Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde lesbienne en radicaal feministe die zeer kritisch is over de moderne transbeweging, met name over de effecten ervan op kinderen, homoseksuelen en de op sekse gebaseerde rechten van vrouwen. Ik definieer sekse aan de hand van gametenproductie en gender als sociale conventie, en ik wijs de eis af dat ik mezelf zou beschrijven als 'me een vrouw voelend'. Ik geloof dat de beweging schadelijk werd toen ze kinderen begon te werven en homoseksuelen vertelde dat ze eigenlijk het andere geslacht zijn, en ik zie het medische bevestigingssysteem als een kapitalistische lopende band. Ik identificeer me als radicaal feministe, maar ben het oneens met sommige online uitwassen ervan. Mijn huidige identiteit is gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw en lesbienne.
Volledig verhaal
I am a lesbian and a radical feminist who has been critical of gender ideology and what I see as the harmful effects of the modern trans movement. I define sex as reproductive function based on gamete production, and gender as a set of social conventions loosely based on sex; I would like to see gender abolished rather than treated as innate. I have been bothered by people telling me I should describe myself in terms of 'feeling like a woman,' and I reject that framing: 'I don't care if other people have an idea of what being a woman feels like.' I compare claims of 'feeling like a woman' to appropriation, arguing that someone who merely likes dresses has not experienced being told as a child that they couldn't do something because they were a girl, being warned to use bathrooms with an escort to avoid rape, or a lifetime of sex-based discrimination. I want a word that means 'female human' because right now female humans can only describe ourselves subjectively or by using 'female,' which also applies to animals and plants. I have observed misogyny directly: 'The observation that shy awkward insecure women get treated like shit and confident social outgoing men get to rule the planet.' I became a radical feminist 'because I have observed that radical change needs to be made to stop misogyny and sexism,' while disagreeing with some online radical feminist extremes such as the idea that all porn is bad or that male violence is purely biological. I have criticized the medicalization of gender-questioning people as driven by capitalism: a conveyor belt that affirms everything people want to hear, notes their depression and anxiety symptoms have temporarily gone away, marks them as 'fixed,' and uses those numbers to attract more paying clients. I believe the movement became dangerous once it started recruiting — convincing children their bodies are wrong, or convincing gay people they are not really gay and should become the opposite sex. I have also discussed practical concerns such as keeping a scanned birth certificate on one's phone because birth certificates are worth more than temporary IDs. I have observed trans women in person and online, noting what I see as an obsession with anime and gaming, sexualized childlike profile pictures, identification with sexualized rather than real women, and objectification of women similar to straight men or incel groups; I avoid 'transbians' for this reason. I have heard trans women in real life talking about 'euphoria boners,' which confirmed my beliefs about autogynephilia for me. I believe gender expression, not identity, should be the protected category, and that fewer people — especially children — would transition if gender nonconformity were more accepted. I have also advised someone I read as a feminine gay man that he does not need to be a woman to fit in: 'You can just be a feminine gay man.'