Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die nu weer als vrouw leeft en moederschap waardeert, inclusief borstvoeding. Ik ben kritisch over gendergeneeskunde, puberteitsremmers, HRT-aanbieders en het onderzoek achter transitie, en ik steun de mogelijkheid van rechtszaken wegens medische nalatigheid. Ik geloof dat identiteitspolitiek en online echokamers het denken vertekenen, en ik hecht waarde aan vrijheid van meningsuiting en het vormen van mijn eigen mening. Ik benadruk dat langzaam, naar binnen gericht emotioneel werk de weg naar rust is en raad herstelmemoires aan. Ik beschrijf in deze berichten geen specifieke operaties, psychische diagnoses of suïcidale gedachten.
Volledig verhaal
I came to these communities after detransitioning, and much of what I post is advice and reflection drawn from my own path back to myself. I was born female, and I now live as a woman again.
I don't lay out my full medical timeline in these posts, but I do talk about having been through transition and come out the other side. When I see someone posting photos of their face after testosterone, I tell them honestly what I see — that the first three photos look like girls and the last is 'a bit butchy' — and I add 'Give it time,' because I know how much changes and how slowly. I also mention that many people I know let go of facial piercings once they 'seemed to become truly settled in themselves (usually past 25 yo) and stopped hiding in a way behind fashion.' I compliment someone's hair and eyes and note that the hair color is hard to pull off, so 'blessed be your skin.' I add, unprompted, 'On a side note I loved breast feeding and I very much valued the experience. Seems like boobs have been fetishized and somewhere along the way we lost sight of their purpose.' That tells me motherhood and breastfeeding were part of my life after (or around) transition, and that I value that experience deeply.
On the medical side, I'm critical. I wonder whether a nonprofit could help with a lawsuit against providers, saying 'It's the only way to keep it within the limits of healthcare rather than a blank check at vulnerable people's expense.' I speculate about 'the biggest malpractice class action lawsuit ever,' note that HRT pharma companies operate internationally, and say the research is 'faulty from detrans rates to the foundation that it is built on aka Dr Money.'(Rightly named in retrospect).' I shared a video about puberty blockers (GnRH) and Laverne Cox's reaction to it. I'm wary of how easily minors can be exploited online — I warn someone not to do anything a person on the internet asks, not to advertise being a minor, and I say the idea that picture files store location information 'just chills me to the bone what ppl might do with that info.'
I think a lot about identity, ideology, and how people get lost in it. I tell someone their 'ideology has probably changed a lot too' and that they're likely 'growing past' an old girlfriend, advising them to concentrate on themselves. I'm blunt about Reddit as an 'echo chamber where moderators limit free speech,' say 'There is nothing inherently wrong with cis white gay (insert other identity politics label) men. All that matters is whether you are a good person,' and call the 'oppression pyramid' tactic 'a power play.' I say my life improves when I call out those logical fallacies. I loved living in a 'purple' county and 'very much disliked being in the SF Bay Area where only one way of thinking was allowed (inclusive my foot).' Being able to speak freely 'has allowed me to come to my own opinions on social issues.'
I'm critical of pronoun usage: 'Using pronouns sounds so innocent and easy, but it is deceptively complex. It requires another person to panderto another's ideology and personal perception by reinforcing it as objective truth every time said person is referenced.'
I have a psychological framework for what I see in these stories. I explain the 'false self' — that narcissists use it to garner attention and praise, that they're 'reliant on external praise bc they lack an inherent sense of self,' and that withheld praise releases 'narcissistic rage... to protect their supply of esteem.' I'm disturbed watching a vulnerable girl who 'went bald' get 'roasted' online, though I'm glad she's still posting. I ask a young man why he dislikes his maleness so much, saying 'I can think of many things I love about men it's hard for me to understand,' and I push back on anime and porn as 'dangerous/unhealthy/detrimental to some young obsessive men.' I affirm that 'A mother is a solid aspect of being a woman' and that 'An emphasis on harmony and nurturing I think is aligned with many women.'
On mental health and healing, I speak from experience: 'Turn inward and do the emotional work to move yourself forward. It's really the only thing that has brought me personal peace. It takes a long time, but it is so worth it in the end.' I recommend recovery memoirs — 'I Never Promised You a Rose Garden' about schizophrenia and 'Get Me Out of Here: My Recovery from BPD' — and say 'I hope some one can recommend a good AGP, NPD, Trans book some day.' I also share that 'my life is better after I cut out my mentally ill / self-destructive friends,' while acknowledging it's 'a double edged sword bc in order to protect ourselves we have to abandon the most vulnerable. It's a guilt inducing solution, but effective.' I advise shifting focus to 'helping others in a meaningful way where self sacrifice and purpose are required,' and I frame growing away from old friends as 'an accomplishment.'
I don't describe specific regrets about surgeries or hormones in these posts, nor do I discuss my own mental health diagnoses, trauma history, sexuality, or current relationship status. What comes through is a woman who has been through transition, come back to living as female, values motherhood, is skeptical of gender medicine and identity politics, and believes deeply in doing slow inner emotional work.