Alle verhalen

Op haar 15e het huis uit gezet, en toen ook de vrienden kwijt

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd830
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben katholiek opgevoed, het huis uit gezet omdat ik genderdoorbrekend was, identificeerde me als tiener als homo en als volwassene als transvrouw, en desisteerde na wat ik omschrijf als een psychotische breuk door „doublethink”, waarna mijn symptomen sterk verbeterden. Ik nam nooit hormonen, al transitioneerde ik wel sociaal, en ik identificeer me nu als gedetransitioneerd persoon die geen labels als „homo” meer wil. Ik verloor het grootste deel van mijn oude queer vriendengroep en een baan waar ik van hield nadat ik openlijk kritiek begon te leveren op transideologie en gendertheorie. Ik organiseer nu een genderkritische leesgroep in NYC en geloof dat genderdysforie een sociaal probleem is en geen ziekte.

Volledig verhaal

I was raised Catholic and was thrown out of my house for being gender nonconforming. Growing up 'queer,' I gravitated toward other queer people, partly because I related to them more easily and partly because I was only allowed to socialize with other queer people. I identified as gay as a teenager, and then identified as a trans woman in adulthood. I never went on hormones — the prospect of having to rely on doctors forever was what stopped me — so my transition was social rather than medical. My decision to desist came directly as the result of a psychotic break. I've described it as 'a psychotic break from all the doublethink,' and I've said that my trans identification 'definitely was a form of psychosis and basically as soon as i desisted ... my symptoms totally relaxed in severity.' After desisting, I stopped going outside for a long time, then reconnected with my old friend group a few months later when one of them needed help moving. My main friend group at that time was entirely made up of 'genderqueer' people. Being back in that community, I felt my experience was constantly politicized against my will, by others and by myself. I tried not to lie about what I believed and only talked about what I thought in their terms. When I started speaking more plainly about trans ideology — posting links to radfem lectures on Instagram, commenting under trans ideologues' posts — my friends gradually realized we fundamentally disagreed. One by one they started talking about me behind my back, blocking me, and sending messages saying they didn't want to be friends. One told me on the phone they were 'done' and 'very disgusted with my behavior' — over my posting an Andrea Dworkin speech about porn. They were coworkers, and at work they pretended I wasn't there and left me the hard work, so I put in my two weeks at the first job I'd really loved. I was nervous about being fired since the friend who cut me off was a more highly valued employee. I also learned that my closest friend in the group was 'reconsidering our friendship,' which broke my heart to hear secondhand. I criticized the medical industry and the sex/beauty industry for preying on trans people, not trans people themselves. I've said I'd rather be 'an extremely ugly, dorky, fat guy who somewhat rebels against gender norms than be a very pretty, narcissistic trans woman who submits to them at her own expense, and at the expense of other gender nonconforming people.' I no longer like identifying as gay, because the idea of calling myself names based on my behavior feels limiting. I don't like identifying within a social gender hierarchy I experience as oppressive. I've said that gender dysphoria is 'a social problem and not a disease.' I've started an NYC-based gender critical reading/discussion group open to trans and cis people, hoping to start a conversation about why gender is toxic; I found groups like that therapeutic. I also debate people online about their narratives when I'm angry, watching them 'repeat slogan after slogan until they block me,' which helps me remember that what they say about me as a detransitioner doesn't matter. I've described this community as 'as much a political space as it is a support space.' I try to affirm the parts of my identity that matter — my skill in art, my skill in work, my writing — because those aren't socially ascribed, so nobody can take them away. I advise others not to run away from being a detransitioner, but to look at it the same way they once looked at running from being a woman: 'you have another shot at loving a version of your body/self that you and/or society feel is wrong or incomplete.'