Alle verhalen

Zes jaar non-binair, zonder hormonen

Vrouw · GedesisteerdEerste dysforie 15 → Desistance 21448
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde (gedesisteerde) vrouw die me ongeveer zes jaar, van mijn 15e tot mijn 21e, non-binair identificeerde zonder ooit medisch te transitioneren. Ik ging geloven dat mijn identiteit voortkwam uit trauma uit mijn kindertijd, pesten op een meisjesschool, psychische ziekte en neurodivergentie (ADHD, mogelijk autisme), versterkt door Tumblr en de online queercultuur. In augustus 2020 kwam ik sociaal uit de kast als gedesisteerd en schakelde ik terug naar zij/haar-voornaamwoorden, met meestal positieve reacties van volgers en mijn ouders. Ik heb geen genderdysforie meer en identificeer me nu als vrouw, terwijl ik transmensen blijf steunen en kritisch ben over overhaaste medische transitie, vooral voor minderjarigen. Ik heb in het verleden te maken gehad met depressie, angst, suïcidale gedachten en zelfbeschadiging, allemaal behandeld met therapie en medicatie.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female and first came out as a lesbian in 8th grade, around age 14, then started using Tumblr and around age 15 realized the non-binary label seemed to fit my feelings. I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria at 15 and had been in therapy since I was 13. I identified as non-binary for about six years, from roughly age 15 to 21, but I never transitioned physically in any way — no hormones, no surgeries, no puberty blockers, and I never bound my chest because chest compression made my anxiety worse. Most of my dysphoria was social rather than physical, and I managed what body discomfort I had with gender-neutral clothing and sports bras. A lot of what led me toward identifying as non-binary, I now think, traces back to childhood and adolescent difficulties. I attended an all-girls school for ten years, from age 6 to nearly 16, and was treated badly by hyper-feminine girls who outcast me for not fitting their mold, including bullying for not being feminine enough and sexuality-related bullying. I wonder whether my very mentally ill younger self latched onto the non-binary identity as a rejection of womanhood because of that mistreatment. I also had a collection of "little t" traumas: an alcoholic stay-at-home primary parent, an absent working parent (who was also the same-sex parent), multiple learning disabilities, poor socialization skills, and bullying. These led to depression, anxiety, suicidal thoughts, and self-harm, all of which I've addressed in therapy and with medication, though the disconnect from my body hadn't been dealt with until recently. I've also been diagnosed with multiple mental illnesses over the years and have been hospitalized. I believe I have ADHD and possibly autism, and I think being neurodivergent, particularly struggling to socialize with girls at a single-sex school, shaped how I experienced gender. I also think the internet played a role. I'm fairly certain I came to my trans identity because of the internet, specifically Tumblr, where I first saw information about being trans. I've described the online queer community for teens as "kind of cultish" and almost a competition for how queer you can be. I was the only trans kid at my school when I first came out and nobody followed my lead. A turning point came when I switched from the all-girls school to a gender-affirming alternative high school. There I wasn't being bullied anymore, the schoolwork was easier, and I hated my body exponentially less, realizing I was more in the middle of male and female. It was as though not having to fight for my identity made me feel less far away from my assigned gender. Over time, through soul searching, I realized it was healthier for me to identify as female again. I acknowledged I have some traditionally masculine and some traditionally feminine traits and that this doesn't have to mean anything about my gender. If my gender doesn't mean anything to me, then all that's left is sex, and I'm female, so female pronouns make sense. I desisted publicly around August 2020. I changed my name and pronouns back in my bio and made a post announcing I was using she/her pronouns again, thanking my followers for being on the journey with me. All the responses were positive and I only lost one follower. I told my parents over a family meal — I'm an only child — and both were surprised but took it well; my dad cried because he was so glad life would be easier for me. I decided not to go back to my birth name because I associate it with a younger self I don't like; my chosen name is a non-gendered noun-name, so I kept it. I've been in therapy for nearly half my life, currently working with a therapist through my college, and I interviewed her beforehand to make sure she'd be willing to discuss challenging topics about gender and trauma from a place of compassion for trans people. My goal is to sort through the traumas that may have led me to feel trans. I also journal. Around that time I was considering growing my hair out for the first time in six years and found the idea of being "just a lesbian" exciting. I went through a difficult adjustment wearing regular bras again after six years of only sports bras, crying the first couple of times because of discomfort and "weird gender feels," but it got easier over a few months. As of spring 2021, I got over my discomfort with she/her fairly quickly by acknowledging that only I get to decide who I am and what my gender is — my pronouns only describe the vessel I'm in. I no longer have dysphoria or worry about my gender. My goal is to be neutral about being seen as a woman at least occasionally and to be happy with my body as it is, though I said even writing that made me feel some dysphoria at the time, and I wished I could someday wake up as a body-confident cis lesbian, knowing it would take years of work. In September 2021 I wrote about watching a younger family friend, eight years older than him, come out as trans at the same age I did, with all the "warning signs" for desisting that I had. I compared it to watching someone with similar experiences to a recovered alcoholic start drinking. I worried because he'd been bullied for supposedly being trans in elementary school because of his "masculine" interests, and because his chosen name and online persona had more-than-coincidental ties to my own chosen name and online persona from when I was his age. I felt sad that I might have contributed to his conclusions. I said I didn't care about being right — I just didn't want to see him in pain. My IRLs, except my parents, thought it would be overstepping to say anything, and I agreed I'd never say anything to him about my feelings. I was tempted to pursue a degree studying the link between trans identities, mental illness, and neurodivergence. I still consider myself part of the trans community in the sense that being non-binary is often treated as trans, though other commenters made me question that interpretation. I have nothing but love for trans people and no space for hatred. I believe trauma can cause people to believe they're trans, that deeper emotional issues should be ruled out before concluding "legitimate" transness causes dysphoria, and that minors especially should wait before making permanent changes — I'm grateful I didn't get into HRT at 15 because I was very suggestible. I would not trust my 17-year-old self with any decision that could affect my entire life. At the same time, I don't think it's my place to hate on people on either side, and I believe adults should be able to do what they want with their bodies.