Alle verhalen

Een decennium gender, en dan ontwaken uit de sekte

Man · Gedetransitioneerd1,2K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik desisteerde ongeveer tien maanden voor maart 2023 van een trans-/non-binaire identiteit, na meer dan een decennium waarin gender centraal stond in mijn leven, en ik ben een gedetransitioneerde man. Ik stopte met testosteron en schaam me nu voor mijn vroegere identificatie, die ik omschrijf als 'ontwaken uit een sekte'. Sinds het desisteren ervaar ik leed, vervreemding en nihilistische gevoelens, en huil ik soms om het het zwijgen opleggen van detransitieperspectieven. Ik geloof dat gendernonconformiteit wordt gemedicaliseerd en dat transgemeenschappen de 'logica van dysforie' zelf voortplanten, terwijl ik gendernonconformiteit nog steeds steun en transitie als laatste redmiddel zie. Ik pleit voor de stem van detransitioners en bekritiseer media die detransitie gelijkstellen aan zelfmoord.

Volledig verhaal

I had identified with gender nonconformity and trans identity for over a decade before desisting, and by March 2023 I was roughly ten months off testosterone. I described the experience of changing my mind as feeling like 'awakening from a cult,' and said I now lived 'in embarrassment of my past.' I had previously identified as nonbinary and had dysphoria, which I described as 'an aversion to identifying with my sex.' I came to believe that being trans was 'more of an idea than an essential quality' and that 'transition is something you do, not something you are.' I felt that a 'fallacious identity that dissociated me from my sex made me more dysphoric and insecure,' and I was glad I desisted. I was deeply distressed in early 2023, sometimes to the point of crying, about what I saw as the silencing of detransition perspectives and the pressure of what I called a 'quasi-religious dogma.' I felt alienated from friends because I did not feel safe discussing these thoughts openly, and I described an aversion to and fear of 'discourse' rather than of trans people themselves. I experienced strong nihilistic feelings since desisting, about my place in time and 'the absurd construct of society,' and I said I wanted empathy and love rather than being treated 'like an injured subject.' I worried that gender nonconformity was being medicalized by 'our patriarchal society and medical industry,' and that gender ideology oversimplified difficult psychological and sociocultural relationships with gender. I worried that the belief 'identity ≠ sex' encouraged people to develop dysphoria by giving them 'maladaptive identities.' I compared trans communities to anorexia communities and to a multiple-personality-disorder community that tells members their other personalities are real, saying such a community 'sounds horrifying' but also 'familiar.' I also noted a nonbinary friend who wanted to 'microdose e' believing estrogen was therapeutic like CBD, and felt this had become 'far too casual and simplified.' I reflected with embarrassment on having posted, a decade before desisting, on International Women's Day that people should stop supporting cis women and read queer theory instead — 'a male telling people to stop listening to women on a day dedicated to them.' I noted that when I propagated gender ideology I received tons of support on social media. I had a cis girlfriend at some point whose voice I found sexy and confident. I believed detransitioners disprove the ideology of innate gender and wrong bodies, and had faith that our existence alone would change the discourse on gender in time. I criticized media equating detransition to suicide as 'detransphobic,' and argued that trans people are likely higher than 1% of the population while also pointing out the inconsistency in activists' arguments about that figure. I supported gender nonconformity, masc women, femme men, and cultural exploration, but felt transition should be 'the last stop on a long journey of self exploration.' I worried some people don't give themselves a grace period to integrate gender nonconformity before 'jumping into an identity and design of a new person they imagine, as an impulsive escape.' I cautioned others against letting trauma distort their worldview and pushed back on sexist 'pussification of men' conspiracy thinking within the detrans community. I did not describe any specific therapy, medical complications, or fertility concerns in these posts.