Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een man die serieus overwoog te transitioneren maar ervan afzag, grotendeels omdat mijn wens voor biologische kinderen en de vaderrol zwaarder weegt dan mijn wens om te transitioneren. Ik heb nooit hormonen genomen of een operatie gehad, en heb geen medische ingrepen, diagnoses of geestelijke gezondheidszorg beschreven. Ik ben kritisch over genderklinieken, de transgemeenschap en vooral MtF-onderlichaamsoperaties, al accepteer ik dat sommige mensen (met name degenen die ik autogynefiel noem) wel baat hebben bij transitie. Ik identificeer me momenteel niet als trans, al erken ik dat ik „sterk een sekse wil zijn waarmee ik niet geboren ben” en blijf ik in een onopgeloste positie. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I am male, born male, and I have never transitioned — I decided against it. I have spent a lot of time thinking about gender dysphoria, autogynephilia (AGP), autoandrophilia (AAP), and the Blanchard typology (HSTS versus AGP), and I have been active in communities where people debate whether to transition, including r/transmaxxing, r/askAGP, and detrans-related discussions.
I first started questioning my gender and considering transition at some point, but I never went through with hormones or surgery. I described myself as being "in a bad spot" because I want the dad role and biological children, and I said plainly: "I feel like my desire for biological children is stronger than my desire to transition." I also said, "I am not transitioning, at least not now." One concrete step I did take was trying online dating presenting as a woman; I wrote, "I decided against transitioning after trying online dating as a woman, almost all males were pathetic, less than 5% were any good." That experience apparently reinforced my decision not to transition.
My reasoning against transitioning for myself centers on fertility and on what medical transition can actually deliver. I have repeatedly said that bottom surgery options are bad — for MtF, SRS "would probably ruin anal sex since the neo-vagina would be created between the prostate and anus," and FtM bottom surgery options are "even worse." I told people that "most people (maybe 95%) who benefit from HrT will not benefit from SRS" and that "unless you suffer from really bad genital dysphoria you shouldn't have bottom surgery." I also noted that breast reduction surgery can leave a person unable to breastfeed, and that transition generally forecloses biological children.
I hold a fairly critical view of gender clinics and the trans community. I have written that "gender clinics know you are less likely to transition if you think it's AGP so they might lie to you and manipulate you into transitioning," and I called the situation "a fraud of industrial proportions," speculating that "research fraud" might have been done to push autogynephiles toward surgery. I also said psychiatry doesn't know how to treat these issues, "so they just offer you hormones and surgery instead." I have described the trans community as "in denial about the limitations of medical transition and the science in general" and said they "are not helpful to people at all."
At the same time, I do not oppose transition for everyone. I have said "I believe some people do benefit from transitioning, i am mostly talking about incels with autogynephilia," and "sexual reasons to transition are valid. Sex is a basic human need." I told one person to continue their transition and bank sperm, and I said I would date a detrans woman. On policy, I support transwomen using female bathrooms, citing a study, and I said I am "not going to throw transwomen under the bus." I also shared a personal detail: "I personally never shower naked with males since that would make me uncomfortable, the last time i was in a public shower room was when i visited iceland, i had to go against the rules and shower with shorts on."
I have discussed my own sexuality and sexual experiences candidly. I described being in a relationship where "i just didn't care about her while she put effort into making me satisfied, yea i am bad," and said that if a girl asked me to do something sexually I "would probably go too far in doing what she ask for." I have expressed a wish to know what having a female body is like: "i wish i could try having a female body myself to find out but that isn't possible." I have also speculated about my own psychology in terms of AGP/AAP, saying things like "if you have autoandrophilia it will probably be addictive since it will make your sex-drive stronger," and I recommended "frequent orgasms to keep the sex-drive down" as a strategy, along with pointing people to r/askAGP.
On causes, I lean toward a partly innate but not fully determined account. I have cited studies arguing "gender identity isn't fully innate (it's at most 60% innate)" and that some people adapt to having a brain of the opposite sex while others develop dysphoria. I believe gender dysphoria "usually fades after puberty" for many, and I have recommended exposure therapy as an experimental option, while cautioning it "could also make things even worse."
I have not described undergoing therapy myself, nor any diagnoses, medications, surgeries, or medical complications. I have not described suicidal ideation, self-harm, or a suicide attempt. My main stated regrets or sorrows are about being stuck: wanting biological children and the dad role while also wanting to be a different sex, which I called "a bad spot."