Alle verhalen

Ze zag een Discord-server zichzelf transitioneren

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd352
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw, als vrouw geboren, identificeer me als biologische vrouw en heb in deze berichten nooit beschreven dat ik zelf een transitie heb ondergaan. Mijn betrokkenheid was die van criticus: ik verliet een Discord-server waar meerdere biologische mannen na elkaar zich als trans identificeerden, wat ik toeschreef aan escapisme, de wens om je bijzonder te voelen en autisme, in plaats van een echte transidentiteit. Ik werd verbannen van een trans-subreddit omdat ik erop wees dat een moderator niet-haatdragende verwarring als transfobie bestempelde en tegelijk anderen vroeg te stoppen hen lastig te vallen. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over genderideologie, waaronder dat gender niet echt is, terwijl ik zeg dat intersekse mensen acceptatie verdienen. In dit materiaal heb ik geen medische ingrepen, psychische aandoeningen of persoonlijke spijt beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I currently identify as a woman — I describe myself as a biological woman. I have never described transitioning myself in these posts; my involvement with this community has been as someone commenting on other people's situations and on broader cultural and political questions around gender. My most substantive personal account concerns a Discord server I was part of. It was a tight-knit group with many biological males, and I watched a striking pattern: once one of them started identifying as trans, quite a few of the others followed. I came away from that convinced that only one or two of them were genuinely trans (one biological male, one biological female). I felt the rest were identifying as trans to escape difficult lives or futures, or to feel special, and that many were, in my assessment, a little to very autistic rather than trans. I left that server about a year before August 2023, and I noted that I heavily question what kinds of servers and online content other young people in similar situations are being exposed to. I've also expressed alarm at the idea of a child having an 'internet mom,' calling it a red flag. I've had direct conflict with trans community moderation online. In January 2024 I intervened in an argument between a trans subreddit moderator and someone who had said simply that they were not trans and did not understand trans people but had nothing against them — nothing hateful or denigrating. The moderator escalated, called the person transphobic, and banned them. I pointed out a contradiction: the same moderator had a large post asking others to stop harassing and doxxing them just for being trans, which I agreed was fair, yet they were themselves continuing to escalate an argument and labeling disagreement as hatred. I was instantly banned. I later recounted a similar ban where I had said trans people absolutely deserve not to be harassed — they were getting a lot of hate — but that saying 'I don't understand why anyone would be trans' is not hateful, just a lack of understanding. I concluded the moderator was 'chronically/terminally online.' I took these bans in stride: 'nothing lost except being able to comment.' I hold critical views of certain aspects of gender discourse. I've said I believe gender isn't real. On intersex people, I've said they deserve understanding and acceptance, but that biologically speaking it's 'a fuckup made by nature.' I've been told my views are far right and pushed back, saying that sharing a personal experience and connecting it only to myself is not far right. I've also commented that growing up means accepting you'll eventually stop speaking to some people who were part of your life. I have not described any medical transition, hormones, surgeries, therapy, mental health diagnoses, trauma, family dynamics, sexuality, or personal regret in these posts, so I cannot speak to those from this record.