Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben als vrouw geboren en identificeerde me als tiener als transman, deels door een slechte relatie met mijn moeder, een gebrek aan vrouwelijke rolmodellen en een vrouwenhatende cultuur die me deed denken dat ik geen vrouw was als ik niet in het vrouwelijke keurslijf paste. Ik desisteerde op mijn 19e en identificeer me nu als gendernonconformistische vrouw; ik beschrijf niet dat ik hormonen heb genomen of operaties heb gehad. Ik definieer gender nu als een geleefde, aan geslacht gebonden ervaring, gevormd door het vrouwenhaat waarmee vrouwen vanaf de geboorte te maken krijgen, en ik ben kritisch over transitie, vooral voor jongeren met twijfels. Ik heb momenteel een gendernonconformistische vriend, voel me zelfverzekerd over mijn uiterlijk en hoe ik mezelf uit, en adviseer anderen actief om T te vermijden en in plaats daarvan therapie te zoeken. Ik blijf een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die openlijk kritisch is over wat ik transgenderideologie noem.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and grew up in an Italian family; I was bullied as a kid for the dark hair on my upper lip. Looking back, I can see that my relationship with my mother was bad, and that I never really had positive female role models in my life. I was only ever presented with one way to be a woman, so when I didn't fit into that definition, I assumed I wasn't a woman at all. That assumption is what pushed me to identify as a trans man for a time.
I now describe myself as a desisted female — a gender non-conforming woman. I never mention having taken hormones or had surgery; in fact, when I advise others I tell them to stop T before starting it, which suggests I did not go down the medical route myself, though I don't state that explicitly. By February 2020, at 19, I had desisted and posted publicly about loving the way I look and express myself, while hating that my masculine presentation makes everyone assume I'm trans or non-binary. It took me a really long time to become confident in that stance.
What led me toward identifying as trans, in my own reading of it, was a combination of factors: a bad relationship with my mother, the absence of female role models, and a misogynistic society that tells young girls that if they don't dress and act the way is expected of girls, they aren't girls at all. I came to believe that the idea of simply being gender non-conforming had been thrown out the window — that if you do 'boy things,' you must actually be a boy, because real girls only do 'girl things.' I now reject that entirely: the activities you enjoy and the clothes you want to wear don't define your gender, and 'boy things' and 'girl things' are just meaningless stereotypes. I also believe brain gender is a myth, and that if you weren't born with ambiguous genitals you probably aren't intersex.
I don't recall any specific therapy that helped me detransition; instead I recall that when I identified as trans, my mother trying to dissuade me only made me more insistent, and I tell other parents that their child will have to figure it out themselves and may have to 'learn the hard way.' My own shift seems to have come through time, reflection, and reading gender-critical feminist analysis. I now define gender as a lived experience tied to sex — for women that means facing prejudice from the day you're born. I wasn't able to escape my oppression by identifying as male, and I argue that trans women have no idea what it is to face real misogyny. I acknowledge it's bleak to define gender by the way the world sees us and how they oppress us, but I think it's an important distinction.
I have not described any specific mental health diagnoses, but I do frame my past state in terms of trauma and dysphoria: I advise others to find a therapist to work through their trauma, and I wish people would recognize therapy as an option for treating gender dysphoria. I also encourage people not to start T if they have any doubts, and to be gender non-conforming instead.
On sexuality and relationships, I currently have a boyfriend whom I describe as 'a very lovely GNC boyfriend who's had his own struggles with gender expectations.' I don't describe any internalised homophobia, and I don't describe a specific sexuality label.
I don't express intense regret about medical interventions because I don't describe having had any. What I do express frustration about is how my masculine self-expression is read by others: I love the way I look and express myself, but I hate that it makes everyone think I'm trans or non-binary. I posted that sentiment publicly and it resonated widely (786 points). I also posted about what I see as inappropriate 'trans infiltration' of detransition spaces, arguing that people who have happily transitioned can't understand what we've been through and that TRAs turn personal stories into debates in order to silence us.
My attitude toward transition for other people is critical and conditional. I tell people not to 'fuck up your body' with T if they have any doubts, I advise stopping T and getting therapy, I recommend researching gender critical feminism and the recent surge in ftm individuals, and I tell people it's okay to present as masculine as they want and still be a woman — there is no right or wrong way to be female. I also tell women not to start wearing makeup just because that's what women are expected to do and not to feel pressured to perform femininity. I've offered to DM with people who have questions and describe myself openly as 'a desisted ftmtf.' I've also argued that the higher-success-rate-than-marriage claim for transition is based on old statistics and that, with the recent 'transgender explosion' and far fewer boundaries on medical transition for young people, there will inevitably be a larger number of individuals who change their minds, probably at a larger rate as well.
As of my most recent activity in July 2020, I was living as a gender non-conforming woman, in a relationship with a GNC boyfriend, confident in my presentation, and actively supportive of others considering or undergoing detransition.