Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die in 2019-2020, schrijvend onder een homoseksuele mannelijke identiteit, gepassioneerd betoogde dat transitie geworteld is in zelfhaat, geïnternaliseerde misandrie en autogynefilie, en neerkomt op zelfbeschadiging. Ik steunde detransitioners openlijk, bekritiseerde chirurgen en therapeuten voor het aanrichten van schade en deelde media over transitiespijt. Ik zet mijn eigen medische tijdlijn in deze berichten niet uiteen, maar mijn vijandigheid tegenover transitie en mijn identificatie als homoseksuele man zijn consistent. Ik was strijdlustig en soms misogyn als ik online werd aangesproken. Ik heb in mijn eigen geval geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have never written much about my own transition history on Reddit — most of what I've posted there, especially around the end of 2019 and into early 2020, has been me arguing with other people about transition, autogynephilia, and detransition. Reading back over it, though, it's clear I was working through my own feelings by lecturing others.
In late December 2019 I got into a long exchange with someone who was questioning whether to transition. I told them bluntly that they seemed to hate men and masculinity, that they needed counseling to "get over your hatred of men to learn to love yourself and your natural body again," and that they were "the kind of autogynephile who loves women and thinks they are superior to men aka 'If you can't beat them, join 'em.'" I said transitioning wouldn't solve their problems. I framed my own perspective as that of a gay man — "as a gay man, I thank goodness every day I'm gay so I don't have to deal with women in a romantic or sexual sense" — and I said I personally find women gross in a romantic or sexual sense. I pushed back hard on the idea that porn was the issue: "There's nothing wrong with porn. That's not the problem here. It's his hatred of men and his own body." I also said things like "Transitioning is self harm. Period." and that "the entirety of transitioning and transgenderism is self harm, self hate, and gender envy." I defended MGTOW and MRA spaces, denied the relevance of the "alt right" label, and cited a claim that women initiate domestic violence 70% of the time. I told one person they had "internalized misogyny" and should "learn to love the body you were born with."
I was clearly not neutral on the medical side. When someone posted about regretting SRS, I called it "buyer's remorse" that is "far, far more common than most 'success stories' like to claim," said dysphoria can clear up leaving you "with a series of regretful changes," and urged them to "speak out more and help save more lives from making the same mistake." I described post-op anatomy in crude terms — "a flesh pouch / pocket you have to dilate to keep from sealing up permanently" — and said surgeons and other professionals "took advantage" and acted "against their oath." I suggested they sue for malpractice and said post-op trans people should hold providers accountable for "predatory, experimental abuse of power." In January 2020 I again criticized "experts" who "vowed to 'Do No Harm'" for "choosing an easy paycheck to play along versus doing their job."
I also commented on other people's detransitions in a supportive, appearance-focused way. I told one detransitioned person, "You're so much better as a lady... your female form is far more stunning," and told another, "Thank goodness you detransitioned. Your natural feminine looks works with or without makeup." I shared a YouTube video titled "'TRANS SURGERY RUINED MY LIFE' - Trans Woman Transitions Back to Man: EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW" to the community, which got a positive reception. I praised someone with "Awesome job!!" after they detransitioned.
I was combative when challenged. When someone implied something about my comments, I replied, "Well I'm gay so whatever bullshit you're implying is nonsense... Your vagina has no power over me," and told them to "get some therapy for your narcissism." I also defended a commenter named Elijah Schaffer against accusations of disrespect.
On therapy, I was encouraging: I told someone to "go check out the office" because "you'd be surprised how many therapists are willing to work with low income, do payment plans," and framed a therapist as being like "an eyebrow waxer" who loves a returning customer. I also made a passing reference to my mother's periods — "they helped my mom stop her periods" — when discussing IUDs and the ring.
I don't have a clear, detailed public account of my own transition timeline, surgeries, or detransition date in what I've written. What comes through is that I identified as a gay man by late 2019, that I had strong feelings that transition was self-harm rooted in self-hatred and gender envy, that I was hostile to the medical establishment's role in transition, and that I was supportive of detransitioners — while also being defensive, combative, and at times misogynistic and hostile toward feminists in online arguments. I don't describe any current mental health diagnosis, and I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm in my own case.