Alle verhalen

Hoog testosteron, geen transitie, en één corrigerende ingreep

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd278
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, intersekse vrouw die nooit volledig is getransitioneerd: ik had van nature hoog testosteron, identificeerde me kort richting leven als man, onderging toen een corrigerende ingreep die de bron van androgenen verwijderde en desisteerde. Ik wilde nooit trans zijn of een ‘typische kerel’; mijn ongemak ging over niet passen in de verwachte vrouwelijke rol en over de seksuele ondergeschiktheid die ik met vrouwelijkheid associeerde. Nu ben ik scherp kritisch over transitiegeneeskunde, vooral voor autistische en intersekse jongeren, in de overtuiging dat financiële prikkels en vraaggestuurde zorg in de plaats komen van goed onderzoek en dat therapie altijd eerst moet komen. Ik pleit voor detransitioners die rechtszaken aanspannen tegen chirurgische zorgverleners, terwijl ik ook betoog dat onvolmaakte bondgenoten minder belangrijk zijn dan politici die transrechten aanvallen. Ik heb vrede gesloten met vrouwelijkheid door het ‘verkeerde lichaam’-verhaal te verwerpen en sterke vrouwen door de geschiedenis heen te vieren.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I am intersex — I naturally produced high testosterone, which I only identified the source of later in life. I describe myself as having been "slightly intersex," and I say I never wanted to be trans and never wanted to be a "typical dude" either; I just didn't feel happy being a woman. Looking back, I think that unhappiness had little to do with the reasons people usually assume: it was mostly that I didn't see myself as the kind of girl people expected me to be, and the idea of being required to be submissive to every man I met "sounded worse than death to me." I also recall feeling intensely out of place in high school as the only Middle Eastern-looking girl among Afro-Latino peers, being asked constantly where I was from, and wanting to fit in — I use that experience to explain why I'm skeptical of claims that cross-race and cross-gender identification are incomparable. I never went through a full male transition. Instead I had a "correcting procedure" that surgically removed the source of my high testosterone, and after that I "desisted on changing to male." Before that procedure, when I was not yet surgically altered, taking birth control softened my features a lot; when off birth control, masculine features would break through. I explicitly say I can't frame my experience as transitioning from A to B — for me it was "is what to what." I also note that some effects I can't even distinguish from the testosterone because I've always been intersex and lived with it. On the medical side, I'm strongly critical. I argue that therapy and psychological evaluation should come first before "incredibly life altering surgeries," and I say I'm for people doing SRS, HRT, or even body mods if it makes them happy — but only after proper psych help for dysphoria. I've become very critical of the financial incentives, asking "Will somebody make lots of money for not giving people the adequate care?" and concluding there's "something fishy that has to do with money and sterilization." I argue that trans medicine doesn't follow normal research protocols — no meta-analyses guiding doctors — and that instead "it has always been the patients demanding A, B, C treatment." I've said you can "always count on people to want to sterilize and overmedicate autistic people," while still acknowledging transition "might even save some lives." I've suggested all detransitioners should pursue class-action lawsuits against surgery and lobbying groups, and I told one person they should sue whoever failed to offer them proper medical intervention as a teen, calling it malpractice. I think a large portion of "T people" are actually autistic girls who don't agree with the "allosocial, hyperfeminine and hypersexualized view of womanhood," and that there is still no tool to separate genuinely trans people from autistic girls who feel yucky about the social role of women. I compare trans identification to transracial identification, arguing both can be driven by a desire to fit in with a visible peer group, and I think OCD plays a role in both, noting there's no good way to predict who will later detransition because it's "so damn close to an OCD." I believe there is some biological basis to being trans (I cite estrogen vs. testosterone in utero as one example) but say it's not yet quantifiable — otherwise we'd be using fMRI — and that desires for bodily change are shaped by what you see around you. I'm Brazilian and I talk openly about violence against women in Brazil, referencing Maria da Penha and the influence of evangelical politics. I reject the "wrong body" slogan entirely: "theres no fucking wrong body." I'm critical of language policing and of labels like "transphobe" being used to shut down conversation, comparing that strategy to how "anti-semite" gets used — noting I'm part Jewish. I think imperfect allies are far less dangerous than politicians actively trying to strip trans people of rights, and I distinguish between clueless-but-trying people and those pushing genuinely hateful rhetoric. I've recommended radical feminist creators (Neeza Powers on TikTok) and pushed back on the idea that radical feminism is harmful. I also engage with detransition communities critically, saying "Actual detrans" spends too much time lecturing and ostracizing people over small things while politicians say vile things. I'm now comfortable in my own femininity and try to pass that on: I tell others that what helped me stop hating my femininity was realizing society's stereotypes are wrong and that women can be strong — citing Hua Mulan, Khutulun, Mary Vincent, Sara Paerson, Queen Nzinga, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and Greta Thunberg. I say "Women are the strongest sex." I've given practical advice to detransitioners about birth control softening features, makeup and contouring to pass, vocal exercises to raise pitch, and hair and clothing choices. I mention having had a husband ("a soft gentle soul") whom I tried to protect, and I've had enough boyfriends to speak about relationships generally. I identify as a woman, I'm fine being intersex, and I'm skeptical of religious framing — I say God doesn't exist in my opinion and that using God as a basis for reasoning only brings sadness or radicalism.