Alle verhalen

De twijfels van een gevangenis-MHT over het bevestigen van tieners

Man · Gedesisteerd280
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd en identificeer me als heteroseksuele man die een bondgenoot is van gedetransitioneerden en desisters, al kwam ik rond 2005 uit de kast als biseksueel, deels om erbij te horen, voordat ik mijn hetero-oriëntatie accepteerde. Ik werk in de geestelijke gezondheidszorg (eerder als MHT in een gevangenis, nu in medische dossiers bij een psychiatrisch ziekenhuis) en ben openlijk sceptisch over hoe snel tieners worden bevestigd en medisch getransitioneerd, terwijl ik mensen steun van wie ik geloof dat ze echt dysforisch zijn. Ik heb geworsteld met obesitas, suïcidale gedachten in mijn familie en spijt over dingen die ik deed om me geldig te voelen, en ik gebruik Zoloft en zie een counselor. Ik moedig mensen die transitie overwegen actief aan om te vertragen, trans-fora los te laten en goed na te denken, en ik heb groot respect voor wie detransitioneert.

Volledig verhaal

I never transitioned, but I've been an ally to this community for years and I've spent a lot of time reading and posting here because I see a lot of myself in the questions people wrestle with. I grew up as a boy with a softer side — as an 8-year-old I played with dolls and played house with the girls as well as doing the rough-and-tumble stuff the boys got up to. I've always had a nurturing, emotional bent alongside being a straight guy who's pretty athletic and into lifting, boxing and martial arts. When I graduated high school in 2005 I was only aware of one or two cases of trans people. Around that time I decided I was bisexual and started going after other men. I did that, in my own words, "because it was new and cool and unheard of and I desperately wanted to fit in somewhere." I got into some relationships and tried my damndest to fit my straight peg into a gay hole and it just didn't work. I'm better now that I've accepted what I am — I'm straight — but I'm still reconciling with that after telling everyone I'm not, including my wife. It's part of my identity and it's something I still carry. Until I was 27 I was, in my own words, "a loser shithead." I worked as a busboy, was over 300 pounds, couldn't drive, had no aspirations and no hope. I lived solely for my fiancee's sake because I knew she'd be devastated if I killed myself. Suicidal thinking ran in my family — my dad and stepdad both died by suicide, and the anger, frustration, despair, remorse and nagging questions go on and on for the living. I changed for me, put the work in, and today I'm a homeowner with a car, a beautiful wife, hobbies and friends. I also have what I call "bitch tits" (gynecomastia) and busted-up hands from my physical pursuits, and I have curly hair I keep buzzed every month or two. I work in mental health. I was an MHT (mental health technician) in a prison where they accepted anyone with a bachelor's and a certain number of credits in psych or social work — I had that from a human services degree, an administrative-focused social work program heavy on grant writing, funding and running departments. I loved it in school, but the reality was a slap in the face. I took a class in theories and practices of group therapy that opened up very old wounds I hadn't been aware of and made me realize how unqualified I'd be at counseling or leading a group. I switched my major from human services last year when I took my current job in the medical records department of a mental hospital that's part of a large chain prioritizing budget over everything. I've been burnt out as both an MHT and in med records. I'm on Zoloft and see a counselor, though I've lost a lot of respect for therapy in recent years because the system is so inundated with lawsuits, risk management and corrosive politics that turnover is massive and the job pushes people out or turns them into something they hate. I don't want to work in this field again, though I'd not trade the experience. Through my job I see a lot of transitioning kids, and it can get pretty hopeless witnessing them come and go, many rotating through area hospitals over the years. Based on the ones who repeatedly come back, they don't seem to be helped by transitioning, though it could be the other issues they're dealing with. A lot of them appear to be average teenagers caught up in peer pressure, hormones and pop culture; the trans kids say their friends are mostly trans or non-binary and now they've come out trans, and they don't see a link between that shift and their suicidal ideation. I suspect some are just gay or bisexual trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. I think we do them a disservice by accepting their pronouns and rapid gender shift carte blanche — for a few it takes real pressure off, which I 150% support, but for the rest it confuses them more. I say that as someone who came out as bisexual twenty years ago partly to fit in. I'm not against transition for everyone — I've told people here I support them wholeheartedly and I've said a genuinely trans person should do what they need to do — but I'm deeply skeptical of how fast it's happening, especially for teens. I've told posters under 25 not to continue this path until they've thought deeply about it and cut themselves off from trans subs for a long time, sought solitude, and come to a rock-solid answer, because the consequences of the wrong choice are drastic and chronic. I've also told people not to jump on hormones no matter how they feel right now, and I've warned about suicide risk. I have enormous respect for desisters and detransitioners — I've written that it takes humility and guts most people will never have to "come back" from what I see as a predatory system, and I've said I'm here for the sanity, clarity and joy from people who've done it. I've offered my phone number to people in crisis and told them they can message me anytime. I've never had gender dysphoria myself, but I've done a lot of things to feel whole and valid — I regret all of it and would change it in a heartbeat because I bear internal and external scars from my trial and error and willful body negligence. I'm 34 now and I've found some peace in looking deep at the stuff I don't want to look at, even if it's only a few seconds at a time. I don't consider myself de-anything; I'm just here as an ally.