Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die op mijn 15e mijn borsten liet afzetten, toen mijn ongemak nog lichaamsdysmorfie werd genoemd. Ongeveer twee jaar Jungiaanse en somatic experiencing-therapie hielp me zelfhaat te overwinnen en me thuis te voelen in mijn lichaam, al voel ik nog steeds de ontbrekende massa waar mijn borsten waren. Nu zie ik mijn ongemak met mijn vrouwelijke lichaam als een traumarespons die voortkomt uit een moeilijke kindertijd en intergenerationeel trauma rond vrouwelijkheid. Drie jaar na het begin van therapie was ik van plan een gezin te stichten, ondanks dat ik eerder antinatalist was, en ik ben trots moeder te worden, ook al kan ik geen borstvoeding geven. Ik ben kritisch op genderbevestigende zorg voor kinderen en sceptisch over het concept ‘geboren in het verkeerde lichaam’, terwijl ik geloof dat volwassenen hun eigen keuzes moeten maken.
Volledig verhaal
I am a millennial who was raised in a major city, where my high school was full of kids with different colored hair, piercings, goth kids, smokers, and JNCO-style pants — so I never personally experienced much punishment for gender nonconformity beyond a 'weird look' from a stranger. Back when I was young, what I now recognize in myself was called body dysmorphia. I had my breasts cut off at 15. I consider myself lucky that no one tried to sterilize me or convinced me I was 'born in the wrong body' at that age.
After the mastectomy I lived with long-standing self-loathing and discomfort in my body. What changed everything for me was getting into therapy — specifically Jungian therapy and somatic experiencing (a body-centered therapy, not mind/ego work). It took me about two years of two different types of therapy before I became comfortable in my body, and beyond that I began to fall in love with myself and my body. In somatic therapy I can physically feel the loss of my breasts — there is mass missing from my body, and despite not being sure how I would carry large breasts, my body feels less safe in a way because there is a piece missing (the piece that provided protection for my heart). Somatic therapy was hugely helpful for that missing mass.
I now feel 'at home' in the body I was given. A regulated nervous system has the capacity to be itself, and it's amazing not to have to be in so much control/hypervigilance anymore — it's really special to be able to know and rely on my body as my safe place, my protector. I have all the wisdom in my body, in my experience way more than what's in my head. I think labeling avoids feeling, and that humans are animals who cannot avoid feeling despite many generations desperately trying to do exactly that.
I believe being uncomfortable in one's own body is likely a result of generations of developmental trauma being passed down until a tipping point — families (and societies) that rejected femininity or masculinity and blindly passed on their own self-hatred to their children. I see my own relationship with my female body as a trauma response rooted in a difficult childhood. I think about this in terms of ancestral trauma: it's my parents, grandparents, and so on, plus society, culture, and religion, that repressed serious things around women and femininity, and it landed on me to deal with. I take responsibility for the fact that no one in my family was strong enough to look at it, and I see the work I do in therapy as being for me and for my ancestors — 'all the work I do in there is for me, and it's for my ancestors.'
I am critical of gender-affirming care for children, which I view as human experimentation/dismemberment and suspect will be viewed in the future as stunningly appalling and the clearest example of mass projection onto children. For adults, however, I think adults should be able to do what they want — 'it's on them if they can't figure out how to receive actual therapy.' I am skeptical of the concept of being 'born in the wrong body' and repeatedly ask for the science or physics of how that could happen, saying that until someone can prove it, I will never believe the 'total self annihilation (and soft suicide)' of that idea. I also suspect there is an enormous financial push to get as many people as possible on lifelong medications for profit, and after the last few years I am more convinced than ever not to trust external authority — 'trusting external authority about personal self expression was not something I as a millennial was raised with.'
I have recommended resources to others, including genspect.org, genderexploratory.com, and a Jungian Life podcast detransition episode that I found very moving. I have told others that if they can get into therapy, they can overcome self-loathing and long-standing body discomfort.
As of early 2024, three years into therapy, I was thinking about starting a family — noting that I had previously been antinatalist as well. I acknowledged I may not be able to breastfeed, but said I am 'so proud and lucky to get to be able to be a mother.'
In general I try not to care what people think of me or what words they use — I think that's the definition of emotional maturity, knowing the difference between words and actions. I'd defend myself if someone came at me with a knife, but words don't bother me.