Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde... nee, ik ben een vrouw die als vrouw is geboren en nooit is getransitioneerd, en ik schrijf hier als iemand met eigen OCD-ervaring die sceptisch is over transitiegeneeskunde. Ik heb zelf geen hormonen of operaties ondergaan; mijn berichten bestaan uit adviezen waarin ik anderen waarschuw om zich niet te haasten met testosteron, puberteitsremmers of een geslachtsaanpassende operatie, en ze aanspoor OCD-gespecialiseerde CGT te zoeken in plaats van gendertherapeuten. Ik sta sterk kritisch tegenover transvrouwen in vrouwenruimtes, sta erop dat biologische informatie wordt gedeeld vóór seks en verwerp het label 'cis' voor mezelf. Ik heb geen huidige transidentiteit, detransitie of suïcidale gedachten beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have simply grown into a woman — that is how I describe myself, plainly and without qualification. I am not 'cis' anything; I am just a woman, and I say that the label 'CIS will never be a mainstream thing.' I am self-employed, which has insulated me somewhat from workplace conflict over my views, and I note that the people I work with 'have common sense so I'm not worried.'
I have battled with OCD in the past. At its worst I described it as 'mental torture,' with the worst kind of intrusive thoughts, and I say OCD 'tends to ebb and flow' for me. What helped was repeating to myself that I have OCD, reading about OCD, and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. I strongly recommend that people with obsessive fears see someone who specialises in OCD treatment rather than 'just a therapist who will direct you towards transition.' I also describe physical symptoms I've had — 'weird pain/breathing problems at night' — which I took to doctors and which turned out to be stress and anxiety related; I believe anxiety can manifest as real physical pain, especially at night when fears 'come to the fore.' I also mention having had braces and wearing a retainer years later, which I can 'just about bring myself to wear... regularly.'
I have no personal experience of being trans, but I have spent a lot of time in online spaces advising people who are questioning or pre-surgery. I have repeatedly cautioned against medical steps taken in a state of conflict. To someone injecting testosterone while wondering 'if i'm actually transgender,' I said that is 'probably not something you should be wondering when you're injecting T,' that therapists 'seem to be reinforcing your dysphoria as opposed to supporting you through it,' and that they should find a therapist who doesn't specialise in gender and explore non-medical ways of dealing with dysphoria, perhaps through a CBT book. I told someone else that 'surgery won't and can't solve mental health problems' because 'Mental health is an internal issue and not something that can be sorted by a surgeon's knife.'
On puberty blockers I claimed to have read that '80-90% of children placed on puberty blockers go on to transition,' while a very high percentage of dysphoric children 'realign' back with their biological sex during or after puberty if left alone, and I argued blockers 'will make it pretty permanent.' I compared gender surgery to a 1990s documentary about BIID in which a UK psychologist sent patients to a Scottish surgeon to amputate limbs, calling it 'madness to me, the same as giving an anorexic liposuction as otherwise they might starve themselves.'
I have argued extensively against SRS (sex reassignment surgery). I said no one under 25 should be allowed SRS because of 'endless types of complications,' because the surgeon is 'literally cutting into one of the most sensitive parts of the body,' healing happens in an area with 'a huge amount of bacteria,' and 'there doesn't seem to be any standard way of doing it.' I warned that people who have had irreversible genital surgery are unlikely to 'express regret about it publicly' and that 'misery loves company,' and I asked whether someone would be upset to lose sensation permanently. I advised against SRS for someone happy as a bottom, citing YouTube videos of transwomen for whom the neovagina was 'to[o] close to their rectum,' making prior intercourse uncomfortable. I also warned about the upkeep: dilating 'much more involved, possible hours every day, day in day out,' and asked whether an approximation of a vagina 'being only man-made' might become a new obsession. I speculated that nipple position after fat grafting would drop due to gravity, noting my own nipples are 'definately nowhere near as high as they once were.' I also speculated that a neovagina sits differently anatomically: 'Vagina's are under a woman's body, neovagina's are situated more towards the front.'
I have been sharply critical of trans women who enter women's spaces. I told one person that at 5'2 they'd likely be 'clock[ed] for a butch lesbian' but that they have every right to use women's toilets. But I also said to a trans woman arguing that cis women should accommodate their presence: 'You have no right to tell women their comfort doesn't matter in their own spaces. You don't sound like a woman what you say things like this,' and 'It's pretty obvious you don't care about women. I think you can then understand why women might not care much for your either.' I distinguished myself from trans women with sexual (AGP) motivations: 'That makes you nothing like me. I'm not sexually aroused at the thought of being a women. I was born female and have simply grown into a woman. Basic fact. I simply am.' I argued that most women use single-sex spaces 'for safety not for validation' and that there is 'literally no way to let 'good' transwomen in and others out.'
On disclosure I took a firm line: as soon as things get sexual with a new partner, a trans person must disclose that they are 'actually biologically a woman,' comparing it to disclosing an active STD like HIV or herpes, and saying it is 'morally repugnant' to marry someone who waits for sex without telling them. I also advised someone to get their medical records corrected: 'You definitely have a right to have accurate information listed on your medical records.'
I have been sympathetic to people I felt were harmed by therapists. To someone whose fears a therapist had 'twisted... into some kind of reality,' I wrote: 'I can't imagine how that therapist twisted your fears into some kind of reality... you should never have gone through that to begin with. What happen to first do on harm?' I was also scathing about a service I saw as substandard, calling providers 'utter charlatans and not remotely professional' and suggesting complaints, noting 'The health service has an annoying habit of closing ranks' in my country.
I have not described undergoing any transition myself, any surgeries, or any detransition. My contribution to this community has been as someone with lived OCD experience who is sceptical of rapid medicalisation, strongly protective of women's single-sex spaces, and critical of both surgical transition and of therapists who affirm without exploring underlying obsessive or trauma-driven distress.