Alle verhalen

De vrouwelijke puberteit ontvluchten, en daarna de woorden ervoor vinden

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd968
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, homoseksueel, gendernonconformistisch en autistisch, die deels is getransitioneerd door geïnternaliseerde homofobie en de wens te ontsnappen aan de seksualisering van de vrouwelijke puberteit. Het lezen van radicaal-feministische theorie, vooral Andrea Dworkin, hielp me mijn dysforie te begrijpen als geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat, en hoewel mijn dysforie niet is verdwenen, komt die nu in golven in plaats van als een constante put van wanhoop. Ik worstel nog met lichaamsdysmorfie en had in 2023 soms suïcidale gedachten die samenhingen met de wens een knappe man te zijn. Ik verwerp de cis/trans-tweedeling en baseer mijn zelfbeeld nu op vrouw zijn als biologische realiteit in plaats van een gevoel. Ik raad jongeren actief af medisch te transitioneren en pleit voor radicaal-feministische analyse van gender.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I am autistic. Growing up I struggled a lot with how growing into a woman tainted my innocence — the perfect child self I wanted to stay as forever. Seemingly overnight my body became pornography; I felt dirty. Boys went from playmates to predators very quickly, and I felt my body wasn't mine anymore. I had dysphoria throughout my teen and adult years, along with body dysmorphia. Part of what pushed me toward transition was internalized homophobia: I wanted to become the heterosexual son my Catholic parents would have been proud of to bring a girl home. A bi girl I liked a lot told me she would marry me if only I were a guy, which hurt badly. For a long time I thought I was attracted to guys because I got obsessive about male actors and musicians, but there was never sexual desire in it — just a fantasy of being them: charismatic, strong, tall, handsome, with women swooning over me, and being heterosexual most of all. I also fell for depictions of transition in art, always portrayed as a breaking of the cage, and I liked how media portrayed transition as a kind of suicide — the old self dying and a better person rising from the ashes like a phoenix, the idea you can self-harm your way to happiness, a feeling of martyrdom. The trans community offered kinship, shelter and understanding at the time. I transitioned and lived as a man. I chose not to pursue bottom surgery, partly because as an avid horse rider I prioritized safety and my passion — bottom surgery and horse riding sounded like a painful accident waiting to happen. After detransitioning I described myself as a 'post-trans masculinized woman' and noted my voice had deepened: other detransitioners told me I sounded like a trans man rather than someone who went through a male puberty, and that people without an ear for nuance would gender me male, and that my voice probably would not lighten much on its own. I accepted that as being 'just a woman with a deep voice now.' What moved me toward detransition was reading feminist literature, particularly Andrea Dworkin. I wrote that only once I started reading feminist literature did the mist part and I could see clearly why I'd been hurting. Learning about misogyny and how it permeates culture was healing: it made me realize the loaded thoughts I had about my body and myself — that I am weak compared to men, that I am a failed woman because I don't want children, that I'm stupid, worthless and ugly — were not mine at all but were drilled into me by other people and by media. I now have a voice to challenge those thoughts when they bubble up. My dysphoria has not gone away and I'm not sure it ever will, but it has subsided; there are ups and downs now rather than just a deep pit of despair. I described it as always there but coming in waves, and said 'I'll never be okay and that's okay.' I currently identify as a woman — a homosexual, gender-nonconforming woman. I reject the cis/trans dichotomy, saying it implies you're either one or the other and asking what if I don't want to be involved in that worldview at all. I don't believe I'm anything other than a woman; I just don't fit the social role or stereotype because I dress masculine and I'm gay. I use 'gnc' to describe how I differ from other women without implying I'm trans. What clicked for me was acknowledging we humans are part of the animal world: 'I'm female in the same way a mare, a lioness, doe or cow is female. It's not about feeling like something, it's about BEING.' Mental health: I have struggled with dysphoria all my teen and adult years, and transitioning only made it worse. I have body dysmorphia intertwined with dysphoria — my fantasies are never about becoming a beautiful woman, but I would never swap my current body for that of an ugly guy either; my face features reside in an awful limbo, too bulbous to be attractive for a woman but too soft to be an attractive dude, and I avoid my reflection at all costs. In March 2023 I described my dysphoria as overwhelming, regularly breaking down crying knowing I'll never be a dude, and said 'I'm suicidal because I'm not a hot dude,' while acknowledging relatives would sneer that it's a narcissistic first-world problem. I told another struggling person to 'just try to stay alive.' I also said I sometimes feel like 'a shell of a human.' I found that focusing on doing and achieving things — drawing, making music, exercise, learning a new language, reading and writing stories — helps, reaching a transcendent state of focus where I forget I have a body at all. Sexuality: I am homosexual (a lesbian) and struggled with internalized homophobia for a long time. I still struggle with the fantasy of being a straight man loved by women — wanting to be the protector, the guardian, to be respected or even feared, to have a woman feel safe with me, and to have an uncomplicated neutral relationship with other men. I'm sick and tired of the visible disgust and contempt most men show towards a masculine woman. I said this struggle will probably never go away and not many people understand. Attitudes toward transition for others: I am not for banning transition, but I believe it should be scrutinized and criticized more, comparing it to how we can agree plastic surgery is majority shady malpractice driven by obsession with beauty and youth, mental illness and industry propaganda. I actively counsel young people against medical transition: I advise teens not to mess with their endocrine system until their brain is done developing, tell dysphoric young people that transition did not help me and that accepting myself alongside my dysphoria did, and I list medical risks of testosterone and surgeries (loss of libido, vaginal atrophy, necrotic neo-phalluses, increased diabetes and cholesterol risk, stroke and heart attack risk, nerve damage post mastectomy, painful clitoral growth, early dementia and organ prolapse post hysterectomy, early menopause). I have said the health risks are not an if but a when. I argue that transition is advertised as a cure-all for misogyny and homophobia and that the default answer to a lesbian's struggles should not be experimental drugs and plastic surgeries. I describe myself as a radical feminist who supports trans people's right to housing, healthcare, job security and safety from harm, but is against the gender movement as it is today, and I say 'how can I hate trans people when I used to be one of them?' I have engaged in extended advocacy and debate in detrans and radfem spaces throughout 2023-2025, arguing that biological sex is real, that gender is culturally constructed, and that radical feminism is a liberation movement for all female people. I have also argued that trans identification functions like a faith-based community with rituals and apostates to persecute, filling the void left by declining religion. Current status: I am a detransitioned, homosexual, gender-nonconforming woman who still experiences waves of dysphoria and body dysmorphia but manages them through feminist analysis, creative pursuits and self-acceptance.