others. I also worked on resonance, shifting vibrations forward to the front of the nose and lips. About 5 months off T, I noticed my face looked "puffy and angular at the same time"; waxing facial hair helped a little but I said I looked like a tween boy. My mom suggested makeup, which I hate because I'm butch, but I was willing to try.
Deciding to detransition was hard on my parents. My mom felt guilty for following me into legal transition and brought up how sure I'd seemed, while also saying detransition seemed like the best option and she was glad I was comfortable in my skin. I couldn't socially detransition until after finishing high school because I worried people would think I was insane or that my parents were abusing me. A friend I told while still questioning didn't get it at all and insisted I had internalized transphobia. I kept my masculine name and am hardcore butch. My FTM friend, who I'd met and bonded with over dysphoria and jealousy that he'd started T earlier than me, was one of the first people I told about detransitioning for real and took it well, even throwing me a surprise Zoom birthday party.
After detransition I noticed I could keep books I'd been embarrassed by as a "guy self" — like a boxed set of Canterwood Crest books I got at ~12 — and watch shows my "guy self" had been embarrassed by, without policing myself. I reflected that conflating femaleness with femininity played a part in wanting to transition. I was frustrated that people were fine with me doing masc things as long as I called myself a boy, but once I said I was a girl again they asked if I'd start wearing dresses, makeup, or be attracted to guys — and I live in a progressive part of the US.
I now describe myself as a primary detransitioner and a detransitioned butch woman. I actively advise others: "if you have any doubt at all, even a little, it's a sign to pull the plug," and I told one person that getting swept up in the bandwagon effect "is the biggest regret of my life and I'm only 16." I said "I definitely wish I'd never done it" about transitioning, and that I wish I'd never heard of transgenderism, blaming YouTube and "ultra-woke trans circles on Reddit." I've posted progress photos, voice-training results, and asked other detrans women for advice, and I give voice-training tips to other teen detransitioners. I work through bad days with my therapist, and once cried myself to sleep over these thoughts.