Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerde vrouw die zich tijdens de middelbare school vier jaar als FtM identificeerde, en mijn moeder voorkwam de medische ingrepen die ik wilde, waar ik nu diep dankbaar voor ben. Mijn transitie schrijf ik toe aan autisme-gerelateerde vervreemding, biseksualiteit, ernstige OCD, behoefte aan controle en maatschappelijke vrouwenhaat, niet aan iets mis met mijn lichaam. Nu beschouw ik mezelf als enigszins non-binair maar identificeer ik me vooral niet met gendernamen, en ik denk helemaal niet meer aan gender. Ik heb kritische opvattingen over de uitholling van sekse-gebonden ruimtes voor vrouwen en raad anderen die transitie in twijfel trekken aan niet-genderbevestigende therapie te zoeken in plaats van medische ingrepen. Ik beschrijf in mijn eigen geval geen operaties, hormonen of voortdurende medische behoeften, en geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging.
Volledig verhaal
I am a desisted female who identified as FtM for four years during high school. I wanted medical interventions badly at the time, but my mother prevented them, and I am now deeply grateful to her for saving me from what I believe would have been a traumatic and expensive transition and detransition.
Looking back, I understand my transition as rooted in several factors. I am autistic, and I felt alienated due to that, along with being bisexual. I now believe the real problem was society's gender norms and misogyny rather than anything about my own body — I've come to accept that it was 'other people and misogyny that was my problem, not myself.' I also have severe OCD, and I recognize that my transition period was definitely OCD-related. In hindsight I'm shocked I didn't realize sooner that it was just OCD. I think part of the appeal was having something I could control, and while I felt euphoric early on, that feeling faded over time.
I don't think about my gender at all anymore. I consider myself to be somewhat nonbinary at this point, but more than anything it's that I really just don't identify with gender labels. Being trans for a few years was a valuable experience and an important part of my life, but it just wasn't who I really was.
I have also dealt with physical issues — at one point I discussed acne, noting I had been on estrogen birth control and when I stopped it my acne was horrendous and took years to go away, and I speculated the biological process for someone stopping estrogen (as in a male detransitioner's case) would be much the same.
On transition more broadly, I hold nuanced views. I've advised a young African American male questioning transition that he can be beautiful as a man without needing to be a trans woman, that his issue seemed more about self-acceptance and loving his body than gender, and that bone structure won't change even with transition. I recommended finding a good, non-gender-affirming therapist — specifically anyone who wouldn't push him to medically transition since he was in a delicate place — and doing things that make him feel beautiful as a man.
I also hold critical views on sex-based spaces and gender ideology. I believe that eroding the link between 'woman' and 'female' eliminates spaces for females, and that there really aren't any female-only spaces anymore. While I recognize some spaces can benefit from including trans women, I argue there are issues specific to the female sex — pregnancy, menstruation, and the fact that research and safety testing is performed on males rather than females, leaving no safety equipment or data for females. I see this as being lost in the campaign to support trans women, and I maintain that misogyny is real and that a huge part of it has to do with being female, not just an idea of womanhood one can identify into.
I don't describe any surgeries, hormone use, or puberty blockers in my own case — my mother prevented the medical interventions I wanted, so I appear to have avoided medical transition entirely. I don't describe ongoing medical needs, fertility concerns, or complications from transition in my own story. I don't discuss romantic relationships, family rejection (my mother was supportive and protective), or career impacts. I don't describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or mental health crises after desisting; my OCD is described in relation to the transition period itself, and I say I no longer think about gender at all.