Alle verhalen

Orthodoxe opvoeding, en dysforie die met de leeftijd verdween

Vrouw · Gedetransitioneerd96
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die orthodox-joods is opgegroeid en kritisch is over conversietherapie, over de druk richting hormonen als enige behandelweg en over ouders die hun kinderen onder druk zetten om te transitioneren (zoals ik zag in de show van Jazz Jennings). Ik geloof dat genderdysforie een psychische aandoening is, maar dat daar geen schaamte bij hoort en dat eerlijk onderzoek de beste weg is voor mensen die denken dat ze trans zijn. Ik heb verteld dat mijn eigen onzekerheid als tiener en mijn lichaamsdysforie grotendeels met de leeftijd verdwenen. Ik raad twijfelende jongeren aan om diepere oorzaken te onderzoeken en te wachten voordat ze medisch transitioneren. Ik denk niet dat transitie altijd verkeerd is, voor sommigen is het de juiste keuze, maar het moet niet overhaast gebeuren.

Volledig verhaal

I grew up Orthodox Jewish, and that background shapes a lot of what I say about conversion therapy — I know people from that community who went through it, and I've seen firsthand how abusive and wrong their practices are. They have zero interest in genuinely helping people; their only intent is to keep people religious and to guilt them into thinking homosexuality is wrong. I've been clear that these practices are really about homosexuality, not about trans people, and that they want to drag us back to the dark ages. I'm critical of how gender dysphoria gets discussed. I've argued that it's pretty ridiculous when people insist being trans isn't a mental illness, when clearly it is — and that there's nothing shameful about that. To me, mental illness is not shameful, and trying to insist it isn't one actually promotes the demonization of mental illness. At the same time, I think the first priority has to be doing what's best for people who believe they're trans, and worrying about what transphobes think isn't relevant. Whether it's a mental illness or not, we owe it to trans people to genuinely explore the topic in order to best provide the treatment they need; not doing so only harms trans people further. I'm skeptical of how transition gets pushed. I've said there's a concerted effort to push hormones specifically and not to seek out other avenues of treatment, and that homophobes have infiltrated the movement under the guise of trans. I watched one episode of the Jazz Jennings show and couldn't bear it — the mother is literally pressuring Jazz into everything, and it's hard not to wonder if Jazz really ever wanted any of it. I've also talked to people questioning transition. When a teenager told me they still never pass as a boy and that it's crushing sometimes, I asked them why they wanted to transition and why they were convinced transition was the solution to their struggles. I told them that pretty much no teenager feels confident and that's normal, and that as a teenager I had zero confidence and a lot of body dysphoria, but as I grew older that mostly went away — not necessarily everyone's experience, but it was mine. I said it's worth exploring the deeper reasons why they want to transition and, at the very least, giving it more time before medically transitioning. I don't believe transition is always wrong — I think for some people it's the right choice — but you want to be sure of it before going through with it.