Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich op mijn 16e als trans identificeerde, 1,5 jaar testosteron nam (op mijn 17e-19e), een dubbele mastectomie onderging en in 2014 op mijn 19e detransitioneerde. Ik transitioneerde grotendeels door geïnternaliseerde misogynie, een emotioneel verwaarloosde kindertijd, de scheiding van mijn ouders, de invloed van Tumblr en de wens geaccepteerd te worden door de mannelijke kant van mijn familie. Na de detransitie had ik verlammende depressie, angst en vluchtige gedachten aan de dood, maar lifecoaching, spiritualiteit en uiteindelijk het ontmoeten van mijn man hielpen me herstellen. Nu heb ik een man en een vriend (ik ben polyamoreus), run ik een YouTube-kanaal over detransitie en modereer ik r/detrans, terwijl ik pleit tegen medische transitie van jongeren en bevestigende zorg. Ik heb spijt van het transitioneren en zou het voorkomen als ik kon, al heb ik er vrede mee gesloten als leerervaring en zie ik het niet langer als een fout.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in a family that, in hindsight, had no real understanding of gender transition — my family just wanted to support me, even though they didn't see me as male. I was a highly unhappy child. I was extremely tomboyish and anti-"girly-girl" from early on; the only reason I had long hair was because my mom made me, and I didn't wear boys' clothes until high school, instead wearing the most unflattering girls' clothes I could find — lots of t-shirts and jeans. I hated everything feminine because I thought it was inferior as a child and teen, and I didn't trust other girls. There was a lot of self-hatred going on, which involved honestly hating women altogether.
I discovered the trans identity after joining Tumblr, probably around freshman year of high school or late middle school. I was anti-girly-girl to the extreme. I researched my way into the identity on Wikipedia when I was 15-16 — I didn't know how to research properly. I came out as trans at 16 and socially transitioned for 3 years. I joined one trans youth support group, which is how I was able to get testosterone, but I couldn't relate to any of them — that should have been a red flag, but I ignored it. I was stealth and passed effortlessly, though everyone thought I was a gay guy. Full stealth was isolating. I was also very obsessed with yaoi/BL fanfiction, which I got from Tumblr and friends at the time; I'd turn every piece of media into gay fanfiction, even the Dead Poets Society. I kept it secret from my family because I knew it was shameful.
I started testosterone at age 17 (in 2012) and stopped at age 19, so I was on T for about 1.5 years. My doctor didn't question me — just wanted to look like a hero and gave me T. My therapist just ran with it when I said "I feel like a boy." My mom, a nurse, was caught off guard and had no idea how to deal with it; there were no resources back in 2011 like there are now. I was very close to having bottom surgery because I didn't see myself having biological children at all. I detransitioned at 19, in 2014.
When I stopped identifying as male, I went with agender first, then that evolved into the realization that gender doesn't matter. I was embarrassed to detransition because of how hard I'd fought to be trans, but I swallowed my pride and was met with support — my mom was more relieved than anything, since she'd gotten the worst of the experience while I was transitioning. She had never believed I was male the entire time, despite helping me get hormones and a double mastectomy. I had a double mastectomy as part of my transition. At work, I was mistaken as MtF at first because co-workers who attended my high school explained it poorly to others.
I went slowly with coming out as detransitioned. I first tried make-up and androgynous clothing leaning femme but felt uncomfortable because I looked like a guy doing it, so I stopped for a couple years. I eventually got back into it once my hair grew out and my fat was in its normal position. I avoided female-dominated spaces like cosmetics and hair salons when I freshly detransitioned. I waxed my upper lip, jaw, chin, shoulders and back. I did voice training — I didn't want to speak for years after detransitioning because I'd sound like a guy. My detransition didn't fully finish until about 3 years after the initial detrans, mostly because I was shy about voice training with roommates around. About 6 years after detransitioning I got into high femme fashion.
I now identify as a detransitioned woman. I'm 26 as of early 2021 (born around 1994-1995). I'm mostly straight and pretty feminine now. I met my husband about a year after detransitioning via online dating — he was shocked by my voice but gave me a chance; we've been together 7 years as of 2022. I'm polyamorous and met my boyfriend about 5 years after detransitioning; we've been together about 2-3 years. I changed my legal name while trans, then changed it again after detransitioning to something new entirely because I didn't feel connected to my birth name. I still feel vaguely weird when people use my legal name.
Causes and contributors: I transitioned due to internalized misogyny, among other reasons — I hated girls and being one because boys seemed cooler. My mom grew up as a tomboy and was still pretty GNC; she didn't want me into princesses and girl things, so I focused on boy's interests thinking she agreed they were superior. My dad also instilled negative beliefs about girls and women in me. I wanted to be accepted and loved by the male side of my family and felt excluded, so in my teen brain I thought being a guy would make me accepted — spoiler: it didn't. I wanted a male in my life to protect me because my dad and brothers weren't doing that. My parents divorced when I was a teenager and I was navigating those complex feelings — I was depressed because of the divorce and subsequent events. I had an emotionally neglectful childhood. I was impressionable, socially awkward, and operating on black-and-white thinking as a teen. Tumblr fed into my depression and was one of the main reasons I didn't pick myself up and move on with life. I had sudden onset dysphoria after discovering transgenderism, which I now recognize as a red flag. I used trans as a hypochondriacal desire to find the problem causing my misery — an attempt to search for meaning because suffering for no reason is preposterous.
Processes toward detransition: I realized transition was a major chore — most biological males don't inject themselves with testosterone, wear a binder, or have to alter their bodies to feel like a man. I was tired of having to look and act a certain way and knew I wasn't as manly as I thought. I realized being trans was putting on a mask for others — alone, I didn't care how I looked. Being seen as a "manlet" while trans is what broke the camel's back for me and why I detransitioned. Before I identified as trans, people thought I was way older than I was and took me seriously. Spirituality saved me after detransition — it gave me direction. I did life coaching for several months, which I recommend more than therapy. I read extensively about setting boundaries and self-empowerment. I went radical feminist for a month or two, which was healing because I could finally connect with and support women, but I stopped because I couldn't fully agree with them and noticed how angry I was toward trans males. I unlearned my negative associations with the words "girl" and "woman." I also studied psychology independently for many years, including Carl Jung's shadow work and Jordan Peterson's interpretations.
Medical: I was on testosterone for 1.5 years (ages 17-19, starting 2012). I had a double mastectomy. I had a pneumothorax at some point (mentioned in passing regarding wishing I'd had post-surgical therapy). I theorize T may have given me osteoarthritis in my hip and forehead creases — I probably wouldn't have these if I hadn't been on T. I have a prominent Adam's apple, visible larynx, a croaky/gravelly voice, some facial hair (I pluck my chin hairs constantly), slightly extended brow bone, and "bottom growth." My breasts grew back to full A's after detransition. I had a scare with lumps in my breasts when I first got off T — turned out they were just ducts and glands growing. I considered surgery to reduce my clitoral size but decided against it for fear of losing sensation. I use a copper IUD. I have a family history on my dad's female side that makes me uncertain about pregnancy.
Mental health: I had depression and anxiety after detransition that was "pretty damn crippling." After detransitioning I felt incredibly trapped, lonely and confused and thought about death (not executing it, but it crossed my mind). I had body dysmorphia alongside gender dysphoria. I had black-and-white thinking and obsessive tendencies as a teen. I've since done life coaching and self-therapy via self-help books and psychology. I also experienced what I think was emotional dysregulation, particularly around emotional abandonment.
Adversity: My parents divorced. I had an emotionally neglectful childhood. My mom used my birth name as punishment, which is why I couldn't go back to it. I was bullied by other girls for being too masculine, then also for being too feminine — my tomboyishness didn't belong anywhere. I was isolated during my trans years due to stealth and my sexuality.
Sexuality: I'm mostly straight now. Before transition I thought I was bisexual. I was obsessed with yaoi/MLM content as a teen. As a trans teen, no guy was interested in me. I now recognize my retransition urges as autoandrophilia speaking, not an actual desire to be the opposite sex.
Regret: I would totally prevent myself from transitioning if I could — I'd stop myself from ever going on Tumblr or following blogs that mentioned transgenderism. I wouldn't have the added struggle of reverse dysphoria and severe depression from getting off T. I felt robbed of my teenage years and at 26 I'm still trying to reclaim them. I've been overcompensating with a sharp interest in dresses, skirts and make-up. I got into an open relationship to date more men because as a trans teen no guy was interested. I sometimes feel like an imposter talking publicly about my transition because I can barely remember the three years I identified as male. I now see transition as something I wouldn't do again but I'm grateful it happened — my life coach taught me there are no failures, only learning opportunities.
Outcomes: I'm now a detransitioned woman with a husband and boyfriend, a lovely set of friends, and I've worked on myself a lot. I have a YouTube channel discussing detransition. I became a moderator of r/detrans. I've been accused by two men of being an autogynephilic trans-identified male pretending to be a detransitioned FtM, which hurt but didn't crush me because I'm not freshly detransitioned.
Attitudes: I believe dysphoria is entirely based on societal expectations and strict enforcement of gender stereotypes. I think affirmative care needs to be abolished and that underlying mental health issues (ADHD, autism, OCD, MDD, BPD, etc.) should be treated first. I'm critical of puberty blockers for children. I don't recommend transition for anyone. I believe in watch-and-wait approaches. I advocate for GNC representation in media. I've done advocacy through my YouTube channel and subreddit moderation.