Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerd persoon die als man geboren is, zich identificeerde als non-binair en later als verwijfde man, en een paar maanden estrogeen en spironolacton probeerde voordat ik stopte. Ik detransitioneerde omdat transitie me een blootgesteld gevoel gaf en me bewust maakte van een tegenstrijdigheid die anderen konden zien, terwijl leven als verwijfde man me mijn dysforie liet beheersen zonder medische ingrepen. Mijn OCD, depressie en sociale angst verbeteren door therapie, veranderingen in mijn leefstijl en kritische introspectie in plaats van door hormonen. Ik sta achter detransitie als de juiste weg voor mij, terwijl ik respecteer dat trans mensen bestaan en dat hun ervaringen geldig zijn, en ik houd me met deze thema's bezig vanuit mijn interesse in bio-ethiek. Ik uit in dit verhaal geen intens spijtgevoel over specifieke onomkeerbare veranderingen.
Volledig verhaal
I am a detransitioned person who was born male and identified as non-binary and later as a feminine man. My dysphoria was never crippling enough to justify the medical burden of hormones, and I came to believe that the cons of HRT outweighed the benefits for me.
I did try hormone therapy: I was on estrogen for only a couple of months, and I also used spironolactone. I stopped the estrogen abruptly and tapered the spiro, cutting the dose in half every four days, because stopping spiro all at once can cause electrolyte problems. I advised others to see a GP to test testosterone levels after stopping, and to go to the hospital if they experienced nervous or heart-related symptoms like arrhythmia, palpitations, or confusion. I was only on HRT for a few months, and I noticed that a few months back on testosterone things returned to normal.
What moved me toward detransitioning was a loss of confidence once I started thinking about how I was being perceived. Socially, having dysphoria without transitioning was something I could handle, because no one sees the dysphoria and I didn't feel vulnerable. But once I transitioned, I started feeling like everyone was always going to be able to see that private aspect of myself, and also the contradiction — the "woman" I wasn't but was trying to be. I also found that living as a feminine man, and not focusing so much on how I was perceived, really helped me get a hold of the dysphoria. It's not gone, but it's just not that important anymore.
I told others in the community to stop chasing a female ideal, noting that you are never going to be female, and that you can be a feminine or androgynous male with or without HRT — you don't need hormones to look that way. I suggested people think about whether they want the rest of their life to revolve around a medical treatment, including blood tests and side effects. I also said that you can always try HRT and abandon it later, and that it gave me much more confidence as a male knowing that I tried and desisted. I told someone who believed they would never be happy that this wasn't true, and that whatever they chose, things would get better later and the dysphoria didn't have to be the center of their life.
On therapy and mental health: as of May 2022, I said things were getting better, and I attributed the improvement not to estrogen but to therapy, lifestyle changes, and critical introspection, which I had been working on for years. I noted that my psychological problems are not necessarily related to dysphoria — I mentioned OCD, depression, and social anxiety.
I have a trans cousin who experienced the opposite of me: she became super confident after HRT. I said she may be perfectly self-aware and feel good about her choice, and that detransitioning was the right path for us, but trans people still exist and their experiences are just as valid.
I am interested in bioethics — I said "I'm into bioethics, that's what I do" — and I argued that criticism of medical practice needs to be supported with facts, not stereotypes, comparing unfounded stereotypes about medical practice to how antivaxxers are made. I pushed back against the idea that doctors push unwanted treatment, noting that pushing unnecessary, unwanted and harmful treatment is illegal, unethical, and not regular medical practice.
I don't express regret about specific irreversible changes in this transcript, but I do frame my detransition as the right path for me.