Alle verhalen

Bondgenoot van buiten, kijkend naar een opkomende golf van rechtszaken

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd31
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een cisgender vrouw die nooit is getransitioneerd; ik post als trans-bondgenoot die zeer kritisch is over hoe jongeren die aan hun gender twijfelen medisch worden beoordeeld. Ik steun mensen die uit de kast komen en vrij leven, maar ik denk dat veel jonge vrouwen lichaamsdysmorfie als gevolg van seksuele intimidatie aanzien voor genderdysforie en daarna onomkeerbare operaties ondergaan waar ze spijt van krijgen. Ik ben boos op gendertherapeuten, Tavistock/de NHS en transactivisten, en ik verwacht een golf van rechtszaken. Ik heb geen persoonlijke dysforie, transitie, psychische aandoening of suïcidale gedachten beschreven.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I have never identified as transgender myself — I describe myself as a cisgender ally to the trans community, and I want to be clear that I am not a TERF and I have never intended to hurt anyone with my words. My engagement with this community has been as an outside observer and supporter. Early on, in January 2020, I read a story that moved me deeply; I called it "extremely powerful writing" and told the person who wrote it that if she was that little girl, I love her. A day later I was encouraging another person to come out, telling them never to care about what others think because it is their life, their happiness and their body, and that they would still suffer by staying in the closet: "BE FREE, BE HAPPY, WITH NO RESTRAINTS." By late February 2020 my tone had shifted to anger at the medical and therapeutic system. I ranted that the medical departments are partly at fault, that so-called gender therapists lack proper qualifications because ethical psychologists have quit, and I cited the figure that roughly 38 doctors had left the Tavistock's gender identity service in three years because they disagreed with self-identification. I argued that the DSM cannot unequivocally define dysphoria, and that in many cases people are mistaking body dysmorphia for gender dysphoria and being left with lifelong, unnecessary dysphoria. I was frustrated at being dictated to and degraded, saying I am an extremely reasonable person but am treated badly twenty times a day, and asked where the equality in that is. Shortly after, I laid out my understanding of why young women transition: from what I have seen online, the detransitioning women in the community tend to be in their early twenties and now identify as lesbian or bisexual, and they wanted to escape their female bodies and identities around puberty, after adult men had sexually harassed them at some point in their lives. They described feeling disgusting, and concluded that if that is what being a woman means — and at a young age you assume these things are permanent, since the brain is not fully developed until around 25 — they would rather be a man. I said it breaks my heart to read stories of women who have had their breasts removed or a hysterectomy by age 20 and up, and that I cannot wait for the day when this is decriminalised for children, calling it as bad as or worse than gay conversion therapy, which is illegal. I framed the whole situation as sad for both the trans community and for women, and for anyone oppressed by what I called a misogynistic movement. In March 2020 I predicted that "the wave of lawsuits are beginning" against the NHS. I also said I found it highly offensive when trans activists compare intersex individuals to transgender individuals. Later that month I offered my opinion on why some trans people react badly to detransitioners: it makes them feel less valid, because people are now saying transition did not work, which forces them to ask themselves "am I really transgender?" and that scares them — while stressing again that this is my opinion only, no TERF here, not scared or phobic of any human being. In May 2020 I returned to encouraging someone to come out, saying the sooner you do it the easier it will be in the long term. I have not described any personal experience of dysphoria, transition, hormones or surgery, and I have not described any therapy, mental health diagnosis, adversity, relationships or sexuality of my own. What I have offered is sustained advocacy: I support people coming out and living freely, while I am sharply critical of the medicalisation of gender-questioning young people, of inadequate therapeutic assessment, and of what I see as a misogynistic movement that harms young women's bodies.