Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die uit de kast kwam als trans (FTM, daarna non-binair) terwijl ik te maken had met onbehandeld seksueel trauma en geïnternaliseerd vrouwenhaat, en rond mijn 20e besefte dat transitie niet voor mij was voordat ik iets blijvends deed. Ik identificeer me nu diep met vrouwelijkheid en voel me comfortabel in mijn lichaam, terwijl ik gendernonconform blijf. Ik geloof dat echte genderdysforie bestaat en dat transitie voor sommige mensen passend kan zijn nadat onderliggende factoren als trauma, BPS en geïnternaliseerd seksisme zijn uitgesloten en behandeld. Ik ben kritisch over hoe non-binaire identiteit voor vrouwen wordt gedefinieerd en over de plaatsing ervan onder de trans-paraplu, en ik heb vaak aangehaalde detransitiestatistieken bekritiseerd. Ik maak me zorgen dat detransitie cultureel onder het tapijt wordt geveegd, en vergelijk een mogelijke toekomstige afrekening met hoe we nu naar lobotomieën kijken.
Volledig verhaal
I came out as trans while I was dealing with untreated sexual trauma and internalized misogyny. Being a woman felt unsafe to me at that point — I no longer felt like my body was my own — and I now understand that what I experienced was dissociation and dysmorphia rather than a true diagnosis of gender dysphoria. Disconnecting from my female body like that was my brain protecting me.
I moved from identifying as FTM to identifying as nonbinary, and I think the line of thinking that led me there was the idea that if you don't fit a list of stereotypical "womanly" traits that fit into a neat little box, then maybe you aren't really a woman at all. I had a realization when I was about 20 that this wasn't for me and that I needed to slam the brakes before I did something permanent that was not right for me. By that point I was already on my way out anyway, having switched from FTM to nonbinary. I returned to identifying with my birth sex after confronting my traumas rather than running from them with drugs, alcohol, and various labels.
I don't state anywhere in this record that I took hormones or had any surgeries — I described wanting to stop before doing anything permanent, so I have no medical interventions to report. I am still pretty gender non-conforming and don't adhere to sexist stereotypes, but that doesn't make me less of a woman for not fitting into a cookie-cutter box of "what it means to be a woman." I am now comfortable in my body and identify deeply with womanhood; it brings me joy to be at this point in my life.
On the broader question, I firmly believe true gender dysphoria is 100% real and that transitioning can help those people, but underlying factors need to be ruled out first, just like any other medical treatment. By underlying factors I mean stuff like internalized sexism, mental disorders that cause identity disturbance such as BPD, and sexual abuse related PTSD. I feel like when all those factors are ruled out and treated properly, then yes, transitioning is right for that person if they truly want it and nothing else has worked. I have always believed the criteria is true gender dysphoria followed by a transition — gender dysphoria on its own doesn't make you trans, but going through a transition does by definition. I am in full support of people living their best lives, including people who are nonbinary, but I have yet to hear a definition of nonbinary (specifically geared towards females) that isn't just blatantly sexist stereotypes. My main issue is lumping nonbinary under the "trans umbrella" when they are ideologically incompatible — MTF/FTM are within the gender binary, from one to the other, which is inherently different from something literally called "nonbinary." I think it would be simpler if people admitted it is a political GNC identity that rejects gender roles and gendered presentation rather than an actual gender.
I wrote a post critiquing commonly cited detrans statistics, noting that the "only 2% detransition" figure comes from a study observing trans-identified children around age 6-8 over a 5-year period, ending when they were only about 11-13, and mostly involved social transition rather than puberty blockers. I pointed out that a lot of people didn't realize identifying as trans wasn't for them until 18-25, and that the "0.01-0.04% detrans" figure came from a Canadian study in 1989 that doesn't hold up mathematically given the rapid increase observed globally. I cited a UK study showing a 4,400% increase in FTM children seeking gender reassignment surgery and a 1000% increase in MTF children from 2009-2019, and a CDC study showing ages 13-25 make up 7.6% of the U.S. population but 18% of transgender-identified Americans since 2017. I emphasized we simply don't know the current detransition rate and that I firmly believe transition can be helpful for individuals 18+ who have been evaluated properly and screened for underlying conditions. I explicitly stated I was not trying to prove a point in any direction, just providing up-to-date information with context.
I have expressed pessimism about how detransition will be handled culturally, predicting it will be "neatly brushed under the rug," that policymakers will quietly change things, that media will move on, and that people will be left to suffer in silence. I compared the possibility of future reckoning to how we talk about lobotomies now, hoping that maybe 20-40 years down the line people will recognize what happened and that procedures will be better regulated.
In giving advice to others, I have encouraged therapy, told someone their expectations were unhealthy and unrealistic, told someone they had serious internalized homophobia to work through before deciding on transition, and told another person that outside of biological sex, gender identity is a social construct and "a performance." I have also encouraged someone questioning whether they were nonbinary or just a GNC female, telling them their mom and friends don't get to decide who they are. I have supported someone's detransition journey, telling them they were "def more female" and wishing them well.
I don't describe any mental health diagnoses of my own beyond referencing trauma, dissociation, and dysmorphia in my own history, nor do I describe therapy I personally underwent beyond recommending it to others. I don't describe family reactions, relationships, sexuality, or advocacy work beyond posting on Reddit.