Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/detransitionerende vrouw die zich ongeveer 10 jaar als transseksuele man identificeerde na drie DSM-4-diagnoses van genderidentiteitsstoornis, en ik vraag me nu af of ik eigenlijk een GNC butch lesbienne ben met geïnternaliseerde homofobie of vrouwenhaat in plaats van echte genderdysforie. Ik stopte met testosteron nadat ik waarschijnlijke incontinentie en blaasproblemen kreeg (ik had een volledige hysterectomie gehad) en begon begin 2024 met oestrogeen, terwijl ik ook chronische rugpijn heb door jarenlang binden. Ik kom uit een gelukkig gezin zonder trauma, maar werd erg gepest omdat ik op een jongen leek, en ik werk met een psychiater en psychoanalyticus om mijn verwarring uit te zoeken. Ik sta kritisch tegenover de losse diagnostische criteria van nu, blinde bevestiging en wat ik zie als sociale besmetting in de transbeweging, en ik heb geen contact meer met de LHBT-gemeenschap. Ik heb geen suïcidale gedachten of zelfbeschadiging beschreven.
Volledig verhaal
I've been GNC since I could dress myself — boys' clothes, a boys' haircut, "boys things." I was a confused child; even with good sex education from 5th to 7th grade, I believed I was exempt from female puberty, and when it happened it "messed me up mentally." As a child I held the belief that if I couldn't be male I'd be as close to male as I could, so I acted, dressed and emoted in ways I thought only men could. I remember my parents asking me once if I thought I should've been born a boy; I was afraid of making them angry and said "no." I could never understand why I always imagined myself as a man in my head or saw a man in the mirror — like a female imposter — and why looking like a girl made me panic. I eventually googled what I was feeling and found transsexualism; I didn't know about it until college. I've been transitioning for 10 years and over that span seen three psychiatrists who all diagnosed me with Gender Identity Disorder under the DSM-4. Despite those diagnoses something feels off. I worry I never let myself explore being a GNC woman, since before transition I was always trying to fit myself into what I thought womanhood was. I was bullied constantly as a kid — kids and adults calling me lesbian slurs — because I was a female who looked like a boy. I identify as bisexual but think I might just be a lesbian, and I'm not sure. I joined r/detrans in January 2024 because I'd been experiencing doubts and wanted to see if anyone had a similar story, to find clarity on whether to continue or detransition. I see a psychiatrist but it's hard to find one who will really push back rather than just affirm my transsexualism; I've since been seeing a psychoanalyst to unravel my confusion, which has helped a little. I'm at a crossroads: continue transition, or am I a butch lesbian suffering from severe internalized homophobia? I'm working on not pushing myself into a box — just focusing on the fact I am female and only labeling my sex and sexual orientation, not how I act or present. I planned to start estrogen HRT in January 2024 to try to alleviate another medical condition that might be caused by my body's response to testosterone, and to use that time to try to embrace womanhood as a GNC lesbian. I've had a full hysterectomy. I might have developed incontinence because of testosterone; localized estrogen hasn't helped my bladder symptoms, and by March 2024 the bladder issues were impacting my life severely. Binding has also caused me back pain — I followed all the binding rules and now can't even wear a loose sports bra without intense pain, and I'm doing physical therapy for it. I'm 5'2" and dislike being small. I believe gender dysphoria is a real mental condition and that transitioning is so far the only treatment, but I think the diagnostic criteria have become too relaxed in the DSM-5, that doctors affirm too quickly without addressing other mental health issues, and that cisgender GNC people are too often convinced they're trans. I distinguish between "transsexuals" (true clinical GID) and "transgender" (those who aren't actually trans or are AGP), and I've criticized social contagion via TikTok, people being coached on what to say to get a diagnosis, and a "pissing contest" in the LGBT community over who's suffered most — one reason I no longer associate with the LGBT community. I've also noted anti-cis/straight sentiment in the community as an influence. I'm still trying to figure out whether what I've experienced is actual gender dysphoria or internalized misogyny mixed with an extreme form of body dysmorphia, and I've described a strange anxiety or paranoia that maybe I was a "butch lesbian who's been twisted and warped." I came from a happy, healthy household and experienced no trauma, yet I can't deny the distorted emotional and mental thoughts and feelings I have toward my sex characteristics. I don't believe in souls, so "born in the wrong body" doesn't exist for me — it's a mental disorder, confusing and painful. I think HRT caused awful side effects not adequately covered in informed consent, and I've said detransitioners are often silenced by the trans community. I'm still working with my shrink to figure it all out and feel like the solution is on the tip of my tongue.