Alle verhalen

Uit de kast op haar 16e, en toen de counselor gevraagd te vertragen

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd117
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een 17-jarige gedetransitioneerde/desisterende vrouw die afgelopen juli begon me als man te identificeren maar geen lichamelijke veranderingen heeft doorgevoerd en nu probeert te vertragen voordat ik een medisch traject in ga. Ik heb PTSS door huiselijk geweld in mijn gezin vanaf mijn 14e, OCD, woon als minderjarige alleen in een sociale huurwoning en ben geïsoleerd van familie, sociaal leven en onderwijs. Ik kwam uit de kast bij mijn ouders, woonbegeleiders en professionals en bezocht een staatsgenderdysforiedienst, maar werd wantrouwig toen een counselor mijn redenen niet onderzocht en opmerkte dat ik op mijn 18e zonder diagnose een medisch traject kon starten. Ik vraag me nu kritisch af of transgenderidentiteit een sociaal-cultureel ingeprent concept is, lees boeken die er kritisch over zijn en probeer vrede te sluiten met vrouw zijn, waarbij mijn lesbisch zijn helpt. Ik zie mezelf in de spiegel nog steeds als man en weet niet wat dat betekent, en ik voel me schuldig en van streek.

Volledig verhaal

I am 17 years old and female. Last July I started entertaining the idea that I am male internally, and since then I have written tens of thousands of words about how 'I am a man' — enough to fill a dense book. I fear I have wrapped my mind up into a pretty bow and absconded from the reality that I will always be biologically female. I have wrestled with my body since before puberty, but I question whether that was simply disgust at undesirable bodily processes, or even just being a dirty, grimy human. Everything is open to interpretation, and I see questioning my gender as an endless cycle that will never render certain, so accepting the baseline feels practical. For the last several years, when I look in the mirror I can only see a man. Calling myself a man in perceived truth for the first time was when I felt the happiest in my entire life — but I now call that a flightless delusion. I want a male body that I can never truthfully have. I did not come to this from social media; I have never even had TikTok. I have had an extremely difficult upbringing and now live alone in public housing as a minor. Family domestic violence trauma began when I was 14, and I have since been diagnosed with PTSD. I think that trauma heavily promoted this idea — perhaps calling myself transgender was a safe haven or distraction from the real mammoth of my life: being completely cut off from my family, any social life, and educational stability. I was wrestling with my body before this, but trauma must have exacerbated my thinking. I have made no outward changes to myself; anyone would see a 'teenage girl.' However, I have attended several counselling sessions at my state GDS (gender dysphoria service) and was undergoing a psychiatry consultation this month, likely to open gateways to other treatments. I now feel a strong urge to slow down. I told the front office workers of my social housing complex, I told my parents at the end of last year that I 'am a man,' and I told mental health professionals. But I worry I have muddied my life and introduced confusion that had no meaning in the first place. I feel guilty for lying to people and making them feel bad for seeing me as what I am: a confused girl. I got my first red flag when the counsellor never asked me the whys or broke down reasons with me. She said you didn't even need a GD diagnosis to start a medical pathway at 18 — it felt like they were prioritising tribalistic politics over addressing me as an individual. I am frustrated that professionals are now immediately coming to help but never took the trauma seriously when it happened, which was when I needed it most. I have also been diagnosed with OCD, which definitely exacerbates my all-or-nothing psyche. I am prone to being overly-intuitive and analysing things until the cows come home. I am intensely critical and struggling to see transgender identity as a naturally occurring human experience, but rather a socio-culturally imprinted concept that complements the medicalising nature of the Western world. I have started reading books on transgenderism being an ideology and can't even refute many of the claims. I ask myself: am I in denial of my intrinsic human experience, or am I beginning to become honest with myself? Have I ruined my life by asking innumerable questions with no answer but a distressed mind? Will I ever be able to live as a normal woman? I still see myself as a man, and I don't know what that means. In giving advice to others, I have shared that seeing testosterone as the ultimate answer made me miserable and got me into an irreducibly complex paradox — questioning possibilities nowhere near adjacent to reality. What helped me was realising that 'woman' doesn't have to mean anything; it is just a 5-letter word society has attached loaded connotations to, while being female is the baseline biological reality. Researching how medicines not intended for my birth sex (testosterone) work showed me how unnatural it was, leaving me in a state of neutrality that is light years more peaceful. I also said that the questions I was asking were not mine to ask but a fabrication of activism capitalising off vulnerable individuals, and that embracing my lesbianism helped me tremendously, reminding me there is no right or wrong way to live as a woman. I have been critical of the movement, comparing it to a religion cosplaying as secular and scientific, and to deconstructing from family religious beliefs.