Alle verhalen

Gedrongen tot transitie, zei hij tientallen jaren nee

Man · Gedesisteerd1,7K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde, of juister nooit-getransitioneerde, man die mijn hele leven genderdysforie heeft gehad en in mijn late twintiger jaren de diagnose Asperger kreeg. Ondanks dat therapeuten me richting transitie duwden, weigerde ik cross-sekse HRT en een geslachtsaanpassende operatie na tientallen jaren intensieve zelfstudie in theologie, filosofie, psychologie en biologie, waaruit ik concludeerde dat transitie me nooit kon geven wat ik eigenlijk wil: als vrouw geboren zijn. Als tiener had ik kanker en onderging ik als onderdeel van de behandeling een orchidectomie, waarna ik voor testosteron koos in plaats van oestrogeen, en ik heb nu om medische redenen levenslang T-injecties nodig. Ik ben getrouwd met een vrouw, heb een kind en beheer mijn dysforie met therapie, gebed, zelfacceptatie, privé crossdressen en het schrappen van porno, terwijl ik kritisch blijf over wat ik zie als de ideologie achter de transbeweging. Ik ben nooit suïcidaal geweest, en hoewel ik nog dysforie ervaar, vind ik die leefbaar en zie ik mijn toestand als een 'genderidentiteitsstoornis' van de geest en niet als een verkeerd lichaam.

Volledig verhaal

I've felt this way for as long as I can remember — all those nights praying I'd wake up as a girl, all those tears. I was never thrilled with being a boy, and when puberty hit things got much worse: my mental state worsened, I rejected myself, and shame, guilt, and embarrassment set in. I grew up in a religious household, so on top of feeling fundamentally broken I also worried I might be sinful. I heard the Manic Street Preachers song 'Born a Girl' and my melancholy took on an aesthetic character, and I became depressed. I was diagnosed with Asperger's, but only later in life, in my late 20s. I spent decades — at least 30 years — trying to figure out the 'why'. I read psychology, philosophy, and theology, areas where I'm highly academically trained (I have a postgraduate degree in theology, with philosophy as a secondary major). I read up on biology, sexology, intersex conditions, genetics, chromosomes, phenotypes, and the arguments for and against transition. I self-examined to death. I even created a mental split between 'the part of my brain that is dysphoric' and 'the thinking-speaking me', pitting my rational mind against my emotions and desires. I was not an integrated self. I hated myself. Sometimes I still do. That project of abstraction eventually broke down completely, and the dysphoria hit back much harder — that event put me back in therapy for months. I was tested for intersex conditions and I'm not intersex. I considered every possible explanation: environmental factors, birth conditions, genetic or chromosomal abnormality, bad experiences growing up, trauma, the wrong encouragement, a fetish or paraphilia, autogynephilia. I came across Blanchard as a teenager and worried I was some kind of sexual deviant, but I tested the AGP idea carefully and it doesn't describe me — I don't find the thought of myself as a woman arousing, and I don't find crossdressing arousing. My therapists told me I should probably transition. I got into arguments with therapists about choosing not to. Counsellors, therapists, psychologists, pastors — none of them really understood, or if they thought they did, it was only to push transition. Two main things happened. First, I found myself on the wrong side of the narrative, with views declared ignorant, bigoted, transphobic. Second, I had to make the choice to accept who I was and become an integrated whole, or continue down a path that would probably see me in an early grave. I want to transition, but I won't. I have an ideal in my head that will never be realised: to be female. I could transition socially, but when the facade comes off I'll still be me. I could medically transition, but I don't think it'd ever stop — I'd chase surgery after surgery, and for what? To look the part. Transitioning wouldn't get me what I want, which is to have been born female. A huge part of my reasoning is epistemological: how does a brain know its body is 'wrong' if it's the only body it's ever known? My brain has never been female, so it has no idea what it's longing after. I lack first-person knowledge of what it's like to be female. I view my dysphoria as an identity disorder — that's what it was called when I was younger — because it reminds me the problem is my mind, not that I was born in the wrong body, which I consider a nonsensical phrase. When I was a teenager I had cancer, and as part of the treatment I had an orchiectomy performed. There I was, dysphoric in secret, getting a surgery other people in my position long for — I've even heard people say they wish they got cancer just for the orchiectomy, and I think they're idiots. Do you know how much that helped my dysphoria? It didn't — it made it worse. Women's clothing fits better down there, but what's left bothers me even more because it's only partially gone. My body stopped producing testosterone in any meaningful quantity, and I could easily have gone on estrogen. Sometimes, when I'm in a poor mood, I wish I had — I might be miserable but at least my body would somewhat look the part. But I went on testosterone instead. I tried a gel first but absorption was too poor and there were supply issues, so I switched to injections — every ~12 weeks a doctor or nurse administers a rather painful needle, and I absolutely hate it. Before I learned I had low T I had near-constant headaches, brain fog, little energy, no libido, little motivation, couldn't lose weight, and was depressed. My pituitary gland is in bad shape due to the previous health issues. I've noticed by experimenting on myself that I can ease or aggravate my dysphoria relative to how low or high my T level is — my mind is much calmer when my T is low or an injection is delayed. I've spoken with an endocrinologist about what would happen if I stopped T, so that's not a settled question. I hate what T has done to my body, and I know I'll have more trouble as aging takes hold. I've also worked in old-age homes, which was a traumatising experience — I learned the end of life is rarely pretty and saw great people die horrifically. I couldn't imagine myself in that situation while on cross-sex HRT. I still worry about what I'd do if I developed a degenerative brain disease; that terrifies me. What I did instead: I acknowledged who I was to myself and worked to overcome the negative emotions. I cut out porn — it feeds my imagination in the wrong way and reorients my dysphoria into a sexualised, destructive headspace; without it my dysphoria takes on a more aesthetic character. I also cut out anime and similar material. I started eating healthier, exercising, and making my bed. I shave, wax, and epilate — if I don't like where hair is growing, it goes. I have a lot of women's clothing — probably 20 items of women's clothing for every 1 item of men's — and a feminine aesthetic in private: house decorations, computer setup, online profiles, always choosing to play as a girl in games. In public I look like a Stoic Nordic man, and that's something I've chosen to accept. I've told a handful of people, but my family wouldn't be understanding and I value those relationships, so I keep secrets. I've been open online instead. I pray a lot, and I'm starting to think that really did help. Kierkegaard helped me enormously — I read Fear and Trembling, The Sickness Unto Death, and The Concept of Anxiety, and construed my decision to be 'always non-op' as an act of infinite resignation and self-denial. I'm Christian, and my faith matters to me. I'm married to a woman — I spoke a vow I will not break — and we have a child. I went through the adoption process at some point. Intimacy is uncomfortable; it's not like how other people talk about intimacy, but I manage. When we meet other families or go to events it's constant reminders of what I'm not and how I don't fit in. I did the right thing, but it hasn't made life any easier. I often wonder what might have been. I'm still dysphoric, but I've learned to live with it. I don't try to pretend to be someone I'm not. My experience of dysphoria these days is quite intellectual — I still feel it, but I think I have a handle on it. I'm happy to be alive, but not so happy over the mode of my existence. Happiness for me takes on the characteristics of eudaimonia. I've never been suicidal, though I know life is hard. I joke that I play the part of the Stoic Nordic guy, but that Stoicism masks a deep dissatisfaction with life, and a certain kind of rage that in feeling the way I do I've never really been happy even though I should be. I'm still a mess, but I'll be fine in the end — it's just the getting there that's a bit bothersome.