Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw en van nature masculiene butch lesbienne die sinds mijn kindertijd dissociërende genderdysforie had en een endocriene stoornis met kleine gestalte en hoge testosteron. Ik begon op mijn 20e met testosteron en gebruikte het een paar jaar, samen met topchirurgie en lichaamsmasculinisering, waar ik geen spijt van heb omdat het mijn dysforie verlichtte, maar HRT veroorzaakte ernstige gezondheidsproblemen, waaronder stadium 2 hypertensie, hoog hemoglobine, hoog cortisol met paniekstoornis, eierstokpijn, diabetes en problemen met bloeddikte. Ik detransitioneerde om medische redenen en omdat ik besefte dat ik nooit biologisch man zou zijn, en hoewel ik pas ongeveer twee maanden in medische detransitie zit en nog te maken heb met gewrichtspijn en onvolledig herstel, voelt accepteren dat ik vrouw ben op lange termijn gezonder. Ik heb mijn vader uit mijn leven geschrapt vanwege zijn afwijzing van het feit dat ik op meisjes val, en ik heb gemeenschap gevonden via butch lesbische Discord-servers, die ik heb helpen modereren. Ik steun medische transitie voor sommige mensen, maar ben kritisch over de druk op genderonconforme mensen om te transitioneren en over „egg culture”.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and have had dissociating gender dysphoria since I was a kid. I also have an endocrine disorder that caused disproportionate short stature and high testosterone — the women in my family are 5'8-6'2, but I'm 5'0 and was often presumed to be a child. Growing up, people were always confused by me, even back when my parents made me wear long hair and makeup.
My freshman year of college I lived in the LGBT dorm; out of 34 of us, only 3 (including myself) didn't identify as trans or nonbinary. I started testosterone at age 20 in excellent physical health — normal BMI, exercising 4-5 times per week, healthy diet — with only a well-controlled endocrine disorder. I was on T for a couple of years. I had top surgery and body masculinization as well.
HRT caused significant health problems for me: it raised my cortisol, blood pressure, and hemoglobin to very high levels regardless of dose, and exacerbated my endocrine disorder. I developed stage 2 hypertension (from a normal 105/65), high hemoglobin near blood clotting territory, high cortisol (which gave me panic disorder despite having no prior psychiatric disorder), and ovary pain I'd never experienced before HRT. Later I also dealt with diabetes and blood thickness issues. I also found that testosterone made me pass much less frequently as male, because at 5'0 it made me look like a trans man instead of a young guy — growing a beard made me look like a 15-year-old instead of an 11-year-old. Realizing some changes weren't 1:1 with cis males made me dysphoric.
I detransitioned partially for medical reasons, but also because I would never be a biological male and that's what I really wanted. I don't regret transitioning at all — HRT and top surgery repaired much of the dissociating disconnect I'd had since childhood, and I don't regret top surgery, body masculinization, or HRT. But I also feel that accepting I'm female rather than spending my whole life trying to change it is healthier long-term. I'm still dressing and acting however I want — I'm a naturally masculine butch lesbian, and I like the body and facial hair, deeper voice, bigger nose/hands/feet from T, though I miss the male fat/muscle distribution. I haven't recovered completely from the side effects since going off T.
Around two months into medical detransition I was experiencing joint pain and debating whether to take birth control to help with it. Off testosterone my voice lost some rasp, and I'm read as mostly female now despite no change in presentation — though I've gotten advice to work on resonance and speaking mannerisms if I want to be read as female.
Family has been difficult. I'm hesitant to believe my parents really loved me unconditionally because they stopped guiding, hugging, kissing, and looking at me when all I did was admit I like girls. To this day my dad says he doesn't like being around me because I disgust me — those words were shared by my sister. I cut my father out of my life the moment I moved out and my life has been significantly better since.
I've been approached and accused of being perverted or in the wrong place when in women's spaces multiple times, and most LGB women I've seen tend to avoid me. I spent time in a lesbian radical feminist Discord server but realized it was more about hostility towards men than community, and none of them were butch. I haven't ever tried integrating into in-person butch communities, which I think may be part of the problem. Joining a few Discord servers for butch lesbians helped me towards the start of my detransition — it gave me that sense of community without the need to pass. I have moderated a butch Discord in the past and was working on setting up a new one to send links to people privately.
I believe there are some people who may benefit most from medical transition, but they are a minority, because modern transgender ideology relies largely on gender roles and stereotypes. The majority of trans people I've interacted with both online and in real life are ashamed of their birth sex, hold sexist attitudes on gender, and will admit in some way that stereotypes motivated their transition to some extent. My issue is not about people transitioning — T improved my physical dysphoria in some aspects that I still think was best for me — but rather the pressure against gender nonconforming people to transition, including 'egg culture' that treats young females wanting to wear suits and get male haircuts, or young males wanting to feel beautiful and soft, as trans. I've seen a lot of ftm/ftnb people with internalized homophobia and misogyny, running from feeling vulnerable. Many gender nonconforming kids had 'trans' experiences, so it makes sense it spreads given that transgender identity is treated as unique to cisgender gender nonconforming experiences.
I'm considerably masculine and get told by people that I am trans in denial, that I will regret detransitioning when I'm older. I find r/butchlesbians sad to visit because it reminds me that you don't need to be a 'non-woman' to do gender-stereotypical activities. I think there is a lack of female masculinity in our society due to mainstream gender ideology, which is very isolating. I'm here specifically to support other detrans people, and I believe it's unhealthy to describe a life as 'ruined' — detrans people can have fulfilling lives post-transition.