Alle verhalen

Jaren op Tumblr, toen een kerk, en toen kwam de dysforie terug

Vrouw · Gedesisteerd1,4K
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die zich jarenlang als non-binair identificeerde, vooral online via Tumblr, maar nooit medisch is getransitioneerd. Mijn dysforie en non-binaire identificatie verdwenen toen ik me bekeerde tot het christendom, al kreeg ik begin 2023 een flinke terugval van dysforie die ik in therapie verwerk. Ik heb dissociatieve symptomen waarvoor ik een DIS-diagnose zoek, autisme, complex trauma en geïnternaliseerde vrouwenhaat geworteld in kinderlijke genderrollen, pesten en gewichtsproblemen. Ik blijf kritisch op genderbevestigende zorg en wat ik zie als pseudowetenschap in trans-activisme, terwijl ik me ook verzet tegen extreme anti-transclaims in detrans-ruimtes. Ik ga nu om met resterende lichaamshaat en eenzaamheid, met sport en therapie in plaats van transitie te overwegen.

Volledig verhaal

I was born female. I first started feeling something I later called dysphoria when I was a child — not a strong, dramatic feeling, but a persistent numbness in the background, which I compared to the numbness people with depression describe rather than a full episode. I would get upset at the thought of being female, but I figured I could live the rest of my life closeted from most people I knew. Thinking about my gender identity for too long made me feel confused and distressed because I'd feel nothing. I never wanted to transition; the closest I came to that was wanting to sterilize myself. Growing up I was put into a lot of gender roles I didn't like. I didn't want to raise children or wear girly clothes — I wanted to wear comfortable things and play video games. I viewed girly girls as inferior and boys as better; the typical "I'm not like other girls" girl. I eventually grew out of putting other girls down but I still felt a disconnect with my gender. I never had feelings of being a boy, so I never identified as a trans boy, but when I learned about nonbinary I thought, "oh you can just... do that? not be either gender? cool." Most of my exposure to the trans community was through Tumblr, where I "realized" I was nonbinary after learning I didn't have to be "either gender." I was also tolerant of xenogenders like stargender because I thought every experience was valid, though I had questions about what it even meant to be a ___ gender. I changed my pronouns and came out to a few friends, but I never physically transitioned — no hormones, no surgeries. Most of it was psychological. I was closeted to my family: my brother had talked about how stupid nonbinary genders were so I never came out to him, and the one time I told my mom about transitioning I wasn't "really there"/dissociated and she thought it was "the voices" telling me it, so I never brought it up again. My mother was an agnostic liberal who never believed gender was a social construct, which is why I never came out to her about being nonbinary. Alongside this I was dealing with dissociation. During a bad time in my life I started experiencing derealization — my surroundings felt fake, life passing by like a dream. Months went by and I got a voice in my head insulting me. At first I thought it was depression, then schizophrenia, then the voice took control of my body — it started cutting my body and insulting my friends. At first I called it "It," but they were insulted by that so they chose a different name. They claimed to be a genderless, immortal shapeshifting demon — genderless because they thought they were a demon, not because of exposure to trans things. More people eventually popped up in my head, all with different forms and different genders: a lot male, some nonbinary, a few female. I looked up DID and asked my mother to get diagnosed, only to have medical professionals say the disorder was rare or that I had psychotic symptoms instead. For a while I gave up, denying it came from trauma because I had no memory of trauma below a certain age. But the alters caused me to be very dysfunctional because of constant fighting and abuse amongst each other, so I concluded I might be disordered and that I actually had gaps in my memory about my home life. For the last two years or so I'd talked to my therapist about it — he'd been helpful, helping me find a diagnosis, not trying to invalidate us. I also had traits of maladaptive daydreaming, though my daydreaming was never disruptive enough to interfere with daily life, unlike my alters. When I converted to Christianity, my gender dysphoria went away. I actually felt like my birth gender — it felt as if a fog had been lifted from my head. I also had no more desire to dress and androgynously, or to sterilize myself. It wasn't something I read in the Bible that convinced me; it just went away when I was born again. Poof — I don't feel nonbinary anymore, I feel like a woman. I try to read the Bible every day (though I'm not always successful), go to church every Sunday when able, and sometimes look up verses or ask others when I don't understand something. I've reflected a lot on what led me here. I think gender stuff can be one way to find temporary meaning if you had none before, or something to fill the void or relieve suffering — religion tends to fill that gap. I think there's the glamor of identifying as something that sounds cool and spectacular, and then the appeal of trying to distance yourself from who you are, especially if what you are causes distress; identifying as something else can form as a way of escapism. I've wondered whether my gender was just a result of my dissociation — maybe thinking I was nonbinary wasn't much different than another person in my brain thinking they were a demon, maybe I was just dissociating from my body because I didn't want to be regarded as female anymore. I'm also just one of them, an alter, so who knows if my gender could have been something my brain did to dissociate from bad associations with femaleness. I also realized the gender roles thing goes deeper than I thought. As a small child I was bombarded with what I was expected to be — to have and love children, to have a husband with all the authority over me, to like really girly things like Barbies when I just wanted to play video games. I couldn't connect much to other girls and would rather talk to boys because I was more similar to them, but I got rejected a lot anyway for being a girl. Even when I was bullied in middle school I got made fun of and demeaned for being ugly and fat, and even after getting out of it I thought I was worthless because I wasn't this hot girl or desirable — I actually used to think I was worthless because no guy wanted to date me. I'm autistic: I can't socialize properly, I have a hard time talking and relating to people in general as well as girls, I tend to have special interests and hyperfocus on very specific things which is more common in men. That's why the nonbinary thing should have never happened — I shouldn't have tried to convince myself of something because I felt I was too different to be a woman. I know it was mostly Tumblr that led me to believe it, but I can't even blame that; me and the other people there were just dumb teenagers trying to make sense of ourselves. I don't want to be genderless. I just want to be me, to act however I want without some gendered expectation of me. Even now it hurts to say "I'm a woman" — but it's what I am. In the end I'm just a woman. I also came to a realization I called "Gender Reality." Some years ago I dated a straight man online — he heard my voice, and I later came out to him as nonbinary and he didn't care, but he would insist he was not attracted to men. I've been in areas of my life where I'd suddenly get attention despite being shy — attention from men but also from nonbinary people who were male. I concluded that no matter what I said I was, nature would win out in the end; my sexual characteristics — my voice, my body — would win out because those are what people are biologically programmed to be attracted to. I was too attached to who I felt I was inside and ignored that my body would be how people would see me. I know this wasn't entirely organic and was the result of interacting with online trans people. Ever since I stopped feeding into this delusion I've actually felt happier — happier that I wouldn't have to deal with the inside vs. outside conflict anymore. Telling people has been difficult. After I said I was no longer nonbinary, some friends told me I was just "suppressing who I am" because of my religion, even though I told them I felt better than before. I even got laughed at in a server I was briefly in when I said becoming Christian cured my dysphoria. People have told me I just had internalized transphobia, which sucks because I deal with second-guessing myself a lot. I've had some trans people accept me though, and I'm still friends with some of my online trans friends. I've told anyone who says I have internalized transphobia to cut it out and reinstated that I no longer feel gender dysphoria — I don't have the patience to deal with that. One friend, after I desisted and converted, thought it was due to internalized transphobia from an evangelical upbringing, but my family was never really religious — going to church was a cultural thing, and any talk about church had ended by the time my parents separated. I still deal with complex trauma and internalized misogyny and am trying to reintegrate into "womanhood" in a way I feel comfortable with. I took different approaches out of fear of being revictimized — I started working out and considered taking martial arts. I lost a lot of weight and feel happier with it, but at the same time have wanted to "hide" myself again; there have been times I felt scared of having my face seen so I'd go outside with my hood up, and I still wear mostly androgynous clothing because I feel my body doesn't look good in feminine clothing. I grew up obese in part due to parental neglect, but I lost the weight because I didn't want to die sooner. I still want a better body, and the best I can do without HRT is lifting weights and dieting. Then in early March 2023 I broke down. The desire to become male had become overwhelming — I ended up crying, disgusted not at wanting to be a man but at desiring something impossible. I couldn't talk myself out of it or into being a woman. I lost sleep and couldn't concentrate; all I could focus on was hatred of being a woman and thinking I'd finally be happy if I were a man. It felt alluring, almost seductive. I didn't think I was "truly" trans — telling myself it's mental illness or trauma did nothing. I published the post a week later in case it went away. I talked to my therapist and my boyfriend; I felt much calmer, though the two weeks were filled with rumination. I think my dysphoria goes farther than just trauma or social contagion — I wonder about the possibility of it being neurological. I still don't want to transition because I don't want to be a patient forever, but I'm also scared of relapsing into worse coping mechanisms. In therapy for trauma, my therapist doesn't want to push me in any direction, only to help me stop feeling guilt over the thoughts, but she also says it's okay if I want to be a different gender. People I trust suggest LGBT support groups. If there was a therapy for dysphoria that wasn't gender affirming care I'd take it. When I see my face, body, or think about my voice I feel tempted to transition, but it's not really rational; in the end I'll probably just do my own research. I can make myself look like an attractive woman if I try hard enough, but even then it doesn't feel "right" — I'm too obsessed with wanting my face shape more masculine and my body shape less curvy. At least in my teenage years I could attribute my dysmorphia to being overweight. I've thought about what would have been different without the internet: I think had I grown up without the internet, I would have been cis and heterosexual. I've also felt sad that an irl friend I'd come out to started questioning being nonbinary shortly after I stopped identifying that way, feeling as if I'd influenced them in that direction. Currently I still sometimes feel uncomfortable and "dysphoric" at times — it's more a generalized hatred of my body than just genitals. When it happens I stop obsessing over my body for a bit and focus on something else. I still have dissociated "parts" of me that hold stronger anger than I do and hate my body, but I feel they'll let go of it in time. I'm lonely — I'm unable to connect with either men or women because I expect rejection, and the only people I end up talking to are trans because it's all I really know how to do. I'd have no idea where to meet detransitioners in real life, and even if I did I couldn't relate much because I haven't physically transitioned. Last time I tried a lesbian event I was publicly embarrassed by a friend. I'm bi. I still wear mostly androgynous clothing. I've only cosplayed once, as a female character (the RSE version of May around when ORAS came out), and considered cosplaying Crona from Soul Eater. I'm critical of how transition is promoted for others. I've said I can't really help but be angry at the introduction of pseudoscience into the field of actual science — believing trans brains exist, or thinking trans kids must transition and they'll be a perfect biological male/female as if human bodies were puzzle blocks. I hope it reaches a breaking point where the madness stops and affected kids and families get compensation. I object to "trans" science presuming that what makes us male or female is our genitals and that surgery can replace them, ignoring that sex is interwoven into DNA/biological programming; HRT/surgery doesn't override that biological programming, which I say also debunks the "trans brain" argument. I've been skeptical of the definition of pansexuality — attraction regardless of gender — because I don't think sexual characteristics can simply be ignored. I think most of the current trans phenomenon is due to social contagion, but not all cases. I don't believe being trans is by itself a delusion, since trans people are aware their sex doesn't line up with what's in their head, though being trans could be the result of a mental illness in some cases. I've pushed back against posts in the detrans community suggesting transitioning leads to school shootings, feeling betrayed and saying it feels more like a place for people to point fingers at trans people than an actual place for detransitioners. I've advised people being harassed to block and report and not give emotional labor. I think too many people overlook that the country or area you live in might affect the care you get, and I've encouraged someone embarrassed to bring their concerns up to a therapist.