Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw, al ben ik in mijn geval nooit echt getransitioneerd en desisteerde ik als kind. Als meisje van 10-13 (ongeveer 2009-2012) zei ik dat ik een jongen wilde zijn en mijn voortplantingsorganen wilde laten verwijderen, gedreven door pesten op een katholieke school en geïnternaliseerde misogynie uit online gamen, maar mijn moeder zag het als een fase en ik had nooit toegang tot hormonen. Ik groeide er overheen door te accepteren dat ik vrouw was, en ik bekritiseer nu genderideologie, non-binaire identiteit en gender-affirmerende zorg voor kinderen. Ik beheer mijn stemming met anticonceptie voor PMOS om de menstruatie over te slaan, aangezien dalingen in mijn oestrogeen depressie uitlokken. Ik heb geen spijt over medische transitie omdat ik er nooit een onderging.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female, and I'm a 27-year-old woman now. Looking back, my gender dysphoria started around ages 10-13, roughly during the years 2009-2012, and at the time I didn't even know what 'transgender' meant. I said all the things people now would call trans signs: 'I want to be a man. I should've been born a man. I want a penis. I want my ovaries uterus etc removed.'
What drove it, as far as I can tell, was a combination of bullying and internalized misogyny. I was bullied by all of the girls and by teachers at my Catholic school, people who were very different from me, and I had to get extensive therapy for the abuse I experienced. I didn't fit in, and seeing how toxic they were, I thought to myself, 'if that was what it meant to be a woman I want nothing of it.' On top of that, I played online games and was exposed to a ton of misogyny online, which I internalized 'to the highest degree.'
I'm grateful things didn't go further. My mom just saw it as a phase, and trans rhetoric wasn't around back then. I thank God I had no idea you could shoot up testosterone or use gel, etc., because I would have demanded that my parents do that for me. If I had been born later in life, I might have been one of the young girls who underwent medical transition — I see myself in them for sure. I never socially or medically transitioned; I never had access to hormones or surgery.
How I resolved my gender dysphoria was because I had no other choice but to accept that I was indeed a biological woman. It didn't happen overnight, but I realized at 13 that it was like wishing I was a unicorn — I would never be male. I also had zero knowledge of transgender procedures or hormones, so I just grew out of the fantasy. I acknowledge my experience is nowhere near as traumatic as other detransitioners who are biological women.
On mental health and mood: I take birth control for my PMOS (polycystic ovary syndrome) to skip my periods so my mood is stable. When my estrogen dips, my depression acts up and it's very unpleasant. I've asked others about mood off HRT because studies show low testosterone for males and low estrogen for females can cause depression.
I do believe gender-affirming care for children is medical malpractice, and I've told others who blame themselves for transitioning as teenagers that it is not their fault. I'm skeptical of non-binary identity — I've said I haven't met a mentally stable non-binary person in my life. I also don't understand what it means to 'feel like a man/woman' other than resorting to socially constructed gender stereotypes; you don't have to fit in any box thrust upon you by society. I'm critical of what I call gender ideology, and I've argued that detransitioners are more oppressed than trans people and that supporters of gender ideology are hypocritical for not recognizing that. I believe biological sex is real and sexually dimorphic — you can tell male and female skeletons apart — and I've pointed to sex-segregated sports as evidence. I also think most people in the West are gender-non-conforming to some extent and that trans and non-binary frameworks reduce everything to outdated 1940s gender roles. I do, however, support men wearing makeup and think heterosexual males have less freedom in that regard than semi-masculine women do.
I've recommended that people struggling with these feelings seek therapy with a non-gender-affirming approach — telling them their whole life history and traumas, ideally with an EMDR therapist — and I've said that if exploring why someone feels this way counts as conversion therapy, 'we are already lost.' I keep spiders as pets as a hobby and don't care about fitting in with society. I've also given someone advice that bangs make them look more feminine.