Alle verhalen

Een brief aan een FtM-tiener in 1985, nooit beantwoord

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd131
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben nooit getransitioneerd, wat volgens mij de enige reden is dat ik ontsnapte aan wat ik nu zie als trans-schade; mijn kwetsbare leeftijd was medio jaren 80, toen ik in een tijdschrift het verhaal van een FtM-tiener las en een brief schreef die nooit werd beantwoord. Ik ben een autistische, aseksuele tomboy van 54 die zich niet als vrouw of man kan identificeren en zegt dat ik helemaal geen gender lijk te hebben. Ik heb genderdysforie, CPTSS en ASS, en omschrijf mijn zenuwstelsel als kapot, met gezondheidsproblemen waardoor het onmogelijk is me goed te voelen in mijn lichaam. Ik heb suïcidale gevoelens gehad over het gevangen zitten in mijn lichaam, maar zeg dat ik er niet naar zal handelen omdat ik niet wil verknoeien wat mijn plannen ook waren bij het komen naar de aarde. Ik heb nu sterk kritische opvattingen over medische transitie, die ik met een sekte vergelijk, en moedig niet-medische gendernonconformistische expressie en het opbouwen van een detrans-gemeenschap aan.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and I never transitioned — that is, in my own view, the only reason I escaped what I now see as trans damage. My vulnerable age fell in the mid-1980s, when there was no internet and transsexuality was only just beginning to be popularized through mainstream youth magazines. I read the story of an FtM trans teen in one of those magazines and could immediately identify with it; it was very emotional for me, and I wrote a letter to the magazine, but fortunately never got a reply. I am now 54 years old and I describe myself as an autistic, asexual tomboy who cannot identify as a woman or as a man. I say I don't really understand gender — I don't seem to have any, I just exist, which I consider kind of lucky because that way I don't want to be anything specific. I have gender dysphoria, CPTSD, and ASD (autism spectrum disorder), but because sex change was not an option when I was young, I had to deal with those things in other ways. I have struggled with my body as well. I can relate to perceiving my body as an alien thing that I'm forced to drag around with me, and I say that it makes me suicidal too — I want out of here — but I won't do it, because I don't want to mess up any plans I may have had in coming into this challenging situation of being a human on earth. I have described trying so hard to find happiness but never finding it and always feeling lonely, until I stopped trying to 'fix it.' For me the health problems are the most challenging; it's impossible to feel good in my body, and I say the nervous system is wrecked. I also say trauma sits mainly in the body's nervous system, especially with CPTSD, and that I have a similar problem — it's not all in the mind, so talking about it usually just triggers more stress. What moved me toward a different way of seeing things was investigating near-death experiences, non-physical reality, and pre-birth memories. Reading Christian Sundberg's book 'A Walk in the Physical' about pre-birth memories was life-changing for me and gave me a workable framework for coping with misery. I came to believe that we are eternal spirits temporarily riding a body, that suffering has a purpose, and that our suffering doesn't make us losers. I gave up trying to be happy and, strangely, that eased the suffering a lot. I also recommend hypnosis for turning down the volume of pain, and I've found helpful information on YouTube about Polyvagal Theory, dissociation, attachment styles, and reconnecting with the body. I mention EMDR as a possible therapy but caution that not all therapies are helpful and many can make you worse. On family, I had to leave my family behind and now have only very superficial contact, which I think is better for all of us. I love them and want them to be happy, but they just can't like me, though they try to be kind when we have contact — as long as I don't speak or act as myself. It's not just the autism; I never managed to blend in with them the way they wanted, and being my own person is not allowed. I immigrated to the other end of the world, so contact is naturally limited. I have few friends with little contact because I'm always worried about being a nuisance; I know autistic people are strangely intense for neurotypical people and I don't want to annoy anybody. Over the years I managed to shift focus from what other people think about me to how I feel about myself, which improved my self-esteem a lot. I believe I need to learn to love myself wholeheartedly and be my own best friend. I never transitioned, so I don't have surgical or hormonal regrets of my own, but I hold strong views about transition for others. I compare being drawn into trans identification to being sucked into a cult: people go into denial, communication with the outside world breaks down, and anyone who leaves becomes a threat and must be shunned. I believe the only chance for people stuck in it is when the pain gets strong enough to force them to leave, and that for people happy in it there is no chance. I'm critical of what I call the industrial sex-change machinery and corporate entities that prey on the most vulnerable while parents blindly believe in the 'experts.' I've suggested to others that they could start a detrans support group in their area, and I've warned about the bad side effects of messing with hormones, especially in the male body. I'm supportive of gender non-conforming expression without medical transition — I've suggested hair removal, make-up, long hair, and eyeliner as alternatives, saying to be gender non-conforming is nothing extreme or ideological. I have not done formal advocacy or activism, but I joined this community because I wanted to reply to a post and I regularly engage with detransitioned and questioning people, offering spiritual and practical perspectives. My current identity: I am a detransitioned... rather, I never transitioned; I identify as an autistic, asexual tomboy who doesn't identify as a woman or a man, and I say I just exist without gender.