Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, gendercritische biseksuele vrouw die zich in 2021 als genderfluïde identificeerde, mijn borst bond maar nooit hormonen nam, en desisteerde nadat ik de ideologie in mijn vriendengroep in twijfel trok, waarbij ik die vrienden verloor. Ik kwam zelf tot mijn standpunten en noem mezelf nu politiek dakloos nadat ik links heb verlaten; de geschiedenis van mijn familie onder het nazisme en het communisme heeft mijn politiek gevormd. Het verlaten van de queergemeenschap is de beste beslissing voor mijn geestelijke gezondheid die ik ooit heb genomen, al mis ik de vrienden en het leven dat ik kwijt ben nog steeds. Ik geloof dat genderdysforie echt is maar vaak samengaat met OCD, ADHD, depressie of lichaamsdysmorfie, en ik pleit voor niet-bevestigende therapie zoals RET/CGT, tegen medische transitie van minderjarigen en voor het recht van detransitioners om te procederen. Ik kreeg op het werk te maken met vergeldingsmaatregelen omdat ik de term ‘zwangere personen’ weigerde, en ik blijf me in het openbaar uitspreken tegen wat ik zie als genderideologie.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up as a tomboy — I never had long hair, never really wore dresses as a kid, and played with the boys. I studied vocal performance in college and later became a psychology student. I was a huge leftist for years: I waved an Antifa flag, went to protests, and organized in my community. My family is Eastern European — first-generation American, my family fled communist Poland in the 90s, and my great-grandmother, who died in 2021 at 101, survived the Warsaw ghetto and told me what life was like under Stalin and the Gestapo.
I came of age when the conversation among girls was about equalizing how girls are treated and 'girls have each other's back.' I was deeply involved in queer-heavy circles and the TTRPG/D&D community. Around 2021, I identified as genderfluid and used she/they pronouns. I never took testosterone, but I did bind my chest — I started binding to try and make my fluidity 'seem legit,' and I also experimented with drag king makeup. In that group, three male individuals came out as transwomen within the span of three weeks (part of what I later described as a kind of pact), and we were all made to question our gender so that the females in the group could 'get a voice.' I was essentially convinced that because I was a tomboy, I must have always been genderfluid. I specifically chose 'gender-fluid' because I said I didn't want my gender to be defined by something I'm 'not.'
About six months in, I started questioning the pain I had from chest binding. When I began questioning some of the gender stuff — asking 'can't I just be a girl with masculine qualities?' — I lost everyone. I was accused of spouting TERF rhetoric, which was called 'literal violence' by the three transwomen in that group. One of them used 'bimbo' to define herself; when I, a progressive woman, objected that bimbo is a slur — one my father used when he verbally berated my mother in a counselor's office during their divorce — I was berated for 'silencing a transwoman who was coming into her own.' I figured I was silenced.
I desisted in 2021 without ever having medically transitioned other than mild binding. My desist moment happened when I realized the signs of my 'genderfluidity' were not always present — I had just been a little girl who liked Legos and trucks. I came to my conclusions on my own, from curiosity and worry, not from RadFem forums or detrans Reddit. I now describe myself as about '80% gender critical' and politically homeless, having left the left alongside desisting from 'the gender craze.'
After I said I was no longer genderfluid, I lost my friends. I moved after breaking things off with them; it's been about two years and I haven't made real, deep new friends since. I miss the friends, the area I lived in, and the things I used to do with them. I sometimes wonder what would have happened if I never desisted. I don't miss who I was back then, but I miss most other aspects of my life.
I now work in a professional setting — I was involved in a project revamping a Psychology course and spoke up in meetings against hiring an unvetted 'gender specialist.' I was given a citation at work after a coworker suggested using 'pregnant people' and 'menstruating people' and I said no; my boss told me I don't have free speech protection from my employer, so I have to keep quiet about my desistance even though I'm 'the person who was in this ideology.' I also have a small business selling handmade items at conventions. I used to work at Starbucks. I got a tattoo at 21 that I disliked two years later. I am bisexual but do not consider myself part of the 'LGBT community,' and I don't sell pride merchandise.
Leaving the 'queer community' after desisting, even while still bisexual, has been 'the greatest mental health decision I've ever made.' I live in a super progressive city surrounded by 'rich college PhD types and Bolshevik Revolution larpers' and I find the gender ideology everywhere — like taking 'They Live' glasses on and off. I wish I didn't care about it so much.
I believe gender dysphoria is real, but I think it's often comorbid with OCD, depression, anxiety, eating disorders, ADHD, or body dysmorphia, and that transition doesn't fix those. I advocate for a non-affirmative treatment model and suggest REBT or CBT with a trained psychotherapist — REBT was invented by Albert Ellis to combat irrational beliefs, and I think the pervasive thought of being in the 'wrong body' can be treated as an irrational belief in the clinical sense. I support trans adults who genuinely have dysphoria and are helped by transition, and I have no problem using she/her for transwomen, but I'm strongly critical of gender ideology, non-binary identity (which I call regressive and a way of erasing GNC women), medical transition for minors, puberty blockers (which I say are not reversible), and what I see as medical and corporate profiteering. I've spoken out publicly — including calling Ulta customer service to delete my account over a Dylan Mulvaney campaign — and I've pointed people toward Erin Friday's legal resources for detransition lawsuits. I've also dealt with family friction: my father was against my detransition, and I've speculated about savior complexes and sunk-cost fallacies behind parental affirmation.