Alle verhalen

Vier jaar twijfelen, en dan kiezen om te blijven

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd311
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een vrouw van 21 die zich al ongeveer vier jaar afvraagt of ik FTM ben, met aanhoudende borstdysforie, onbehagen over mijn stem en het gevoel dat mijn aantrekking tot mannen ‘van een andere man’ komt. Na vier maanden intensief jezelf in twijfel trekken ben ik afgestapt van het idee van een aangeboren genderidentiteit en zie ik dysforie nu als een psychische aandoening met meerdere oorzaken, waarvan ik denk dat de meeste onderzocht kunnen worden zonder transitie. Ik ben niet sociaal of medisch getransitioneerd en bevind me momenteel in een twijfel-/richting-desistance-fase, waarin ik mijn gevoelens langzaam verwerk en therapie overweeg. Ik vermoed angst en depressie, maar heb geen diagnose. Nu heb ik gendercritische opvattingen en pleit ik voor zorgvuldig, niet-bevestigend onderzoek voordat iemand transitioneert, terwijl ik antidiscriminatiebescherming blijf steunen voor volwassenen die ervoor kiezen als het andere geslacht te leven.

Volledig verhaal

I'm 21 and I've been questioning whether I'm FTM for about four years now. I have a lot of what people call textbook symptoms: I like being called a male name, I'd love a flat chest, I want to be perceived as male, I want a deeper voice and facial hair, and I don't mind the other side effects of testosterone. When my female traits are pointed out, they feel like they aren't mine. I've tried to argue myself out of it. I don't think it's body dysmorphia or low self-esteem, because even if I were the most physically fit and attractive woman tomorrow, it would still feel off. If I had everything I wanted in life but was still a woman, it would still feel off. I don't think internalized misogyny quite explains it either, since I feel out of place in things meant to empower women. I had no traumatic experience related to my gender — being seen as a man wouldn't be "running away" from any trauma, and I have no illusions it would ameliorate anything. The chest thing has actually always been there. I remember asking my mom why my chest was hurting and hating when she explained it was growing. That's the main source of my "dysphoria" — I look in the mirror and imagine my chest without breasts and it always feels better, like they're an extra addition that isn't part of me. My voice is the next closest thing; it feels too high. Less intense but present are feeling like I have too feminine a face and fat distribution. I get "bottom dysphoria" too, but I could never do bottom surgery, so it's out of the question. My attraction to men feels like it's coming from another guy, not a girl, and it doesn't feel right to not be perceived that way. I'd want my partner to see me as a man. I enjoy being feminine sometimes, but I'd want to be seen as a feminine/gay man rather than a woman — which I find odd since the former is less acceptable. I like the accessories and fun outfits, but whenever I'm reminded they're on a woman, it feels wrong. I'd prefer mixed-gender groups over "girlies" or "bros" — neither feels right. When a group project turns into "oh look we're all women!" it doesn't sit right (though restrooms might be tough). I don't get sexual gratification from this. I looked into autoheterosexual.com's writing on autoandrophilia and was confused about how to tell apart "emotional" AAP from plain gender dysphoria, since the sexual aspect isn't strong for me — I'd still want to be seen as a man even if it meant I never had a partner. I suspect I have anxiety and depression but haven't been diagnosed. I'm not overweight, not a gym girl, no major body issues surrounding weight, overall healthy. I grew up religious and had to teach myself critical thinking and evidence-based knowledge, which is why the "unquestionable" nature of an inherent trans identity set off red flags for me. Over four exhaustive but productive months of questioning, my views changed a lot. I used to think it was wild that so many people were "transphobic" — I was especially confused when big-name atheist commentators like Dawkins and Sam Harris held gender-critical views, since they were supposed to value rationality. Now I don't think there are inherently trans people; there are people with a real and strong desire to transition to living as the opposite sex, which is observable. I don't think there's hard biological evidence for a "trans brain." Gender dysphoria describes a psychological condition where a person feels persistently distressed due to their sex, and it can develop for multiple reasons, as with most mental illnesses. Self-exploration, reflection, and support can help alleviate it. I think the existence of transitioning people is inherently tied to the existence of gender roles. You can transition from one social role to another, but you can never change your sex. I define a woman two ways at once: an adult human female, and a person who assumes the societal role of woman. Most women are both; trans women can only be the second. I think for most people the answer is not transition, and the affirmative method is counter-productive at best. Bottom surgery in its current form is terrifying. Children cannot consent to physical interventions. For adults it's a question of personal autonomy, and I'd support non-discrimination laws — but people aren't entitled to others seeing them as the opposite sex if they don't pass. Looking back, I'd always only related to male characters and used gay love stories as escapism because the characters were actually interesting — the relationships were equal and built on respect. When I stopped and asked myself why I wanted to be a gay man, the answer was that I wanted respect: to be valued for my competence, skills, insights, argument, and clarity of thought, not my looks or emotions or empathy. I wish women weren't assumed to be incompetent; I wish being an old woman sounded as nice as being an old bearded man. Most of this is misogyny, but my traits do match more with average male traits, which doesn't make me any less of a woman — it connects me to a long line of women in history who felt the same. It just makes it tough to relate to other women around me, and I trust I'll work through this. I hate that the sexes are different and I'm still dealing with it. I still wish everyone was sex-blind. I would rather learn to live with the truth than be comforted by a lie. In retrospect, some alarm bells should have gone off when 80% of the profiles in my online circles went from she/her to he/they overnight. I used to get upset that it's impossible to find an equal hetero relationship, but it's just rare and hard to find. My plan is to take this very slow — spending time rationalizing and working out my own thoughts, seeing a therapist, and working through underlying issues. I'm not here to be diagnosed; I just want a space to talk things out that won't boil down to "you're 100% trans king!" I've advised others questioning to be as specific as possible about their feelings — what exactly are they envious of, physical strength, societal treatment, male attitudes? Learning to accept what I can't control (biology, beauty standards, how people view women vs. men) and focus on what I can (getting stronger, more confident, healthier) has helped, and that envy has been decreasing ever since. I've also shared the HHS gender dysphoria report link with others.