Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, lesbische, gendernonconformistische vrouw die mijn eigen transitie nu zie als een fout die ik maakte toen ik kwetsbaar was – ik had depressie, autisme en een geschiedenis van gepest worden omdat ik GNC was – en ik zeg botweg 'ik ben erin getrapt. Ik was een idioot.' Ik schrijf het aan COVID toe dat ik uit de transitie kwam. Ik ben sterk kritisch over gender-bevestigende zorg, over het idee dat sekse kan worden geherdefinieerd en over de bewering dat niet-bevestiging zelfmoord veroorzaakt, en die punten verdedig ik online. Ik beschrijf geen specifieke medische ingrepen of onomkeerbare veranderingen, maar mijn spijt is intens en voelt als bedrogen zijn. Na de detransitie meld ik geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I am a detransitioned, gay, gender-nonconforming woman. I came out as trans at some point in my life, socially and medically transitioned, and then got myself out of it — I credit Covid with helping me do that. I now look back on the whole thing with blunt self-criticism: "I was a moron and I'm not afraid of admitting it... I was had. I was an idiot. I'm just glad I got myself out of it."
Before I transitioned I already had a stack of co-factors that I think made me vulnerable. I was gender non-conforming from a young age, I'm gay, and I was bullied growing up for being GNC. I also had depression and autism. I don't have exact ages for when the dysphoria started, when I came out, or when I started or stopped hormones — I never laid those out — but I do know the transition happened and ended before June 2022, and that the COVID period was when I extricated myself.
I don't frame my transition as a free, fully informed choice. When someone pushed me on whether people really choose to end up in these situations, I compared it to joining a cult or ending up in an abusive relationship: "Do you believe every person who joins a cult or ends up in an abusive relationship really chooses those things, especially people who are already vulnerable due to mental health, trauma or neurodivergency?" I extended that to gender identity itself — I asked my interlocutor to "explain to me where the idea of a gender identity comes from," implying it's implanted or indoctrinated rather than innate. I also said I do think "there are some evil people motivated to do harm to others with trans ideology," while being careful not to claim everyone involved is malicious. I raised the claim about WPATH founders belonging to "child castration fetish groups" and linked to a reduxx.info article as evidence.
I'm strongly critical of the medical and psychological establishment around gender. I brought up Diane Ehrensaft, describing her as "the leading psychologist responsible for the satanic panic in the 80s" who now is "one of the leading voices in 'gender affirming care'," and I used that to argue there's a pattern of the same people running damaging moral panics and experimental therapies in both eras. I'm skeptical of the claim that not affirming someone will make them suicidal. I asked: "If not affirming them means they'll kill themselves, where are all the tons of known 'crossdressing' aka trans people who unalived from not being affirmed in history?" My argument is that historical gender-nonconforming figures — "a trans noble from somewhere - like france during the sun king, or china in the tan dynasty, or some prince of the nubian empire" — weren't trans in the modern affirmative sense; they were GNC and "internalized that they were some kind of 'other' as a coping mechanism," and they didn't die as children for lack of pronouns. I noted we know gays and lesbians from all of history but asked, "Where are the trans?"
I hold a strict biological view of sex and I argue against any attempt to redefine it. I define female as "of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) which can be fertilized by male gametes," and I insist this applies in "99.999 percent of cases," with only "extremely rare chromosomal intersex condition" exceptions. I lean on Enlightenment-style scientific and secular consensus as the basis for language. I used analogies — cars that break down or have missing wheels are still cars, a fire-truck that isn't red doesn't mean fire-trucks don't exist, a cat born without retractable claws is still a cat — to argue that edge cases don't dissolve a definition. I also pushed back hard on the word "can," arguing "Can means could. Could does not mean will... Possible is only potential," and I noted that no male will ever have menopause.
I've also given medical and health advice to others in the community, warning them not to take diet advice from unqualified people online and to get full checkups — thyroid, liver, kidneys — because "we collectively are informed so very little on the long term effects of endocrine dysruption on young bodies and their ability to process nutrients." I recommended a documentary called "The Weigh Down" about a diet cult, arguing that "calories in calories out" can be dangerous advice when underlying autoimmune, thyroid, or gut issues are the real cause of weight gain.
On my own regret: I don't spell out specific surgeries, hormone durations, or irreversible changes, but my regret is total and self-directed. I say I "was had" and call myself an idiot for going along with it. The intensity is high — I frame the whole experience as having been duped — and I express relief at having gotten out. I don't describe my current mental health in detail beyond noting I had depression before, and I don't mention suicidal ideation or self-harm after detransitioning.
I don't describe my family's reaction, my relationships, my career, or a support network. Sexually, I identify as gay and I was bullied for being GNC as a kid. My current identity is a detransitioned woman who is critical of transition as it's currently practiced, particularly for vulnerable people with mental health issues, autism, or trauma. I don't do formal activism, but I argue these points actively online and I offer health guidance to others in the community.