Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Volledig verhaal
I have never medically transitioned — I'm older and from a time with more barriers to transition, which gave me time to resolve my dysphoria naturally. Looking back, I can see signs that my dysphoria was going to resolve with experience: a narrow view of what it was okay for a man to be that didn't include homosexuality or femininity, and wanting to look a certain way to attract a certain flavor of romantic attachment — specifically, I wanted to be a woman to attract a man and exist in a heteronormative relationship as the woman.
I'm a gay man, though I've been with one trans guy and guess I'm 'a little bi' — I've really only been truly attracted to men and women who have had FtM hormones, and I think I'm more attracted to secondary sex characteristics over primary ones. I wouldn't put 'bi' on a dating profile because the term would be misleading to women. I frame it as: sometimes trans-identifying people illicit homosexual attraction leading to heterosexual acts, and heterosexual attraction leading to homosexual acts — I don't think that recategorizes the attracted person.
I think of 'trans' as a modern Western social construction — real like Christians, Kiwanis, or metal heads are real — and I don't believe transness is inherent to the human condition. I do think queerness is inherent to human populations, and different cultures at different times deal with it in different ways, with different identities and labels. I compare it to holiness: shamans, priests, imams have similar but different societal functions. Every society has cultural norms for males and females, and then people who don't fit the one matching their sex — whom I'll just call 'queer.' Our society has created a form of queerness that requires medicalization, which is pretty novel, and some of us question the overall health of that practice with the technology at its present level. I think being trans (or gay, or a fireman, or a parent, or any identity) is more of a verb than a noun — a thing you do, a role in society, more than a fixed object to be.
I'm critical of therapists who specialize in gender — I believe they're often taught in trainings that make them feel specialized to be gender 'yes men' who discourage exploration, which is sad because we need more people willing to explore gender with their patients. I think laws in Oregon and other states make therapists fear providing therapy, insights, or feedback that counters the culturally dominant narrative around modern western queerness. I'd encourage someone whose therapist states whether they think they're trans to ask the therapist honestly what their definition of 'trans' is and why they don't think you're it. I also suggest reframing the idea of 'really trans' — you're just a soul (or brain) in a meat suit making choices, and the idea that there's some objective, spiritual 'trans' to be or not be is reductive.
I'm sex-positive all around — I feel leftists are sex positive for everyone but straight men, and red-pilled women are sex positive for ONLY straight men. I've recommended The Metaphor of Gender YouTube channel and Ken Wilber's four-quadrant model for thinking about whether trans is 'real' (experience, culture, objective/material reality, systems). I've also recommended the Tao Te Ching (and the Red Pine translation) for helping accept present circumstances with dignity and grace, and I once wrote a whole essay about my experience for fun.
I've given advice to others about coming clean in relationships — I used to be a big white liar and worked on admitting lies immediately, which broke the habit. I've also cautioned someone about trading one strict set of rules for another in pursuit of a 'proper life.' I expect the ideology to stay for at least a generation, but think people can fight for legal boundaries and culturally make off-ramps for those having negative experiences, while allowing the framework to exist for those it serves. I also expect things to change as technology changes — if transition were cheap and without side effects, most of gender ideology as-is becomes much more harmless.