Alle verhalen

Drie jaar transitie, en toen testosteron in de top 1%

Man · Gedetransitioneerd222
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man die van 2013 tot 2016 getransitioneerd was en later detransitioneerde, en ik identificeer me nu als man en werk eraan mijn mannelijke lichaam te omarmen. Ik herleid mijn transitie tot een verloren identiteit in mijn jeugd plus de effecten van pornografie op mijn lichaamsbeeld en seksualiteit, niet tot een onderdrukkende opvoeding. Na mijn detransitie testte mijn testosteron in de top 1% van het mannelijke bereik, wat me geruststelde dat mijn endocriene systeem is hersteld. Ik heb sterk kritische opvattingen over transactivisme, de beweringen over de „omkeerbaarheid” van puberteitsremmers, makers van pornocontent en wat ik zie als sociale besmetting bij kinderen, terwijl ik ook genderkritische feministen bekritiseer. Ik meld geen suïcidale gedachten, operaties of een specifieke diagnose.

Volledig verhaal

I was born male and grew up in a normal suburban Catholic upbringing with what I describe as a non-oppressive home life. I was a typical sports kid growing up and always muscular, which felt normal to me. Even so, as a young person I had what I call a 'lost identity' and gravitated toward things and groups that would help define me, which is how I got 'sucked into the trans thing.' I transitioned between 2013 and 2016. I recall being in trans support groups during that period and reading a well-praised book by a trans author featuring a discussion with 'bear,' a transgender man — at age 19 I found it refreshing and inspiring, 'breaking down the gender binary.' Looking back I now think that author was 'just old AGP hon' and that 'bear' is a silly name for a transgender man; a lot of my memories have been revised this way. I describe teenagers and college kids as 'retarded' in retrospect. I eventually detransitioned. After detransitioning I had my testosterone checked and it came back in the top 1% of the male range, which I take as evidence that estrogen did not permanently damage my endocrine function — 'I guess I just have high T.' I also note that most detrans males have properly functioning endocrine systems with normal testosterone levels and are indistinguishable from other healthy males. I advise others in my position to get a hormone panel from a primary care doctor, and that if they recently quit hormones they should give it a few months, watching for their testicles returning to natural size as a sign things are progressing. On causes: pornography is central to my account. I say 'pornography did it. It fucked me up to and my body image.' I describe modern porn as 'trauma in and of itself,' with videos of every conceivable genre designed to make you sexualize your insecurity, plus addicts pushing toward more extreme content, including entire genres dedicated to 'turning you gay' and 'assaulting your masculinity.' I believe porn is a huge gateway for AGP in 2022, while agreeing AGP does not require porn. I also despise the content creators of sissy/feminization porn as 'the worst people' and 'the definition of degenerate' for involving others in their fetish and making content that a 12-year-old boy might watch. I am on what I call 'a road to embracing my masculine body' and I now like having muscles. I attribute part of my earlier confusion to having a weak identity rather than to upbringing: 'People with weak identities get pulled into things like this more easily.' I think identity formation, not family background, is the key variable. On hormones more broadly: I say estrogen lowers your emotional need for competition and success — 'it did for me' — and call estrogen 'a de-motivator for males.' I am strongly critical of using how you feel on and off HRT as confirmation of the right choice, calling it 'pseudo-scientific bullshit inundated in placebo.' I am also sharply critical of the claim that puberty blockers are reversible for males, pointing to genital atrophy ('how many women like fucking men with 3 inch shrunken penises'). I hold strongly critical views of much of contemporary trans and LGBT activism. I say I 'definitely have some generic hate for a significant amount of trans people,' though I frame it more as hating people who are ignorant of themselves and of reality. I never got on board with the extreme leftism exhibited by LGBT people, even though I listen to leftist YouTube channels, whose opinions I find wrong and often ignoring human nature. I contrast 2013-2016, when trans people seemed 'much less political,' with the present, when trans people go on CNN and are all 'activists.' I am skeptical of non-binary identification, noting 'Non-binaries are 90% females' and that identifying as non-binary is itself gendered. I am critical of gender-critical feminists too, calling them 'science denying' for a blank-slate view of males and females. I am also critical of what I see as the influence of trans ideology on children, describing LGBT people who expose young children to gender and sexual identity ideology as 'groomers' motivated by a belief that being trans or gay is innate and uninfluenceable. I point to 'tons and tons of accounts' here of people who never questioned their gender, went through a crisis, surrounded themselves in online trans communities, and then came to identify as trans — adults, I note — and ask what happens when this is applied to young children. I think the huge increase in gender-questioning people over 15 years is explained by this social influence. On sexuality and relationships: I advise that a straight man can 'enjoy femininity through the girls that you have sex with,' meaning being attracted to it and getting to touch and hold it. I push back against the idea that any man who doesn't fit an ideal straight-male mold is a closeted homosexual, and defend bisexual men's ability to marry women. I am critical of what I see as women's very selective standards for male partners ('80/20'), and I hold critical views of modern feminism, saying 'Lots of soft men are created these days because of our feminist society' and that 'women are the gatekeepers of sex.' I acknowledge I 'get a lot of joy from bitching about the other gender.' I am also skeptical of claims that dairy raises estrogen in healthy males, and of claims that prior estrogen exposure makes males more sensitive to environmental estrogens. On mental health and community: I do not report a specific diagnosis. I do report that I had a lost identity as a young person and was searching for definition, and I encourage others not to obsess about how they feel day to day as a way of figuring out life goals. I value this community specifically because people can say and believe different things without being banned, 'because words aren't violence.' I reject the framing that words can be violent, though I say I 'will get violent over fighting words' in person, not on the internet. I advise someone worried about passing later in life that they are being selfish to make it about themselves when the stakes for children are considered. I have not described any specific therapy, spiritual experience, or advocacy work. I do not report suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. I do not describe surgery. My current stance is that one should 'accept who you are, one way or another' and not be 'one of those fools who gets married then comes out at 50 and up-ends his wife and kids lives.'