Alle verhalen

Wat ze las als dysforie was een wens om aan de mannelijke blik te ontsnappen

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd127
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich ooit als trans identificeerde, grotendeels gedreven door lichaamsdysmorfie, een cluster B-persoonlijkheidsstoornis en onbehagen over de seksualisering en seksistische verwachtingen die jonge vrouwen worden opgelegd. Ik besefte dat wat ik als genderdysforie had gelezen eigenlijk de wens was om niet als lustobject gezien te worden en als individu gewaardeerd te worden, en consistente gespecialiseerde therapie plus medicatie verminderden mijn verlangen om te transitioneren grotendeels. Ik heb een voorgeschiedenis van seksuele aanranding en omschrijf mezelf als een ‘schoolvoorbeeld van een cluster B-wrak’ dat nu in behandeling is. Ik steun het bestaan van legitieme transmensen met echte dysforie, maar ben kritisch op wat ik zie als overdiagnose bij jonge vrouwen, en ik raad anderen actief aan om een grondig psychiatrisch onderzoek te laten doen voor ze medisch transitioneren. In dit verhaal heb ik geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female, and my story is one of thinking I was trans for a while before realizing it wasn't the right path for me. Looking back, the roots of it were in body dysmorphia — I genuinely believed I wasn't pretty enough to be a woman. My mantra about myself was, "you can put lipstick on a pig, but its still a pig." I now see that as less about anything actually wrong with me and more about the crushing expectations placed on young girls to be desirable, which I've called "truly evil." I've also described myself as, in my own words, "a textbook cluster B basket case," and I'm currently in treatment for a Cluster B disorder. I've said I showed signs long before I was assaulted, so there's a history of sexual assault in my background as well. I've noted that I also had rampant untreated BDD (body dysmorphic disorder) and a personality disorder that impacts identity. I've observed that a lot of women in the communities I've engaged with come from abusive backgrounds, and I've been frustrated that I can't openly study that connection at university without risking my spot for "entertaining 'bigotry.'" I've been quite vocal about my belief that BPD is over-diagnosed in young girls who more clearly show signs of C-PTSD or autism, calling it "modern day hysteria." What moved me toward detransition was getting into specialized therapy and being medicated consistently for a couple of years — I've said that pretty much alleviated my desire to transition. Before that, I changed my mind on the topic about five times before I settled. I've urged others considering transition to get a full psych evaluation, not at a gender clinic, but with an actual psychiatrist and psychologist, and to explore root causes like BDD before pursuing surgery, warning that otherwise "you will get the surgery and find something else to obsess over." A big part of what drove my trans identification was, I realized, not wanting to be seen as a sex object — which made me subconsciously despise my body and womanhood. I've written that "being a man sounds new and exciting, i'd love to wake up one day as a man because life seems so much greener on the other side...people wouldn't look at me like i'm a walking fleshlight. I could simply exist as a human." I wanted to be an individual and be seen as such the way men are, to "live life carelessly as a man," to have a fun career title not starting with "female" and be known for my contributions rather than for being a woman in my field. I've concluded that "the desire to be a person didn't make me trans like I thought originally." On physical specifics, I've mentioned having large breasts and discomfort from them, and I said I was honestly still considering a reduction, though chest workouts helped with the discomfort. I've also commented that a voice can be "absolutely female sounding, yes deep female voice but tons of bio women have that without taking testosterone," though it's not clear from my own account whether I took testosterone myself. I've spoken about femininity and not feeling like "a woman in the same way they are" as exactly why I thought I was trans. Sexuality-wise, I've suggested to others that sometimes the drive to transition can be about not wanting to be seen as gay, and I've said that the life of a trans woman is not easy and that people would still wrongfully consider a trans woman a gay man. I believe trans people with legit dysphoria exist and I don't hate trans people, but I also believe there is an overwhelming amount of young women who are more so uncomfortable with the idea of what a woman should be — a sexist box only a select few women can fit into. I've said I "don't see the transphobia" in examining societal issues affecting young women, and that both legitimate trans people and people like me can simultaneously exist. Currently, I identify as a detransitioned woman. I've found community in detrans spaces, saying "It's nice here." I've been an active voice advising others — particularly young people — not to make life-altering choices before their brains are done developing at 25, and to do a deep dive into why they want to transition before anything else. I've said that if someone doesn't have extreme gender dysphoria growing up, especially hitting puberty, and describes none of that, they should seriously question other motivations, because "if you don't have that, you will ultimately regret it." I've compared gender dysphoria to BDD as the closest related disorder, and I've been careful to distinguish between actual trans people with dysphoria and what I see as over-diagnosis or socially-driven identification among young women.