Alle verhalen

Drie jaar non-binair, zonder dysforie en zonder hormonen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,1K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die drie jaar als non-binair identificeerde maar nooit genderdysforie had, nooit hormonen nam en mijn lichaam nooit wilde veranderen. Samenwonen met twee transvrouwen en de sektarische dynamiek in mijn sociale kring zien, dreef me tot desisteren. Sindsdien ben ik gestopt met pornografie kijken, heb ik mijn relatie met mijn lichaam en seksualiteit hersteld en leef ik nu gelukkig als genderniet-conforme lesbienne. Nu ben ik sterk kritisch over medische transitie, vooral bij jongeren, en heb ik ertegen gepleit met zelfmoordstatistieken en onderzoek naar puberteitsremmers. Ik identificeer me momenteel als vrouw en heb een liefdevolle relatie met een andere vrouw.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and I never took testosterone, but I did identify as trans — specifically non-binary for about three years — and I have since desisted and now live as a gender nonconforming woman. I have never had gender dysphoria or any desire to change my body, which is why I say my experience is very different from people who actually medically transitioned. My path into trans identification was largely social. In 2014 I was in a friend group that initially had one trans identified person; within a year there were several more, and then several people in the group, including me, started identifying as transgender. It became cult-like very quickly — a hierarchy formed with trans people at the top as the oppressed class and cis people at the bottom, and once that division was made, more people started identifying as trans. I later moved across the country to a very trans friendly city, where it was part of everything: every lesbian or women's group was becoming overcrowded with men, and it was constantly reinforced that saying the wrong thing would get you kicked out. Living with two trans women (both, as far as I could tell, straight AGPs) was a big part of what made me wake up and desist. I had never lived with men outside my family before, and living with them opened my eyes — I kept thinking, 'they're just men. They act like men. They are men.' I remember one night coming home to find both of them in the living room crying about how they never had a girlhood — no sexy sleepovers, no shopping trips, no big group of girlfriends. I was grossed out and angry and told them outright that what they were imagining wasn't real, that I grew up a girl and never experienced any of it. They rolled their eyes and dismissed me. I have a million other stories about what a nightmare those two men were, plus two other male roommates who were non-binary. I went through eating disorder treatment at some point, where I did a lot of ruminating on what 'feeling fat' actually meant — I realized that what I identified as 'feeling fat' was really just feeling aware of my body and uncomfortable with that awareness. I've applied the same logic to 'feeling like a woman/man': what is the actual feeling behind that thought? Since desisting I've become very comfortable identifying as just a woman. At a job a couple of weeks in, a coworker asked my pronouns out of nowhere and I just gave a confused look and said 'I'm just a woman.' I participate in society as a gender nonconforming person without a trans identity — I wear mostly men's clothing, I have short hair, I don't adhere to female sex stereotypes, and I'm fat. For several summers I've gone to a women-only music festival that many detrans women attend; being around fat, happy, naked women in a comfortable female-only environment absolutely healed a part of me and made me more comfortable in my body. I'm a lesbian. When I was trans identified I was also doing BDSM, and I was hypersexual. After I stopped watching pornography my sex drive evaporated. It's been a few years and I feel really chill about sex. I'm in a relationship with a woman who never watched porn and our sex life is great — probably sparse by most people's standards (1-2 times a month) but perfect for us, with no pressure. Changing from a hypersexual existence to a mellow, loving sexual experience has been peaceful and wonderful. Stopping porn also changed how I saw myself, other women's bodies, and sex generally; the desires for dominant/submissive experiences went away over time. I've also dealt with vibrator use affecting my sensation — I went back and forth for a year or two and only noticed a difference after several months of not using one. I don't use it anymore and don't plan to. I have a cousin who had a double mastectomy in her 20s for breast cancer without reconstruction and wore prosthetics — I had no idea for about 30 years. I'm very critical of medical transition now. I believe doctors should only treat patients who need treatment, and that treating a body when what's ill is the mind is malpractice — comparing transition to giving liposuction to an anorexic who believes she's fat. I think people who believe they should have been born the opposite sex shouldn't be given treatments to cosmetically change their body, because the harm vastly outweighs the temporary joy. I've cited studies claiming suicide rates are higher after medical transition, and I've told people to send their families the Swedish study and articles about the NHS discontinuing puberty blockers. Learning about the Pritzker family changed my thinking and made me receptive to some conspiracy theories. I was upset by Facebook ads for hormones, calling them disturbing and 'like they're just asking for a lawsuit.' I've advised a sibling's situation by urging someone to be brutally honest with their family about detransition to save their sibling from medical intervention. I've encouraged others considering top surgery to remember they can reschedule but can't get their breasts back or breastfeed afterward. I've recommended the book 'The Body Is Not an Apology' by Sonya Renee Taylor for body neutrality. I've also spoken about how algorithms push detransition content to extreme viewpoints on both sides. I don't regret any medical procedures since I had none, but I do regret the years spent in the trans-identified mindset and the social dynamics of those groups. My mental health and body comfort have improved substantially since desisting and stopping porn.