Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, genderneutrale vrouw die ongeveer 30 jaar geleden als tiener met genderdysforie worstelde, voordat transitie een optie was, en er doorheen kwam door mijn vrouwelijke lichaam te accepteren en te besluiten het soort vrouw te zijn dat ik wilde zijn. Nu identificeer ik me als genderneutraal, mijn persoonlijkheid is genderneutraal, mijn sekse is vrouwelijk, en ik accepteer dat ik vrouw ben. Ik heb depressie, waarbij medicatie me heeft geholpen, en medische problemen die aanzienlijke gewichtstoename veroorzaakten, maar ik heb geleerd mijn lichaam te accepteren en te waarderen. Ik ben moeder van een dochter van 23 die uitkwam als trans nadat ze met een transvrouw trouwde, en ik probeer haar te helpen transitie te heroverwegen. Ik ben sterk kritisch over transideologie en alleen-bevestigende zorg, vooral voor minderjarigen, en ik pleit ervoor dat detransitioners hun verhalen delen.
Volledig verhaal
I struggled with these feelings as a teenager, about 30 years ago, before transitioning was even an option. I realized I didn't really fit in with the other girls and thought I might be a boy. My body was fully functioning female, and I had to accept that fact. I decided to be the kind of woman I wanted to be instead of what the girls said I had to be and what the boys said I could not be. I never felt like a woman and I still don't, but I accept that I am a woman. Recently I learned that I am gender neutral, and I'm glad to know that — gender neutral is my personality, female is my sex. I'm definitely a masculine woman and can be feminine at times, and I love being gender neutral because it means I can easily and happily fulfill any role or need. I've learned to love and accept my body for all it allows me to do.
I have depression, and medication has been a great help to me. In my teens and 20s I hated my body because I was overweight. I have several medical problems that caused weight gain; I weigh twice as much now, around 300lbs, yet I don't hate my body anymore. I'm happier with my body now than I was at 150lbs — not because I look better, but because I accept, respect and appreciate myself more. I stopped judging myself and comparing myself to others. I was a singer, so I understand the impact of losing your voice.
I got through my dysphoria by ignoring or avoiding triggering it, and by turning my thoughts — I don't recommend ignoring depression or other mental health issues, but that is how I got over it. I also confused people because I've expressed myself femininely, masculinely and several ways in between; different circumstances call for different outfits.
I'm now a mother. My child was always a 'girly girl' until 10th grade, when she switched to jeans and t-shirts — I did the same thing at the same age. I made sure my boys and girls did an equal amount of housework and learned all the jobs; I taught them 'There is no such thing as men's work and women's work, just work.' She had a stressful childhood and was very insecure, was diagnosed with ADD and a learning disability in 2nd grade, was overweight and doctors pressured us to make her lose it. There was abuse at her dad's house that I'm only now learning about, and sexual fondling by older siblings from age 1 to 13 (the oldest had been molested and recreated it with the younger kids). She had mostly female friends, started puberty a little young, and is very large-breasted so clearly got some unwanted attention. She is an artist; her favorite toys were dolls and tools. At 14 she told her therapist she was gender fluid. At 16 she came out as a lesbian, now she is clearly bi. At 21 she married a trans woman who had been a friend for many years; my child wore a dress at the wedding. They are now getting divorced. One month after the wedding her spouse had an affair with a man, and two months after that my child came out as trans. She says that in kindergarten she thought she would have a beard when she grew up like her dad, and that is proof she was always trans, but at the same age she constantly asked for a bra. I'm worried because some people de-transition and regret the harm done to their body. I am a mom of a 23-year-old FtM and I want to help my child realize transitioning is not the answer.
I am against trans ideology and the current affirmation-only treatment model. I believe individuals and parents need all the info before taking steps to transition, and that minors should not be allowed to medically transition — if they are not mature enough to get their tubes tied, they are not mature enough to medically transition. I think transitioning could be considered conversion therapy: you were converted from a girl to a boy. I believe males usually transition because of autogynephilia, while females are usually gender non-conforming and/or abuse victims (usually sexual), and that once females deal with their trauma and/or reject social stereotypes they no longer feel the need to be the opposite sex. I think the suicide rate before and after transitioning is the same, and that transitioning or not transitioning will not make you feel better. I've encouraged other detransitioners to share their stories, to campaign for future children to prevent this from happening to them, and to join with other detransitioners to convince the medical establishment this is wrong. I believe de-transitioners deserve safety and respect in the same way transitioners do, and that what is good for some is bad for others, so doctors and therapists should have the freedom to treat their patients as individuals.