Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedesisteerd persoon: ik transitioneerde sociaal en identificeerde me als trans, waaronder non-binair gebruiken als opstapje naar FTM-identificatie, maar ik onderging nooit een medische transitie en stopte met me als trans te identificeren toen ik besefte dat ik geen testosteron wilde. Ik gebruik nu ‘gedesisteerd’ in plaats van ‘gedetransitioneerd’ vanwege dat onderscheid. Ik heb geen operaties, hormonen of medische complicaties gemeld, en ik beschouw mijn zelfacceptatie als beter dan het alternatief van T nemen. Ik blijf actief in detrans-ruimtes, steun de individuele keuzes van anderen en ben kritisch over zowel transmedicalistische beweringen als detrans-ruimtes die door niet-detrans mensen worden bewaakt. In mijn verhaal worden geen suïcidale gedachten, zelfbeschadiging of zelfmoordpogingen beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I have always drawn a careful line between the words I use for my own experience. I use the word 'desisting' for myself because I never went through medical transition, but I did believe I was trans and I did socially transition. I usually associate detransition with someone who took steps to transition medically but then stopped. Because different stages have different effects, I find it easier to communicate when people distinguish them — some people just use the term reidentified, and I think that can be helpful too. For myself I was socially out but not medically transitioned, so 'desisted' is more of an accurate label than 'detransitioned'.
Looking back, I used non-binary as a stepping stone in both directions. I first used non-binary as a stepping stone to identifying as FTM, and then I used it again to step down when I realised that testosterone wasn't something I wanted to do. I noticed someone else who had medically detransitioned and started to identify as non-binary instead, and it made me realise I had done something similar. I put that question to the community in a post in April 2020, asking whether anyone else had used being non-binary as a stepping stone of sorts.
On the question of how I think about my own body and choices now, I told someone that they are not obligated to love their family or not want them to worry, and that if they are okay with their top surgery I am happy for them. For me, a big change in how you are perceived takes some getting used to, but it does help with self-acceptance, which was better for me than the alternative of taking testosterone and facing future complications. I do not think it is ever too late to detransition — there are people who have been in the process for a while and then detransition. It can be harder to detransition socially or medically if you have been transitioning for a long time, but it is an option that is there if you want it.
I have thought a lot about how people consume content that upsets them. Sometimes people seek out content they know will upset them — for example those with PTSD might try to face their triggers, but it can set their progress back. I wouldn't class reading detrans content as self-harm, though. It's sad that the moment someone expresses having second thoughts they are told to ignore it by the community. I see similar talk with trans people reading gender-critical content even though it upsets them, which doesn't sound healthy to me, and I would recommend stopping reading or blocking if it is affecting your wellbeing. In a follow-up conversation someone explained that they found such reading helpful, possibly as exposure therapy, and I acknowledged that it has also been beneficial for me with triggers. I clarified that I meant more someone seeking out content they know will be triggering in a way that isn't therapeutic — I don't think it's self-harm, but I do think it can be unhealthy for some people if it is not productive or helpful. I'm glad I allowed myself to read what at the time I didn't want to, and I'm glad we have a space like this.
I have also engaged with community politics. I've said that this subreddit should be focused on detrans issues — if someone is both gender-critical and detrans that's not a problem, but if they're a trans or gender-critical person who hasn't detransitioned and they're trying to debate, this isn't the space for it. I've expressed annoyance at the claim some transmedicalists make that 'detransition happens when you don't have dysphoria'. I've also warned someone away from Trans Lifeline, saying I hadn't heard good things about it and that it turned out they were scamming or embezzling funds while calls went unanswered, and I advised against posting pictures on a certain sub because replies to pictures don't generate compassionate responses the way written experiences might. I've commented supportively to others, saying 'I'm desisted and glad that you're back up' and mocking a subreddit 'ran by people who are not detrans to police us'.