Alle verhalen

Twee jaar zichzelf testen op dysforie op /lgbt/, geen hormonen nodig

Man · Gedesisteerd1,2K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde homoseksuele man die nooit medisch transitioneerde maar in mijn late tienerjaren ongeveer twee jaar obsessief mezelf op genderdysforie ‘testte’ nadat ik rond 2013 /lgbt/ op 4chan ontdekte. Mijn genderverwarring was geworteld in het zijn van een verwijfde homojongen die niet in het masculiene archetype paste, en loste op door te accepteren dat gender voor mij niet essentieel is, naar de sportschool te gaan en socialer te worden. Bijna tien jaar later gaat het goed met me, ben ik actief in de detransgemeenschap en pleit ik voor eerlijke discussie over de grenzen van transitie, terwijl ik erken dat transitie sommige mensen echt helpt. Ik heb geen chirurgische of hormonale spijt aangezien ik geen medische transitie onderging, en ik heb geen gemelde suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and grew up as what I'd now describe as a camp gay boy — physically I never lived up to a masculine ideal, and that left me confused about my place in the world. My gender issues did not originate in dysphoria at all; I never really thought about my gender as a child. That changed nearly 10 years ago (around 2013, when I was roughly 17–18) when I was scrolling the newly created /lgbt/ board on 4chan and had what I described as a "shiver down my spine" moment. From never thinking about my gender, I went to obsessively 'testing' myself for gender dysphoria every day, and that persisted for about two years until I went to university and gradually moved on. I never had a formal diagnosis, but at the deepest point of what I called my 'delusion' I felt something like phantom breast/vagina syndrome — my anxieties seemed to get rerouted onto my gender even though I hadn't started out with misgivings about my body. I remember my mum found a page about 'Pure OCD' on Tumblr, and that was a light at the end of the tunnel: an explanation for my anxiety that wasn't just 'you're transgender'. I'm a thoughtful, philosophical, obsessive person, and it was frustrating trying to prove to myself one way or another that I was transgender — being trans felt like the only possibility on offer, but it never felt right. I never medically transitioned as far as my posts indicate, and I don't describe myself as having detransitioned in the surgical or hormonal sense; my account is one of desisting from a gender-obsessed period. What resolved it, in my own reading, was accepting that my gender isn't really anything to me — there was no essential truth of my gender identity to uncover either way. I also found practical anchors: going to the gym, which put me in touch with my body, and becoming more social. I said "Gym put me in touch with my body and who nature intended me to be, I'm so happy I found that way out," and I've described my solution as working out plus being more social, which "basically solved the problem for me." Now, nearly a decade later, I'm fine. I identify as a gay man. I've thought a lot about why some gay men — particularly effeminate ones — end up in this situation. I've cited J. Michael Bailey's book (I referred to it once as 'The boy who would be queen' and elsewhere as 'The man who would be queen') and its argument that homosexual male transitioners do so because they're too feminine to appeal to gay men and too masculine for straight men. I've said I think my own gender confusion was related to feelings about attractiveness: "if you don't fill the role of a man very well how are you supposed to imagine your life and plan for the future?" I acknowledge that some people really want to fit an archetype and that nonconformism isn't for everyone — I'm happy to be outlandish in manner but not in body. On dating and body image: at my thinnest and most effeminate-looking I was disgusted by myself, which I'm not now, though I'm unsure the gym has improved my prospects with men. I do think I get more respect from people in general. I've been open that physically changing yourself may never solve the underlying problem — and that this may apply to transitioning too. I'm active in the detrans community online and post frequently. I've argued that r/detrans is unfairly maligned, that its growing membership (from 35,000 to over 41,000 during late 2022) reflects genuine interest in honest discussion, and that "a million detransitioners can speak out and it will never count" for people who are towing a line. I've pushed back on purity tests and on excluding people from the cause just because I disagree with them politically (e.g. radical feminists). I've also defended the position that some people are genuinely helped by transition — citing Amanda Lepore as someone for whom it's hard to imagine she'd have been better off as a gay boy — and I've said I "personally suspect that transition is right for some people," while insisting it isn't a simple fix for everyone. I've been vocal about informed consent and medical harms, particularly around testosterone, noting that a detransitioner's identity questioning began only after reproductive pain from testosterone and that these risks may not have been disclosed. I've also criticised the way online searches funnel gender questions straight to 'start your transition today' — "You said it better than I ever have, that's my major gripe." I try to advise younger people cautiously: telling them they don't have to take hormones just because they already have, that they're allowed to stop, and that feelings about gender can change with time and maturity. I've also counselled people writing to clinicians to stick strictly to the facts to avoid legal trouble. I don't believe in an essential gender identity: "We don't have a gender identity deep down inside that defines what we 'really' are." I also question whether it's always good to take negative feelings about gender seriously, since one can become fixated on any ill feeling, rational or not. I have no stated regrets about medical procedures because I didn't undergo them; my main 'regret' framing is about lost years of obsession in my late teens and early twenties. I'm supportive of other people's detransition or desistance journeys and try to reassure people that family will usually come around.