Alle verhalen

Zes weken zonder oestrogeen en de voorstelling stortte in

Man · GedetransitioneerdEerste dysforie 5 → Transitie 40 → Detransitie 53250
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man, in 1959 als man geboren, die 13 jaar als vrouw leefde op oestrogeen na een orchidectomie op mijn 49e, en in 2013 op mijn 53e stopte met oestrogeen uit angst voor beroerte/DVT. Binnen enkele dagen begon ik aan mijn 'vrouwelijkheids'-voorstelling te twijfelen, en zes weken later, nadat ik op 26 augustus 2013 radicaal-feministische blogs ontdekte, hield ik op te doen alsof ik een vrouw was en nam ik mijn naam terug. Sindsdien ben ik een uitgesproken criticus van transgenderisme geworden en betoog ik dat niemand 'trans' is en dat transitie slechts een kostuumwissel is. Ik heb nog af en toe een niet-erotisch verlangen om vrouw te zijn, maar noem mezelf 'droeviger maar wijzer' en grotendeels in vrede, zonder seksleven maar met een stabiele carrière en leven. Ik begon ongeveer vier jaar na het stoppen met oestrogeen met testosteron en merk op dat de orchidectomie nu voelt als een handicap.

Volledig verhaal

I was born in 1959, the eldest of five children, and by age five I had taken it for granted that I would grow up to be a woman, even though I was clearly a boy and not especially bothered by being one. My childhood was chaotic: my parents divorced when I was seven, we moved from the East Coast to a small beach town near San Francisco, and my mother began taking LSD. From about age eight to fifteen I experienced what I described as the worst, sketchiest things a hippie kid in the late '60s and early '70s might experience — watching my mother's violent boyfriend beat her and being beaten by him myself, police raids, being taken to a foster home, hiding from police, hanging around Hell's Angels, shoplifting groceries, taking LSD at age eight, taking mushrooms, and being my mother's main helper and confidant. I had PTSD symptoms from those years but did not know I had PTSD. By my early teens I was refusing haircuts, recoiling when people said 'he' or 'him' without saying anything, and making frantic efforts to stop growing. I got my mother to unofficially scratch out my name on my birth certificate and write 'Cheyenne Oaxaca.' At age twelve I borrowed a woman's outfit and took an early bus to San Francisco to crossdress in the city — I noted this was pre-erotic for me. At age fourteen the erotic/sexual autogynephilic phase of my life began. I noted that my story doesn't quite match Blanchard's model: I was not homosexual or a 'sissy,' just a little different, possibly with separation anxiety, and very close to my mom. I left home at fifteen and graduated high school at sixteen. I found Christine Jorgensen's book and was intrigued but confused because I liked girls. I had girlfriends, surfed, took mushrooms, lived on Maui half the year, and was mostly okay in my own skin — but when I got really depressed or felt abandoned, I would really wish I were a woman. At nineteen I became a father to a son, whom I raised solo from when he turned ten. In my late twenties I read Mary Daly and Janice Raymond, which gave me some distance from my autogynephilia; I didn't crossdress for about ten years and decided I would never transition. Around age thirty-nine to forty I was depressed after losing money in the first dot-com crash, my son left home, and I went through a painful breakup. With home internet for the first time, I started reading late-'90s TS/TG content, drinking wine, feeling sorry for myself, and crossdressing again. I went to a therapist who told me everything I wanted to hear. I started estrogen a few months later and got a good job at a university. At age forty-nine, trans surgery became available on my health plan, but I was not really into it; however, the State Department told me I could only get a full ten-year female passport if I had surgery, so I had an orchiectomy — which I now call 'stupid.' I had been on estrogen for thirteen years and was a '36D.' At age fifty-three, a lady friend worried I might get DVT or a stroke and urged me to stop estrogen; I was fully 'developed' and not generating testosterone since the orchiectomy. I stopped abruptly. Within days I woke up highly self-critical, baffled by all the nails, cosmetics, and shopping I had planned, and keenly aware that my 'femininity' was a performance and a masquerade. For about a month I scaled my femininity way down, trying to look androgynous or 'dykey,' while still thinking of myself as a woman. Six weeks after stopping estrogen, on 26 August 2013, I discovered GenderTrender and other radfem blogs and read them for twelve solid hours. I learned that children were being transed and that trans activists made violent threats to women. I realized my participation in transgenderism endorsed an industry dedicated to 'exterminating women and sterilizing children, just so autogynephilic men's fantasies could come true.' I stopped all effort to give the impression I was a woman that day, took back my old name, and stopped all makeup and primping from 8/26/2013. I told an old friend I had 'come back into my body, my name, my own self,' and although I had harmed myself and my body had changed drastically, it felt like a homecoming. I worked through what I'd done using depth psychology, traveled through 'cold hells' of grief and remorse, and had some bad days and nights but came out stronger. About four years after stopping estrogen I started testosterone. Five and a half years after detransitioning (age fifty-nine), I still occasionally perceive a wish that I were a woman, but with no erotic charge — I observe it, feel it as an old source of comfort, and say a calm goodbye. I have no sex life and am mostly alone, which is okay. I have an 850 credit score and an amazing career. I describe my old self as 'dead and crammed into an old gopher hole' and myself now as 'sadder but wiser,' out of the gopher hole. People still sometimes say 'ma'am' to me because my face is smooth and I have breasts; I am bemused and correct people when it matters. I now describe the orchiectomy as leaving me feeling like I have a disability, and I say it is not good to remove organs that are working fine. I am an epidemiologist and have read much of the research on innate gender identity, which I consider wildly speculative and fraudulent. I have become an outspoken critic of transgenderism, arguing that no one is 'trans,' that there is no innate opposite-sex gender identity, and that transition is only 'costume change and role-play.' I recommend CBT or DBT therapists for people with gender dysphoria, encourage detransitioners to be honest with themselves and others, and have posted resources including Sheila Jeffreys' Gender Hurts and a 1982 paper on the socio-medical construction of transsexualism. I posted a call for reports on transgender medications and have been active in advocating against childhood medical transition.